Is Piano or Guitar more intuitive to you?
Hey all, this is obviously a hugely subjective question, so I'm just curious.
I've been teaching myself both for about a year and a half, and in the beginning I found piano far more intuitive in its layout, but recently I think I've seen guitar as more intuitive.
This is coming from a jazz perspective I guess, but connections between scales and chords across keys is far easier for me to visualize on guitar than it is on piano. If you asked me to play Ab altered or Gb harmonic minor on piano it would be really tough to figure out on the fly, but all you need on guitar is to know the alterations and root note and you can figure it out in the middle of a solo.
Additionally, moving between scales is super easy, like if I'm in a C major tonality and I want to make it brighter I just move everything up a string and two frets, and I'm effectively in C lydian. If I want to play the secondary dominant of some chord I just play the fourth below the incoming chord. All that stuff is much easier to see on guitar I think. It's not difficult to figure out on piano, but I find myself skipping around in bigger intervals and sounding worse.
I still think melodic countour and chord voicings are a little easier to conceptualize on the piano, but root shell pretty stuff is pretty simple on guitar too. Chromatic enclosures are more intuitive, arpeggios to a certain extent, and even intervals. It just feels easier to grab the notes I want on guitar.
I'm finding that having to memorize scales on piano makes me want to play it a bit less recently, but I still find it really fun. I especially like how piano has a bit more of an ability to do solo stuff, and it's emphasis on voice leading is very good as well.
What are your guys' thoughts?
Posted Nov 30, 2021, 3:54 AM UTC
This is a great question and I think both have great benefits! One of the things that’s best about the piano is that you can only play each note in an octave in one place. It can be very easy to visualize chord construction, orchestration, and voice leading this way as well as how harmony and melody interact.
On the other hand guitar (and other instruments tuned at regular intervals) are very helpful for recognizing patterns. Once you learn one pattern for a scale or chord (or several variations on that pattern) you can usually play it in any key without much thought. Compare that to a piano where you have to learn a new tactile pattern each time you want to learn a scale in a different key. In short, both have great benefits and being able to play one or both can really help develop you as a musician!
This is a good point. The guitar comes close to having that sort of octave equivalence, but the B string screws it up.
If the B string were tuned to C and the high E string to F so it was all stacked perfect 4ths, we would have octave equivalence similar to a piano, except that you would have to shift up 2 frets with each higher octave. And, lots of the open chords would be much harder to play.
You might say that one odd-ball B string is in some ways like the missing black keys (natural half steps B-C and E-F) on the piano, in breaking what would otherwise be a logical pattern.
A P5 on guitar usually means up one string and up 2 frets, unless the upper string is the B string in which case go up 3 frets instead.
A P5 on piano usually means go up 4 white keys, or to the black keys just above or below that spacing, unless the P5 comprises both of the natural half steps, then span one more half step.
But since the piano has 2 anomalies instead of 1, and more importantly because those anomalies repeat with the octave as opposed to being defined on the instrument, a pattern emerges that defines the octave physically within the instrument's design, unlike on the guitar where even without the B-string anomaly it could only be applied to the instrument as there is nothing about the arrangement of the strings that does suggest the octave.
Mid-range notes on the guitar can have so many extra places you play each note. This is obviously super useful for creating new patterns for solos and lead playing, but isn’t great if you’re trying to learn about voice leading. It can be super confusing understanding how chords resolve when you can’t visually see notes spreading out or smushing together. I think that’s really what advantage the piano gives is seeing how harmony progresses and how texture and register change as a result of the chords and voicings you choose!
Agreed - voice leading as a concept clearly did not have the guitar in mind. A guitar playing one note at a time could be treated as one of those voices, much like a monophonic instrument, but trying to translate different voices onto a single polyphonic instrument doesn't work on guitar nearly as well as it does on piano.
Resolution as well - if I play D7 resolving to G on guitar using movable chords, from the D7 with the root on the 5th fret of the A string down to G with the root on the 3rd fret of the low E string, it is not at all obvious that the F# (7th fret of the B string in the D7 chord) resolves to the G (3rd fret of the high E string in the G chord) because it switches strings.
As for seeing how harmony progresses though, that's where the guitar becomes more intuitive, for me at least. To play a ii-V-I progression in C major on the piano you just play all of the white notes with no regard to which chords are minor or major. The guitar forces you to become intimately familiar with the pattern: I ii iii IV V vi viidim, or IM7 iim7 iiim7 IVM7 V7 vim7 viim7b5 if you are using 7th chords.
The piano certainly has more options for voicings and textures than the guitar does, but I see that as a result of what is effectively a higher level of polyphony on the piano. It's versitility and intuitiveness are different things though. IMO the guitar is more intuitive in understanding intervals and chord construction, while the piano is far more intuitive in understanding how we read music.
That’s interesting! I have formal training on both guitar and piano although I have quite a bit more on guitar. I’ve found for myself that piano makes much more sense in terms of chords and understanding harmony. I will admit though that I was never much into playing chordal guitar and just wanted to shred when possible so that’s probably why!
The problem is that most people play guitar on standard — thus irregular — tuning, so the fretboard patterns doesn’t actually move across. Everyone knows how to play the C chord, but there isn’t a simple way to shift it all a semitone up or down; a D chord is entirely different fingering (and forms from a different blend of tones).
(On the other hand, regularly tuned - M3 for example - is a joy to do these chord construction/visualizations in. It’s such pain, however, to unlearn the fretting hand, and few things in the standard repertoire carry over :( )
Sorry, I didn’t mean entirely regularly tuned instruments, just ones like guitar where you can move shapes and patterns up and down. Once you learn one pattern you can do it in pretty much any key. Barred chords take care of some of the chord pattern problems (as well as a capo), but aren’t super fun to play. That B string has always been a bit annoying to work around!