Balancing question of modifying a spell's use
One of my players has the spell Planar Ally, and has an idea that she recognizes wouldn't work RAW but was wondering if I'd allow it anyway. She wants to beseech Pan to send a former follower of his and a former party member (bard with Acolyte background) as the ally. Obviously, he wouldn't be a celestial, elemental, or fiend, but I like the flavor of it. I'm just afraid of allowing something that becomes unreasonably powerful because of something I haven't considered. Is allowing an adventurer to be the aid too much?
Posted Dec 17, 2021, 7:37 PM UTC
That spell really is flawed in terms of mechanical exactness. Summon Celestial was a good fix.
Compromise - it has the statblock of a normal summon but the personality of the adventurer. But you can also just have them come with normal body, the spell has no real limit baked in. It is up to you to decide on case by case basis.