wiz-R-YOPLKMT Song Qingling Gang•

R5: After a long time, I played Manchu restoration path again. The gameplay is just fire, wars kept emerging themselves between 1937 and 1943. But you could easily rose 96 divisions in 1937, so the enemies just threw themselves into destruction.

Firstly the warlords were taken between 1938-1939, then Fengtian fell in 1939, and then Japanese fell in 1940. The rest of concessions and territories were reclaimed before 1941, and I spent the next 2 years building level 10 roads and civil factories.

​

Eventually, the YCP - Yan Xishan path gives me +15% construction speed, +15% division organization, +10% morale recovery, +10% army speed, and +25% production cap. This is the strongest buff I have seen so far, better than any buff of Fengtian and LKMT.

​

I sincerely suggests everyone tries the Manchu restoration path!

112
P1neapple_1•

Too bad its not real democracy

70
wiz-R-YOPLKMT Song Qingling Gang•

Lore wise, the democracy is a fragile balance between the Manchu nobles, baoding officers, and high level intellectuals. True democracy like LKMT or federalists were off the table for them.

But still, had those 3 factions could enforce democracy into future (and even gaining a new tree after second election), Qing would be a tag matching LKMT or Fengtian.

64
P1neapple_1•

wouldve been great if they got a post-unification tree that could shape democracy for the future, i.e. keeping the status quo, expand democratic institutions or concentrating more power in one of the factions or even the emperor, and some foreign policy stuff, like claiming outer manchuria, dominating south-east asia and an alliance with the PRF or something

51
wiz-R-YOPLKMT Song Qingling Gang•

Yes, Fengtian had post unification tree about internal affairs (dealing with federalists/ dealing with Japanese influence), and LKMT could establish east asian revolutionary league. The fact that Qing, as the former master of east and south east Asia, got no content post unification, is quite disturbing. Whether Wu Peifu/Puyi would restore real democracy, or will they switched back into autocracy, and how they could use the Qing claim to secure the exterior/ how could they really made this 'fake Zhili Republic' into a real thing, would be quite funny to play. But little attention was given to this thing who is always merely a 'final boss' for LKMT , federalists and Fengtian.

37
Chiron29Discord & Reddit Moderator•

Whoever takes over suspends elections by the time the first real election is supposed to happen.

None of them are democratic

34
[deleted]•

The Manchu Party and YCP are insanely elitists, no way they would ever instate democracy

24
ER4OFDEMONSIstanbul Pact•

Guangdong Federalist path: Am I a joke to you?

23
P1neapple_1•

i was refering specifically to the qing "democratic" paths, but yes, federalists are pretty cool dudes ngl

18
wiz-R-YOPLKMT Song Qingling Gang•

As the meme shows, Federalists do not have 'the warlord' part.

Also UPC could not claim / core Mongolia and tibet in my memory.

6
ER4OFDEMONSIstanbul Pact•

Manchu Restoration = I have no foresight how they'll fare due to not knowing why Qing collapsed lmao.

Btw main reason was Han Chinese hating Manchu dominance. Qing China had never ending revolts. Qing lagging behind the world, empty treasury and incompetent armed forced were only the consequence of Han Chinese neither supporting nor complying to the Qing Dynasty.

61
angry-mustacheSid McMath•

Minority rule is based actually, if there is no manpower penalty modifier that means there's no racism

t. KR players

50
ER4OFDEMONSIstanbul Pact•

Hey mate,

Don't forget that Chinese militias opened the graves of founders of Qing after the rebellion. If u want a more objective and authentic perspective on the issue, watch the movie "The Last Emperor", talking about the life of Puyi.

