Repeater at recreational community.

I have a cabin in a (very wooded, very hilly) gated recreational community totalling about 3300 acres. My cabin is pretty close to the middle of the community and is at one of the highest elevations. I want to set up a repeater but am I allowed to instill "rules" for the people I allow in? There are over 1000 owners that are weekend warriors there and I want the repeater to be 1) only available to licensed users and 2)family friendly language. If someone is unlicensed or vulgar can they be given "the boot" from the repeater?

Posted Dec 20, 2021, 7:19 PM UTC

1120
persiusone•

You can use whatever rules you want for your own repeater, as long as you are still conforming to the FCC rules as well (for example, you cannot relax the FCC rules).

I'd probably setup a system with specific DCS codes to access the repeater, and instruct members not to share or discuss the code(s) with anyone. People in violation would be booted (and the code changed). Good practice to change codes periodically to keep membership-only access to the repeater.

13
ChadHahn•

A local repeater was having troubles I guess so they implemented a cross tone setup with different tones for receive and transmit. Something like that might slow down the unlicensed.

Since it's a small community, you might be able to recognize the voices of the people using the repeater. If you do, you can get on and say, "Sorry Joe, this is a private repeater and you have to be licensed to use it."

2
Chrontius•

It'll also slow down the Midland-owners, and Midland makes a lot of the mobile units in service lately.

1
mixduptransistor•

On the topic of unlicensed users, you have to be licensed to transmit on GMRS regardless, so that's not an issue

As to any other rules, you are completely free to let anyone or no one use your repeater. Users must have permission to use a repeater. Some repeater owners set no restrictions, others set many. It's up to you

5
Mr-Measure-Twice•

That is assuming that everyone is obeying the FCC rules. Anyone can buy a GMRS radio, no license required, so unlicensed users is an issue.

2
TheObjectifiedOP•

Exactly. I dont even have gmrs license yet but I could get on a gmrs repeater very easily with radios I already own, if I wanted to.

2
mixduptransistor•

So, I guess your question was more of a technical one (how to actually restrict access) rather than a philosophical or legal one (are you allowed to restrict access)?

Short answer is no, there's no reliable way to stop someone from using your repeater. You can put tones or codes on, so that they have to know the tone or code to transmit to key up your repeater, but many radios can scan those codes and they're not secret

3
TheObjectifiedOP•

Yes that is more like what I was asking. So even if I kick someone off (change pl tones) if they are savvy enough they can just get right back on and there are no repercussions?

2
mixduptransistor•

If they're not following FCC rules what makes you think they're going to follow the repeater owner's rules?

2
noxbos•

This

With the number of handhelds on the market that are FRS/GMRS units and don't clearly distinguish between the two, I can see people using it without knowing about the license requirement.

hopefully the FCC will get the fee changed "soon" and that will lower the cost of entry into gmrs.

1
mixduptransistor•

Well, a FRS radio isn't going to be able to use a repeater anyway

2
Chrontius•

OTOH, most of those units don't have repeater-in frequencies, so…

1
Mr-Measure-Twice•

I think it's a cool idea, but I have a few thoughts/questions.

Do you have a feel for how many of the owners have GMRS radios and are licensed? Just curious. Also, do you have an easy way to let the owners know about the repeater?

Lastly, does the community have any rules/regulations about antennas, etc.?

1
TheObjectifiedOP•

Have radios and already licensed probably very few. Are willing to buy radios and try to use the repeater, much larger. Are willing to buy radios and a license and use repeater, less but still enough that it would be justified. The group of people that I hang with down there alone is probably 50 people ish. Some have already even suggested they'd chip in on such an idea. Cell phone reception isn't very good there. It would be very easy to let others know. Word spreads fast but there's also multiple Facebook groups and community events. There are not any antenna rules.

2
Remmy700P•

Before you fire up a repeater, gauge interest first. Have a meeting or a web page for user signup. Collect names, emails, # of users per license, and FCC callsigns. Make sure each call sign is valid. Have all users sign a rules sheet, particularly the part about identifying oneself when TXing. A little tedious, I know, but the work up front will save you a lot of headaches down the road.
Then, when you set up your repeater, use CTCSS or DCS tone codes (I'd suggest a different one for TX and RX). If you get a bunch of knuckleheads STILL making it a mess, try non-standard tone codes so they'll be a bit harder to scan, but I doubt it'll be that much of an issue.

1
porty1119•

If you're really intent on limiting access, require MDC1200 or Fleetsync to open the repeater.

1
Chrontius•

It'd be about the only way to make limited access really work, but it'd really cut back on users' hardware choices, and turn our hobbyist into the de-facto radio dealer.

Sure, it'd work, but it'd also make you tech support for the entire community!

1
porty1119•

There are a lot more MDC-capable radios than you'd think. In my case, I already maintain a commercial radio fleet so what's one more? lol

1
Chrontius•

Please don't hate on me too much right now (lol) but I'm currently enjoying the hell out of my latest radios.

it's a fleet of four each Maxon PC-50s at 49 MHz, (F3JPC50) and another fleet of four Motorola MS350Rs. (K7GMSCEJ)

The Maxons predate bubblepacks, and are the finest 49 MHz radios shipped to date (but still are older than I am) and the Motorolas are the finest bubblepacks ever shipped (and one of the only repeater-capable ones, to boot!)

The nice bubblepacks straddle the line nicely over deadface radios to hand to FNGs, and field-programmable monsters.

1