Liability for damage caused by skip lorry.

Traffic & Parking

Skip lorry knocked over my wall when reversing onto my drive.

They claim no liability for damage on private property - understandable in part as it’s feasible that their stabilising feet could damage driveways. Only liability they accept is on public roads.

They were on public road when they clouted my wall. The same driver had successfully delivered & retrieved 3 skips prior to this.

My question is - can they just decide they are not liable?

Realistically I won’t be pursuing it in court (if I do have a case) but wouldn’t mind calling them out on it if they are talking nonsense.

Any inputs gratefully received.

Edit: thanks for the advice. It backs up my suspicions. The wall will be knocked down & moved in the summer so I’m not stressing too much about it.

I’m mostly annoyed at the skip company immediately going on the offensive and telling me that it’s my problem to sort out.

Posted Dec 14, 2021, 8:17 AM UTC · edited

34772
[deleted]•

No liability might cover "We can't be sure this won't damage your drive, it's really heavy, so that's your lookout." It won't cover "I drove right into a wall because I wasn't looking."

393
Alexia2312•

This is it. They're (usually) not liable for damage they warned you would/could happen or something anyone would reasonably know. Eg if you insist the skip should go on your flower bed you can't blame them for squashed daisies.

They don't get to choose what they're liable for or not after the event. If you've already made an agreement that they can damage your property however they like then they wouldn't be, but I don't imagine that's the case somehow and it wouldn't necessarily hold up anyway.

44
Every-holes-a-goal•

Even then if the property is joint owned I e married then the spouse can claim against them also for damage under negligence.

2
PM_Me_Rude_Haiku•

You can't just declare yourself not liable. That's like shooting a bunch of people and telling the police you've given yourself diplomatic immunity.

353
[deleted]•

[removed]

35
[deleted]•

[removed]

12
[deleted]•

[removed]

7
[deleted]•

[removed]

5
[deleted]•

[removed]

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

16
[deleted]•

[removed]

8
[deleted]•

[removed]

12
[deleted]•

[removed]

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
colin_staples•

They claim no liability for damage on private property

Do not take legal advice from the other person.

The fact is that they hit a stationary object and caused damage. They are 100% liable, regardless of if it happened on private property.

Let's test their false claim by taking things to the extreme: imagine their skip lorry crashed into your house which is definitely on private property and knocked it down. They would be liable, wouldn't they? Of course they would.

And they are also liable for the damage that they caused to your wall.

146
WHAMPanzer•

Bollocks to that. They knocked over your wall, they’re liable. Get their insurance details or go through your house insurance who will then go after them as that’s what you pay it for.

140
TheGoober87•

Be careful with this. I had a similar issue and my home insurance is being absolutely useless.

They do not have to claim it back, and you might lose your excess. If they do decide to chase the other party, they only ask for your excess as goodwill...

1
Mantaray2142•

I'm a transport manager for a skip company. They are liable. Striking a stationary object (like a wall or parked car) is negligent and they'd have to prove otherwise to a magistrate. (Spoiler. They won't be able to). In their terms of sale they will likely have words to the effect of 'not liable for damage caused when being ordered off the public highway' There's some mileage in this but only to the point of forseeable damage to a driveway not caused by the drivers negligence. I.e. you ask a skip company to drop a skip on your drive. It's your responsibility to ensure that your drive can hold the 4 tonne of builders waste you put in it without buckling. That you put chipboard down so the corners don't scratch up your stones. And if deep enough on to your property the 18 tonne of skip lorry AND its stabilising legs. Drain covers are the bane of my existence. My stance on them changes case by case. Autumn? Leaves obscuring drive? Your fault. Summer? Literally the only feature on a tarmac drive on a mid-day delivery? I'm likely to offer you some dosh off your skip without prejudice. Might i ask which company?

76
plotslostOP•

Thanks for your comments, very helpful! I don’t want to name & shame quite yet - it’s a small firm local to me.

I completely understand the need for the skip company to indemnify itself against damage to the drive etc, after all, I asked them to drop it there!

Maybe it was tempting fate, the same driver, in the same lorry, had already done a few drops & recovers with no issues.

6
Lozsta•

Just to reinforce the previous post, I have had both brick tower downed by a neighbours skip delivery and damage to my drive from my own skip being delivered without them using the correct pads to displace weight.

The tower was dealt with straight away after I contacted them. The driveway damage was a bit of a pain as the builder who ordered it dealt with them himself and agreed a couple skips (for other jobs) and that he would put it right himself. I ended up having to ask the builder to leave as they were spreading themselves too thin and took far too long for the final stages of the work to be done and I had no clue about the driveway agreement. I contacted the skip company by email and mail and after some back and forth that they had a verbal agreement with the builder about it I stood my ground and they sent round a driveway chap to deal with it.

Just stand your ground and eventually it should be sorted. They are liable.

6
NoDG_•

That is a clear public liability incident. The easiest route is to claim off your home insurance and let them subrogate the loss.

40
Chainsawmanicure•

What happens then? Skip company (or their insurer) pays the home owner's insurance company, presumably, but does the home owner take a hit to their premiums as a consequence of making a claim?

3
NoDG_•

There will be a increase for claiming on the insurance as this causes costs to the insurer. If the subrogation is successful, the increase should be greatly reduced as theyll have successfullly recovered the loss. This is a straightforward case, but its worth noting the 3rd party is right to deny their own liability and let his insurer deal with it. This is usually a condition in the policy wording.

5
Chainsawmanicure•

Thank you. I'm unhappy with the idea that the wronged party is out-of-pocket but there you are.

