ELI5: How hard would it be to determine your position in space travel?

Engineering

If (when) humans start colonizing other solar systems how would we navigate vast space? More specifically if humans travel in hibernation and for some reason AI that is guiding fails, could humans determine position of the spacecraft and orient it to original destination? Historically ships used stars to navigate seas, but could stars be used to determine current position?

Posted Dec 13, 2021, 7:53 AM UTC

16
varialectio•

The plaques on the Pioneer 10 and 11 spacecraft from 1973/4 have an engraving of the position of our solar system relative to 14 identifiable pulsars (stars whose light appears to pulse at different rates). That would form the basis of a whole coordinate system for navigating this part of the Milky Way galaxy.

4

You know how sometimes you approach an intersection you've been through before, but it's your first time approaching it from that direction? But you can recognise it anyway?

Your brain picks up on some distinctive features (a tall tree, an advertising billboard, etc) and their arrangement with each other, and fits what you're seeing into a mental 3D map which already had that intersection in it.

We can do the same with what's in space, with the help of our computers. We have a 3D map of space with a lot of distinctive features. Pick a spot in space, choose a camera angle and we can generate the image of what you would see if you were there. In fact, you can do that on your phone.

We can work in the opposite direction, too,like approaching that traffic intersection from a new direction. Put a starship in a random location, point the instruments at the sky (it's all sky) and collect the relative arrangement of some distinctive objects. The computer will figure out where it is. Of course, you can save a lot of unnecessary computation if you narrow the field to "within a day's travel of where we were yesterday".

Fun fact: back in the 60's when the SR-71 Blackbird spy plane was developed, they needed a navigation system which could accurately position the plane and they couldn't depend on navigational beacons when flying over enemy territory. So they built something which would look at the stars and figure out its location. It say behind the pilot and had a domed lens on top, and when Star Wars came out it became known as R2-D2.

2
lemoinem•

And then, they cut the tree and change the ad campaign, and you're like Fk, Fk, Fk, Fk, crash.

1
PappiStalin•

Well people can navigate what is mapped out, I imagine that humans will send out about a billion probes in all directions before really doing any manned ventures into space, so assuming these drones map some ideal routes ahead we should be able to navigate. In terms of sending out signals of ships that are lost, or using navigation equipment which requires some kind of wireless connection to something...

Well we have radio waves. Which do not travel very far, very fast at all. Outside of that, your stepping into far future science fiction. Which at that point you could say anything can happen.

3
Russucas•

Yeah there wouldn’t be any problem in doing this. Basically from our perspective the relative positions of stars don’t really move. It’d be as easy as fixing your position on a plain on a clean day by keeping the mountain on your right. Bit more complex but kinda like head towards Sirius and hook a left

2
WRSaunders•

That sort of space travel is going to be point-to-point. Our star (Sol) will be behind you and your destination will be in front of you. If this isn't true, you're off course to one side or the other and you can figure how to get back on course. In terms of how far you've traveled, some geometry with a nearby star will be required, probably several to get good accuracy.

Now if you pull a Wil Robinson and some unknown alien warp vortex sends you into a random part of the galaxy and you have no idea where, it will take a long time to measure enough variable stars and calculate when and where you are located. If you're on the other side of the Milky Way, it's unlikely there is enough information to calculate your position accurately. If you're outside the Milky Way, in some random other galaxy, you're "lost in space". Don't be Wil Robinson.

2