16
ArgentinoRoninE V E R Y M A N A C A R L E S•

The Manchu Restoration isnt minority rule (except maybe with the Manchu Party which is mostly made up by nobles), it's basically the Meiji Restoration if you take the YCP Path, a new modernized and strong China that can protect and provide for it's people is really all you need to ensure that the populace will support the regime, the other options like the NCERA heavily seek to upfilt the chinese peasant, while imo its not the best path to take (because industry is what China should really be focusing on hard) its still better than others since it will help the common man and maybe develop on from there. As for the Manchu Party, they really are kind of shitty, they would make China generally strong and more modern but their rule lacks legitimacy, I actually think they might be the most likely to eventually put some form of democracy to raise their own legitimacy.

20
WanderingPenitentMediterranean League•

This is why, even though I know it's not realistic, I wish there was a path to bring back the less unpopular (by comparison) Ming dynasty.

6
IvantheGreat66•

A Ming restoration was discussed, and there was a heir with two young boys as kids.

1
SkellyManDanCairo Pact Stronk•

There’s something wild about China coming out of the Century of Humiliation still having a Qing emperor.

It’s like despite an entire country’s best efforts, you just can’t get rid of them.

26
agentpippInterdimensional Habsburg Empire•

It is quite fitting for the KR vibe. The old monarchies holding on to power despite opposition at every turn, with the 20th century possibly seeing surviving Ottoman, German, Austro-Hungarian, Chinese, Russian and even French monarchies.

29
wiz-R-YOPLKMT Song Qingling Gang•

In the case, the emperor was merely a puppet under field Marshall Yan Xishan and his Baoding officers, the empire is quite 'Chinese'. Best Puyi can do is sitting there and attending Chinese year ceremonies. Actually, China already got rid of the emperor once, the life of Beiyang simply was a chaos tho. In our timeline, R-KMT and CCP built up a central government. In this timeline, the Baoding officers built it.

And in case of the Kaiserreich timeline, Germany brought strong legitimacy towards monarchy. Even the republicans still got popular support, a constitutional monarchy in case of YCP or NCERA would surely shut most mouths.

8
Ryousan82Argentum Legio•

Republican Larper < Manchu Restoration Enjoyer

19
Kinesra93Communard Soldier•

Kemalist China !

16
ER4OFDEMONSIstanbul Pact•

Please learn Turkish history first before hating Kemalism, where Turks' only alternative was reactionary clusterfuck if they dropped it. They tried in 97 and finally did it in 2002, now Turkey is choking under it.

-10
ArgentinoRoninE V E R Y M A N A C A R L E S•

He wasnt hating on it though?

2
ER4OFDEMONSIstanbul Pact•

lol he gave it as a comparison to Qing China's "fake democracy", which is narrow-minded to say the least.

1
ChimpcookieLeague of Thirty-Eight Provinces•

A restoration that nationalizes Yan Xishan thought is good and all, but I still think Hu Shih's Beijing government is a strong contender for strongest China.

9
wiz-R-YOPLKMT Song Qingling Gang•

Hi shih had -10% consumer good, but that would be kinda about it. Hu's military would be weak somehow, as the zhili Marshalls had 'old guard' traits and would not evolve nicely.

And hu shih could not annex minor zhili warlords, which gave less division caps. Yes, hu shih got 2 industrial focus trees (zhili reform and republican investment), but you just don't have enough time to complete the trees. You must prepare for the Fengtian invasion in 1938, so you must complete the military reform and zhili reconstruction trees. Then while you are struggling for republican built up, Zhang and Japanese would come for you.

1
Lima_32Entente•

You were supposed to destroy the Qing not join them!

7
wiz-R-YOPLKMT Song Qingling Gang•

From my point of view, the LKMT is too hard to play!

​

(If Sichuan/Yunnan did not went pro LKMT, your gameplay just got doomed. Qing could unite the south before 1938 anyway)

4
Thatoneguy3273•

What was your strategy for beating Fengtian?

3
wiz-R-YOPLKMT Song Qingling Gang•

Your army will have absolute majority. Just punch a line through, and take those major cities before you take Shenyang. Make sure Fengtian collapses just after you take Shenyang, so you would fight Japanese with your 96-120 divisions at ease.

4