Cardhu Gold Reserve

Posted Dec 16, 2021, 10:39 PM UTC

Posted Dec 16, 2021, 10:39 PM UTC
While my score wasn't as low as yours, it was one of the lower I've given. I didn't hate it, but just like you it didn't do anything for me. I tried it with water, too, and boy dit it ever drown. Actually had to pour the rest out after that.
I haven’t got a good scoring system right now and just go purely on feel lol. 50s seemed like a good place for “not good, not bad”. 70 is probably closer though if I’m thinking “C average”.
This was one of the rare few that I didn’t even try adding a dash of water. It already felt watered down, so I figured there was no point.
There indeed wasn’t. I reviewed back when I was adding water to everything briefly, before I started reserving that for if I felt it could use it.
Maybe use it in cocktail, it would look fancy pouring from this bottle
Maybe, though I haven’t found a scotch cocktail worth drinking. Especially for a whisky on the lighter side.
I’ll probably just make an effort to pour some of this when I’m not particularly choosy about what I’m drinking. It’s not offensive in any way, just really light and boring.
That’s a very good point. This reminds me of glenmorangie X they claim that’s designed for mixing, but I don’t know how light taste glenmorangie would do well in cocktail, and honestly I won’t spend my money on X, so I may never know…
I wonder if it’s a bit bolder than the 10, though rougher around the edges so not a good sipper.
I quite enjoyed the Glenmorangie X for what it was. It more or less tasted like the 10-year with a rum cask finish. I think the "designed for mixing" claim comes from the abundance of those sweet tropical flavors that you don't typically get from Glenmorangie. Tasty and smooth, even sipping neat, but if I'm buying Scotch specifically for mixing, I'm just going to get a cheap blended handle, not a $40 single malt.
Figured I should get around to reviewing all the dusty bottles I haven’t touched since I was first getting into scotch. It turns out there’s a reason I haven’t touched them, at least according to this one.
Details: NAS, I assume colored and chill-filtered.
In the glass: bright gold
Nose: freshly sliced granny-smith, whisper of smoke, honey. Very fresh and crisp.
Palate: thin. white cracker, a little citrus. Not a lot here.
Finish: medium-short. Upon exhale we get that whisper of smoke and the green apple back. Quickly fades towards malt and honey. Hint of cocoa.
Score: 52/100
Meh. It’s certainly not offensive in any way, it’s just rather bland and unsatisfying. Wouldn’t turn it down, but not something I’d buy again. It is cheap at least, but there’s better single malts (and even more blends) that are a better at this price.
Good review. Seems to confirm passing on it was the right move for me.
Yeah I really only bought it because it was the cheapest of the GOT bottlings lol. I’ve got the Stark (dalwhinnie) up next. iirc it was better than this, but probably not by a large degree.