Hey r/nursing, settle a dispute about your jobs?

My friend is trying to discourage me from going into nursing rather than an academic graduate program because he thinks nurses are "doctors' bitches." Basically, he sees nurses as analogous to, say, secretaries in an office.

I find this insulting on behalf of nurses and furthermore have not witnessed this type of dynamic in the medical facility where I work.

What are your experiences with doctors in your places of employment, and do you see your job description as glorified "doctor's bitch"? Why or why not?

Posted Mar 25, 2012, 9:09 PM UTC

826
thechickenfootRN•

"Nurses: we keep doctors from accidentally killing you." I've seen this over and over. I've also seen some lazy uncaring nurses. We're not doctors secretary - we do the direct patient care that MDs don't do.

15
Colonel_CarterOP•

This is a great explanation. Thanks.

1
cutesychuRN, BSN•

I'm only a nursing student, BUT I have seen this in clinical and I've been told many things by my instructors. Unfortunately, this is how a lot of people still view the nursing profession. We are our own profession and have our own responsibilities and duties. We do have to do a lot of things for the doctor, take orders, type in charting, and many many more; however the patient is also OUR responsibility. We can't hide behind the doctor if something goes wrong. Nurses have to know how to assess, plan, implement, evaluate, and what to do in emergency situations. From what I've seen in clinical, the doctor interacts VERY LITTLE with the patient, and rest is left to us. We're FAR from a secretary. If you were to go and get your masters and become a nurse practitioner, you write your own prescriptions and see your own patients. It is insulting when people think that way about nurses. I've seen how a lot of doctors interact with nurses and some are nice and respectful, and others can be giant douchebags. Other nurses can be the same way though. Like I said, I'm not a nurse quite yet, but I have never felt like the doctor's bitch, nor have I ever heard a nurse say that.

8
Colonel_CarterOP•

Thanks for your reply! I know nurses are their own profession and work really hard, and it sucks that their status is sometimes viewed as low. I work with psych nurses at my job and I want to be one myself - I'm even considering getting my masters.

I just resent the implication that because I'm intelligent I shouldn't be a nurse and should go into grad school instead. It's really disheartening, especially since I want a job when I'm done with school!

2
cutesychuRN, BSN•

No problem. Nursing is a profession and a damn good one if you ask me. You have to really love patient care if nursing is what you want. NP's get a lot of respect from what I've seen. Psych is tough, but you're a great person for wanting to work in that field, it's hard for some people. Don't feel bad. Nursing school is very tough and will consume your life while you're in it. I've met a lot of RN's that wanted to be a doctor, but changed to nursing. You have to be very intelligent to be a nurse and you must have great critical thinking skills. I agree though. I want a job that I will always be able to have, not to mention, nursing has ENDLESS possibilities!!

2
Colonel_CarterOP•

That's pretty much what I've heard from others. I've been working with mentally ill patients going on 3 years now and I love it, so I thought nursing might be a good next step.

2
cutesychuRN, BSN•

Well if you really enjoy it, then I think nursing would be great for you. Another option would be getting a masters in Psychology. Which I'm sure you've though of that. Nursing school would be a shorter amount of school. It will end up taking me four years to get my Bachelors.

1
aaomalley•

Just an FYI the accrediting body has suggested that prescription privileges be withheld until the DNP (Doctor of Nursing Practice) level. In Washington state NP's will have to have their DNP starting in 2015, and most states are making the same change on different timeliness.

1
casaquesoRN, BSN•

I think if you talked to a doctor, you would find that they would say they wouldn't be able to get along without nurses. Nurses are the first to see many symptoms and report them. Nurses are the first ones there when there is a Code Blue. If you want a hands on job where you get to work with the patient, being a nurse is for you. Most of the doctors in my hospital spend MAYBE 30 minutes a day with their patients. I think it goes without saying that your friend is just speaking from an ignorant place.

8
lostperceptionRN - Med/Surg•

It's even less than 30 mins if you're on an Ortho floor. I would say that after the surgery is complete, and the patient is stable a doctor will spend about 5 to 10 mins a day with the patient. Granted they really don't need to spend much more than that if the Nurses are good at what they do. Nurses help keep doctors focused on the most relevant problems.

3
nursologyRN - ER•

This is definitely insulting to nurses. It's not a reality of the job, but it is still quite a common misconception perpetuated by some doctors and some of the public. I find it happens more often with young doctors. When they start out they look down on nurses and order us around, act like we know nothing etc. They soon learn that if you treat nurses badly, you aren't going to get very far! And that because we work around the same stuff every day, we know our shit. The older doctors frequently have a lot of respect for nurses.

In no way are we the doctors bitch. We work in collaboration with the medical team. We are crucial to implementing their decisions and informing them of progress or decline. In addition we advocate for the patient to ensure they understand their treatment and agree to it, and have their needs met. And in an emergency situation, the doctors usually aren't around, and we run the show until they arrive.

4
Colonel_CarterOP•

Thanks for your input. I'm glad to know that at least most doctors consider nursing staff very important. I think my friend has a misconception about nursing that stems from TV and media.

2
nursologyRN - ER•

If you do choose nursing, you will have people think about you that way, and treat you that way, and it's a pain in the ass sometimes. But you and the majority of other people, especially in the profession, know that it's nowhere near the truth. And actually can be the exact opposite sometimes!

5
Colonel_CarterOP•

Thanks!

