The sidebar over there

I would like us all to debate the contents of that sidebar over there. There seems to be a lack of certainty about what to do with the problem and perhaps a debate here would lead to a better idea of what should be over there and what best represents the beliefs of the members of this subreddit.

EDIT: It concerns me that not a single moderator has acknowledged that this post exists or that many members of this subreddit have a problem with that sidebar. jf_tw has an idea below which seems to be good with many people. I would ask the moderators to consider putting it up on the sidebar, and at the very least just acknowledge that this discussion exists. I have been extremely disheartened and disappointed by the lack of attention form the moderators on this issue, and it leads me to wonder if they pay any attention to this subreddit at all.