6
Nutmeg1729•

You’re effectively paying the insurance in this case to defend your right to not pay costly repairs yourself. If an insurer successfully recovers they should also be able to recover your excess as well so you won’t be too much out of pocket.

It does suck, but better than having to pay ££ yourself to have a wall rebuilt, imho. That said, if the repairs are cheap, and you can stomach it, plenty of people just deal with it themselves and don’t attempt recovery.

3
leonteale89•

That's a terrible idea why would you go through your own insurance, they did it

1
NoDG_•

If its a terrible idea, why do you need an explanation?

1
leonteale89•

For the person giving the idea. Clearly they didn't even think about it first before they gave the idea.

0
NoDG_•

Well... Theres 2 main options here. Insurance or small claims court. One is a hell of a lot easier.

1
ColonelFaz•

Possibly they are not insured for it. Sounds like they are liable, though.

28
cottontail57•

Driving without insurance would be worth reporting ASAP if that was the case

8
Obese_Hooters•

It's not driving without insurance. Public liability insurance is different. I would be surprised though if it is even legal for them to operate as a business without public liability insurance ?

3
dynodebs•

Public liability insurance is not mandatory in the UK, although I don't know a broker who would advise against it

3
cottontail57•

The hit a wall while on a street. Normal insurance should cover that

2
Obese_Hooters•

No in the course of business you would claim on their public liability insurance

Public liability is a type of insurance for businesses of all sizes, across a variety of industries. It covers you if a client or member of the public claims they have been injured, or their property damaged, because of your business activities.

2
kennethjor•

I won’t be pursuing it in court (if I do have a case) but wouldn’t mind calling them out on it if they are talking nonsense.

The only way you can call them out and teach them a lesson is to make them pay for the wall. You telling them "well ackshually, people on Reddit said" won't teach them anything.

14
snappercop•

As the others have said, if damage is caused due to their negligence (driving into a wall would almost certainly be this), they are liable.

Do you have home insurance? Suggest you contact them, give them the vehicle details and they should pursue it.

10
leonteale89•

No, don't do this, you'll suffer extra costs and premiums going up. Why go to your own insurance when their insurance will easily cover it. (assuming you have proof of course)

1
MONKEH1142•

Did you contract them and agree to those terms?

5
plotslostOP•

Good question. Nope, called them up, ordered a few skips as needed. Paid cash, got receipt each time.

4
MONKEH1142•

Ask them that I guess. On what basis do they accept no liability? On an agreed basis prior to the incident or on an assumed basis post incident. One of those puts you in a position of arguing against a contract and the other is someone damaging something and refusing to pay, which is a classic small claims win for you.

5
custard-powder•

I’d at least be trying to get them to give you a free skip to take the wall away if you’re knocking it down anyway. Most skip companies make money if it’s just bricks anyway as they crush it for hardcore

5

I was going to say I doubt there is any money in it after dropping skip, collecting buying a crusher, transporting to a wholesaler and their profit margin. I bought last year at £23 a ton bag……but a quick search shows the price has have doubled!

2
Court96e•

This would fall under the motor insurance, I’ve seen some people incorrectly state it would be under the public liability insurance.

As the vehicle was reversing with the skip attached, it would fall under the motor as the skip was controlled by the motor vehicle.

Contact them and ask for their insurance company details and go directly through them. Get the registration of the vehicle that delivered the skip.

5
MrDeviousUK•

I came to say the same as this. I would expect that fleeing the scene of an accident without providing his contact and insurance details could land the driver in hot water.

4
Court96e•

Technically under the road traffic act, yes, but unless it has actually been a ‘hit and run’ type of incident (OP has the third party details, and a discussion has taken place afterwards) the police will have very little involvement and take no interest.

3
Alex_j300•

Yes they fucking are liable. See if you have any witnesses. Contact their main office tell them that one of their lorry’s knocked down your wall. Take them to small claims court and represent yourself if you have to. Take it as far as you need to. Get your wall repaired if they don’t play ball immediately and claim back the money plus any lost earnings.

Edit I would imagine the owner would be more willing to cooperate than the driver as he knows he is in for a bollocking. Also take some pictures and tag them on social media if you have any.

4
Lou-Lou-Lou•

Your house and buildings insurance may have free legal advice and may also take up the case for you. Check your policy for their terms. They know their stuff usually.

3
ASAPRockii•

Just a thought on you saying about the plan to move the wall anyway… it may be possible that as long as it doesn’t cost any extra that it could be rebuilt at their expense in the new desired location.

Not claiming I’m an expert but someone had a similar issue except it was a lorry fully driving into their living room! The whole house was rebuilt but it didn’t have to be exactly the same. So it may be beneficial to try!

3

I work for a skip company. We would fix this if we made this mistake. Speak to a manager.

3

Their definitely liable for that. The damage they're talking about is the damage the skip might cause to driveway when being delivered or collected. Them driving into your wall is definitely on them

2

Your insurance company won't know or actually care about your intentions with the wall. If you want to exchange a bit of a faff for some cash (might want to check excesses and the effect on your premium) make a claim with your insurer with the skip company's details.

2
Gorrodish•

I have 30 years litigation experience in this area

1 they cannot disclaim
Send a letter of claim them Sue make sure you tell the insurers You should sue the driver and the employer vicariously

2
Welsooo•

OP - you’ve said that you are planning to knock the wall down anyway but you are still entitled to make a claim through the companies own insurance policy (this can be a cash settlement).

2