1
nocrnRN, BSN•

I have had a lot of autonomy and collegiality in the two RN jobs I've worked.

There are some doctors who give you free reign to put in orders (not medications) and trust your judgment.

There are also those controlling (and sometimes annoying) doctors who call for status updates and give you loads of orders but after all is said and done you feel like together you were able to really help this patient and accomplish so much because they were so on it.

And there's also the douchebags who never give you what you want and that's when you just cover your ass, but this is less common.

3
Colonel_CarterOP•

So basically... doctors are people and you never really know what you'll get?

4
nocrnRN, BSN•

Yes but the vast majority of MDs are of the first two type--either very trusting and give you a whole lot of free reign (at least in the ICU setting) or more controlling but still in a very team way.

Like others have said, the doctors really trust the nurse because they spend 30 seconds with the patient and the rest of the time buried in paperwork.

They rely on us to paint an accurate description of the patient and they don't mind suggestions too--actually, you will find as you gain confidence you will suggest more and more things as they pertain to the patient, both to cover your ass and to advocate for the patient. It feels good when the doctors agree with you.

But exactly, they are just people too. And you have to give them some credit. If they are grumpy, you have to remember they have dozens if not hundreds of patients across multiple hospitals, in addition to the ones they are covering for and often get little sleep, sex, or time with their family.

Honestly, I have never felt like a handmaiden or felt disrespected. There are the random hostile ones I mentioned, but I don't take that personally. They are few and far between, at least where I've worked.

5
baconmuffinsRN - Pediatrics•

Good doctors do not treat nurses like their bitches. I work at a hospital with a huge medical residency program so we see new doctors all the time. However, whether they are told early on by their higher-ups or they come to this decision themselves, the really good doctors get to know the nursing staff personally and are receptive to our suggestions. Usually the residents that do not do as well are those who disregard what the nurses say and take a more paternal role, missing out on a nurse's valuable input to improve their care.

3
dcnurseRN - PACU•

I have never seen this at my facility. I work at a level one trauma center that is also a teaching facility. I am on first name basis with many of the residents, and the attending physicians are more or less open to discussion about clinical practice. There are physicians who are less open, but those are the same physicians who have clashes with other doctors and are often "talked to". We are very autonomous at are hospital and interdisciplinary collaboration is a high priority. I have never seen being a "doctor's bitch" an accepted culture at any facility I've been to, employed or otherwise. Degression to that mindset is all but wiped off the map, at least in my demographic area.

3
gracieegrace•

It really depends on where you work. Some places you do your own thing like a rockstar, others you have to bend over and hope that they remembered the KY. In Connecticut the doctors were wildly rude. I just moved to Texas and I am very impressed by how nice the docs here are.

2
justatouchcrazySRNA•

It just depends.

In most places, especially critical care and transport settings, hell no. But, in some units of some hospitals with certain physicians, yes. I did clinicals at one inpatient psych unit where the only psychiatrist in 100 miles worked and the climate there was nothing but "Do exactly as the doctor says and nothing else. Also open his charts for him and pour his coffee." Needless to say those are the exception but they do exist.

2
[deleted]•

I rarely see the doctors. I have never felt like one's bitch. I've found most I have dealt with to be pretty respectful, overall. I have a lot of autonomy in my job. Usually whatever "we" ask for, the doctors are happy to oblige (within reason).

On a side note, I <3 my secretary when I get to have her on my shift. Working second shift with no secretary kind of sucks ass. The faxing and filing and phone answering alone that I do when she's not there costs me a couple hours a day. She's nobody's bitch either.

2
melsam14•

No not at all.Where I work nurses are treated with respect by the doctors.Nurses are a valuable part of the health care team and our input is valuable.Nurses do not just blindly carry out doctors orders.We are expected to use our nursing judgement to make critical decisions about our patients care.Doctors rely on our knowledge and assessment skills.We judge how a patient is responding and when certain doctors orders need to be implemented.

1
monkeyface496RN•

I'm a bit late to this thread, but out of curiosity, why does your friend have this impression? You mentioned TV shows, but is it just that or is he involved in health care as well?

In my experience, most doctors realise how important nurses are and are aware of how hard their job would be without their support. As the nurse has more knowledge of the patient, they'll often listen if the nurse recommends something relating to the medical treatment (different dosage or medicine for example) and can provide rationale. In the ED, many nurses will draw up medication then speak to the doctor to tell them what they're giving and have the prescription form signed. I've seen several junior doctors who try to treat nurses like their bitches, but find out quickly how hard it makes their life and how little respect it gets them- from nurses and other doctors alike.

Additionally, there have been several times when a nurse spots an error that the doctor missed that can potentially be life saving- ie: drug dosage or incorrect written instructions. In the UK (and I hope elsewhere) you're held responsible if you administer the wrong medication- even if it was prescribed by the doctor as you have your own professional guidelines and working knowledge. To me this shows how important nurses are in addition to doctors.

1
letitbelindsayRN, BSN•

I can only speak from my experience. I worked as a public health nurse at the county health department; my job was to do home visits mostly to new moms and also to give routine vaccinations to all populations. That being said, the county doctor didn't follow any of the home visits (we would only provide support and education; nothing requiring an order), and we had standing orders for all vaccines. If ever there was a question about a vaccine, we'd call the doctor, and usually her answer was always just to agree with what we thought was best. We certainly weren't her bitches. The nurses were pretty autonomous at my work.

1