Losing weight for gender dysphoria, but without affirming unhealthy thoughts?

Note: post discusses internalized dysphoria, body shame and fatphobia.

I've hated my weight since I was a teenager, but now I find myself in a situation where even though I like many more things about my body, I hate how my weight makes me look and feel.

I'm trans-fem but tall and broad-shouldered with wide hips and quite heavy. Overall I'm way happier with my body than I have been for most of my life, but I hate how my fat gives me a gut, makes my boobs look smaller, and takes away definition from my face. It makes me feel like I'm just a fat guy, instead of a fat girl. I wouldn't mind being a fat girl, but that's definitely not how my body now makes me feel.

My struggle is that so much dieting now is about body positivity and "health at any size." But I don't want to be healthy at any size, because after two years of HRT I've come to believe I will never be recognizably feminine at this size.

I have tried losing weight in the past; I've tried at least once a year every year for the last two decades. And it's never really worked out, and I feel like it's just a pipe dream at this point. I also don't know how to engage with these thoughts and feelings. Even if I wanted to try losing weight again, how can I do that without just reaffirming that I hate my body?

Anyway. I am struggling to figure out how to do anything about my body without feeding into my worst, most self-destructive feelings and beliefs. How to acknowledge that I am dieting for the sake of appearances without just feeling like I hate my appearance, when that's something I struggle with anyway, and feeling like if I fail I should hate myself.

Thoughts and advice from anyone who has been in a similar situation would be appreciated.

Posted Dec 15, 2021, 8:52 PM UTC

26
LikeIGotABigCock•

What works is going to vary person to person. If you're somebody who finds it easy to over consume its impossible to outrun the fork.

For me I made successive changes over quite a number of years. Some things that work for me:

  • Simply not having certain foods in the house. If they're there, I'll consume them, and quite rapidly. Candy, chocolate, sugary drinks, chips, ice cream, bread.

  • A period of complete calorie tracking via weighing everything. Simply calculate what macros and calories need to be consumed for targeted weight loss, and adjust over time. For me, calories must be recorded prior to consumption as this makes them "real" and let's me adjust things. McDonalds becomes "Zero calorie drink, no fries, and bunless burger(s)". Doing this helps to teach yourself just what is in each food.

  • Intermittent fasting makes things so much easier. It was hard at first but I simply don't get hungry as much. Eating, particularly carbs, is what makes me hungry. Just not having a snack is easy, but having the snack will easily lead to a binge.

  • Just relaxing about the whole thing, made much easier by having had historical success. I won't violate any rules just because, but I don't brutally restrain myself during social occasions. This will not work if one has sufficient social occasions.

2
HoneyBadgerninja•

Same boat.

My guess, learn to love yourself....and see getting to the desired weight as a form of love?

Problem is.......how the fuck do we love ourselves?> Body shaving? Ice-cream once a week? Going to the movies? Buying clothes/jewelry/Scents/Makeup? Honestly IDK, nothing feels right.

1
ericfischerErica, binary transfem, HRT 9/2020•

The body-positive way to lose weight is as a side effect of getting more exercise to improve your physical condition.

1
eggpossibleOPQueer Trans-Femme•

Uh, that sounds overly ambitious for where I am at mental-health-wise. Currently working on mustering the energy to walk enough that I'm not totally sedentary.

1
ericfischerErica, binary transfem, HRT 9/2020•

Me too, honestly. Pandemic isolation has not been good for my fitness.

2
eggpossibleOPQueer Trans-Femme•

It's a really, really hard time. Personally having a work friend who I walk with on breaks is the primary reason why I am having some success.

3