Trade offer: Moore & Castro for McCutchen & Andrus

I've been offered Moore & Castro for McCutchen & Andrus.

Keeper status for next year:

Moore: 9th Castro: 1st

McCutchen: 7th Andus: 3rd

I really like Moore this year, and Castro/Andrus seem like a wash to me. Castro already has a 200+ hit season, Andrus provides more categorical value (steals). I love McCutchen but does Moore have more upside? 10-team 6x6 H2H. Thanks.

EDIT: formatting