Ways to minimize the massive taxation rate on my bonus?

Taxes

Hi Everyone,

I recently accepted a position where I will be making a substantial amount of income from an annual bonus. In summary, my base will be 150k and my target annual bonus is 125k.

My understanding is that bonuses are taxed as supplemental income, and the current federal supplemental income tax rate is 22%. However, both New York State and City have their own supplemental tax rates of 13.78% and 4.25%.

So basically, I’ll be paying a total tax rate of 40.03% on my bonus, which obviously sucks.

My question is, are there ways to minimize the amount I owe on this amount. For instance, is it allowed and possible to pull all of my 401k and IRA contributions from my bonus? Can I pay my medical, dental, and vision taxes from my bonus for the previous years out of my bonus?

Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated!

Posted Nov 26, 2021, 5:09 PM UTC

021
ronnevee​•

Bonus pay is taxed just like any other income. Even if it is withheld at the supplemental rate, that is just withholding. Not final taxes. So it makes no tax difference if you contribute to your 401k from the bonus check or not. All that matters for actual taxes is you total year end income. So, lower year end income lowers taxes, but it makes no difference if those contributions came from the bonus check or not.

19
MarcableFluke​•

Bonuses aren't taxed at a higher rate, but they are generally withheld at one.

For instance, is it allowed and possible to pull all of my 401k and IRA contributions from my bonus?

Whether you max out your 401k through paycheck contributions or your bonus, your tax liability doesn't change.

12
WhenIntegralsAttackOP​•

So the withholding rate is 40%, and this is just the amount that my employer will pay directly to the government. The remaining 60% is what I will receive, and then I have to pay income tax on top of that? Sorry, I’m just a bit confused as to the difference between withholding and taxation.

1
ThunderDrop​•

Withholding is a guess at what your tax responsibility is. Withholding is not final.

A portion of each paycheck and bonus check are "withheld" or given to the government as that is a guess at the taxes you owe.

When you file your tax return in April, you sit down and do the math and tell the government how much you SHOULD have paid based on ALL your income and other variables.

If your math comes out that you didn't withhold enough, you mail in a check.

If your math shows too much was withheld, the government mails you a check.

Withholding is not your final tax bill. You may well get some of it back, particularly if you load up tax advantaged accounts such as a 401k.

9
fixin2wander​•

No, the 40% is what your employer will pay the government and then at the end of the year you will get back anything over paid (for example, if your max tax rate is 25% then you get 15% back). This is over simplifying it but basically you just need to know it isn't actually TAXED at a higher rate than the rest of your income, it is just WITHHELD at a higher rate.

5
WhenIntegralsAttackOP​•

That makes sense now. So then is my bonus added on top of my base salary and then I determine which portions of my total income fall into which tax brackets when I pay taxes?

3
fixin2wander​•

Yeah, I mean you don't break it out by what comes from where. You just end up with a total owed and they look at how much you already paid, but the basic idea is correct. Don't worry, it will all even out in the end!

4
texanchris​•

No, it’s just withheld at the higher rate but will be a refund when you file taxes if you’re due a refund.

4
MarcableFluke​•

Withholdings is what is taken out of your check and is just an estimate of your taxes. Your tax liability is calculated at the end of you year based on your income, deductions and credits. If your withholdings are higher than your liability, you're owed a refund. If it's lower, you owe them more.

Think of it like paying for groceries with cash. Your grocery bill is $75 (tax liability) and you give them $100 (withholdings). They give you back $25 in change (tax refund).

2
shadow_chance​•

Withholding is a semi-reasonable estimate of your tax liability based on your income and choices you made on your W4.

Your tax liability is what you actually owe according to tax law set by Congress and enforced by the IRS. Your total liability can't be known exactly until the end of the year.

1
SwAeromotion​•

If you are making $275K for the year and are single, a federal withholding of 22% is going to be too low on that bonus as you are in one of the 3X% marginal brackets.

If you are married and the only earner, then 22% is going to be close to the correct federal withholding, maybe just a slight under withhold.

I would call your payroll to verify that they will withhold at 22%.

7
WhenIntegralsAttackOP​•

From what I’m reading, the federal withholding rate is a flat 22% for any bonuses under a million. Is that incorrect?

1
SwAeromotion​•

It's probably correct, but I don't know the answer specifically.. I am a pedantic individual and would do my due diligence just to make sure, though.

The issue that I see is that if you are single, 22% for federal is going to be too low.

3
Its-a-write-off​•

That's withholding on a check outside of payroll dates, yes.

But your actual marginal tax rate could be 35%, so that would mean not enough taxes are being taken out to cover your actual liability.

3
doktorhladnjak​•

It’s 22% on the first million for the year, then 37% on everything above that.

However, employers usually have the option of withholding for the bonus as if it were ordinary wages too, in which case it almost certainly will be withheld at 37%. You’d need to ask the employer what they do and if they offer any options for the withholding (unlikely but possible).

2
stefand2010​•

Doesn't the tax get trued up come tax time?

2
wrldruler21​•

OP, I understand what others are saying.... Withholding vs Taxing so I deleted my previous post.

It is very true that your bonus will come into your account 40% less. So plan on that.

But when you get your W2, the bonus and salary will be mixed together into one number. So when you do your taxes, the IRS will treat bonus the same as regular income.

So it's not like there is a place on the 1040 tax form which says "Put bonus amount here so we can hit you with a 40% tax".

The bonus over-withholding may cause a tax refund, or you can reduce the withholding taken out of your normal paycheck

2
vynm2​•

You may already understand withholding by now, but it's basically pre-payment of what you'll owe when you file your tax return. Withholding on your "regular" W-2 income is an estimate based on the amount of your paychecks and the info you provided to your employer on your W-4 form, and withholding on your bonus is done assuming that your bonus will fall in the 22% tax bracket (hence the 22% rate).

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1†
ronnevee​•

You've been getting a bonus for 15 years and still think it is taxed at a different rate then other income?

All that is different is withholding. The estimated taxes taken out. That all gets trued up at tax time though. Someone that gets a 100k bonus in January and no other pay all year pays the same tax as someone that earned 100k evenly all year long.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
WhenIntegralsAttackOP​•

So can I make 401k and IRA contributions out of my bonus?

3
ronnevee​•

It doesn't matter. Bonus pay is not taxed any different then other pay. It is only withheld differently.

Does your bonus come as part of you regular check? Or a separate check?

What is your normal weekly pay? How much is the bonus for? Are you single or married/

6