Speed tests through Starlink app are confusing

💬 Discussion

Pretty much every time I run the speed test through the Starlink app I get results that seem backwards. The 'Router to Internet' speed is usually lower than the 'Android to Internet' speed. By noticeable amounts: For instance, I just did it and got 105 Mb/s from router and 180 Mb/s from Android. Why would this be?

Posted Dec 16, 2021, 3:18 PM UTC

414
TheLantean•

Yes, this seems counter intuitive, you'd expect the router test to be faster because it doesn't have to deal with WiFi overhead.

My speculation: the speed test runs on a general purpose CPU core on the router, which is slow and bottlenecks it. While packet routing is fast because it's handled by an ASIC (like GPU hardware acceleration for graphics processes).

If your phone has a good processor it won't bottleneck the test for the same reason and will just take full advantage of the router's (ASIC accelerated) throughput. WiFi overhead becomes a non-issue because 5 Ghz at close range is faster than what Starlink can provide.

2
Henslykg•

i like your theory. I wonder is it true.

3
BigBlueEdgeOPBeta Tester•

That may be it. If so, I'd expect that it would be a consistent thing for all/most users though. I haven't heard others mention it. And if this were true it's odd the Starlink folks would have pushed a feature like that out because it isn't really very accurate info.

3
graybeardedone•

turn off the mobile data on your phone and try again.

2
BigBlueEdgeOPBeta Tester•

That makes no sense. If you have wifi enabled on your phone then that's what your phone will use for Internet connection until/unless Internet is unreachable via that wifi path. Your phone is not going to randomly switch back and forth between wifi and cell data.

1
graybeardedone•

Mine uses both at the same time

1
BigBlueEdgeOPBeta Tester•

I've never heard of that and I'm skeptical of the concept being an issue even if my phone did that, since when I test I'm always right next to the Starlink router with perfect wifi signal.

Regardless, it is not the issue. Just turned off cell data and re-did Starlink app test. 96 Mb/s from router to Internet and 180 Mb/s from Android to Internet.

1
huh_say_what_now_Beta Tester•

Same as me, on speedtest.net I'll get almost 400mbps wired or wireless but with the app router will be around 150 but android will be at least double

1
News8000•

Used to be the opposite many firmware generations ago up to early September, router was way faster than my device, always. Lasted for about a month after I got my dish late August

Since a September firmware update on the router, the router has since lagged behind my device like you say.

So there's software involved, as it's the same hardware that I was getting faster down/up for the router before the update.

1

Prior to a windstorm yesterday, SL was cranking 150-165+ MBPS Down and about 30-40 MPBS Up on my MacBook Air running Mac Mail. After the windstorm, Down is about the same, but Up is a disappointing 10-20 MBPS. No visible changes to the (rectangle) receiver, mounted on my roof, which is still pointed exactly as before. Ideas? PS I rebooted the SL modem and it's 40 MBPS slower Down than before, no difference in terms of UP. I hope this isn't a permanent situation!

1

Speedtest, ten minutes later, DOWN's worse, about 40-50 MBPS. UP is still the same. What's up with that?

1
ChesterDrawerzBeta Tester•

not confusing at all. the test checks the speed from device to the SL router and then from the SL router to the internet separately.

-4
TheLantean•

This is not true. If you look at a screenshot the tests are labeled "router to internet" and "android/iphone to internet", not "android/iphone to router".

3
BigBlueEdgeOPBeta Tester•

That's not accurate. The tests are from your phone to the Internet test server and from the router to the Internet test server. With the router being hard wired to Starlink there is zero reason it should be slower than the phone over wifi, on a consistent basis.

1