Why didn’t they have a funeral for Sirius?
Posted Dec 15, 2021, 5:19 PM UTC
Posted Dec 15, 2021, 5:19 PM UTC
That‘s a really good question..
I‘d say because they had no body and the Order was busy hindering Voldemorts return.
And also wizards have no clue about psychological health, so they don‘t realize how important a farewell ceremony can be.
I mean when Cedric died they just shipped Harry to the Dursleys. Where the only „person“ he could talk about what happened to was his owl or a letter to Sirius every week.. Poppy didn‘t even give him a potion to take in case his sleep got bad.
Councelings not even mentioned.
Makes sense. Idk why Harry would be invited to or knowledgeable about Cedric’s funeral though, they weren’t really friends right?
I'd imagine Harry chalking it up to an emotional need of his that no one bothers to fulfill and he can't ask. Given that in HBP, the people he does talk about Sirius to is - Buckbeak ("missing him? But you are okay with Hagrid aren't you?") and Tonks, who he mistakenly assumes is in love with Sirius. Basically Harry only brings up Sirius with those who he thinks is experiencing the same, raw loss he does.
Perhaps, after the war, Harry does a quiet memorial with himself and Ron and Hermione.
I imagine that they had a small ceremony remembering Sirius on Grimmauld Place or the Burrow at some point, but well, it's not like there was a body to bury anyway.
There was no body to bury that's why there was no funeral
Who besides Harry and Remus would have gone to the funeral/memorial, though? I get the feeling no one really likes Sirius that much.
Not liking someone that much and not going to his funeral are too different things, though. All the Order members would go just because he was a member and to be there for Harry.
The sixth book says there wasn't a funeral because there wasn't a body to bury. Whether one would attend a funeral with no body is someone's personal preference. But that was the explanation given in the book.
Yeah it doesn't make a ton of sense, you'd think that Tonks or her mom would have planned it at least even if they weren't close to Sirius
Because there's no body to bury.
No body to bury
People bury empty caskets all the time. That’s a terrible excuse. The fact they were in the midst of Voldemorts return I’m sure played a role but it was probably just something glossed over as I don’t recall them really discussing funerals for anyone that’s passed in the series.
Dumbledore had a funeral
Actually it's worse because Harry buries Moody's eye and DD has a funeral, even Harry going to his parents' graves is his funeral for them, so its really sad that Sirius didnt get one. Especially since Harry is so young. Remus not doing that as the last maurader says to me that he never really forgave Sirius for trying to make him attempt murder (plus Lupin getting loose in werewolf form near children due to Sirius breaking in. A second time he could have turned or killed a child due to Sirius.)
I don’t think you need a body to do a funeral… did Pettigrew’s mother do one with just his finger? I thought that’s when they gave him the order of Merlin but idk if they mention a funeral