Nat. Org. on Fetal Alcohol Syndrome: Emily Oster’s Advice is Deeply Flawed and Harmful
I regularly see people on this sub pointing Redditors at Emily Oster's Expecting Better and Cribsheet. Please, please read this note from the National Organization on Fetal Alcohol Syndrome before you do:
Emily Oster’s Alcohol and Pregnancy Advice is Deeply Flawed and Harmful
You can also find statistics supporting NOFAS's comments here: https://depts.washington.edu/fasdpn/pdfs/astley-oster2013.pdf .
To quote the article summary:
- She cherry picks studies and ignores the research showing light drinking to be associated with miscarriage, stillbirth, preterm delivery, spontaneous abortion, and sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS).
- If Emily Oster wants to tolerate the risk of alcohol on her own baby, that’s her choice, but she has no right to advise pregnant women to expose their unborn baby to even a small amount of a substance that can cause brain damage.
- She is clearly less concerned with protecting the health of newborns than she is with protecting expectant mothers from health messages she deems bothersome.
I am not an expert on all the topics covered by Cribsheet. (Noone is.) But in the areas where I know the literature, I would make the exact same criticisms; Oster has only read a handful of studies, and always uses them to push a specific agenda, namely that you can do whatever you like and it won't affect your child.
In some cases, especially where alcohol is concerned, it's likely that Oster's advice has done real damage to children. Please, please stop pointing people at it.
Posted Dec 3, 2021, 1:00 PM UTC