Highfleet + The Expanse

Discussion

Does anybody else think than an Expanse-themed game with Highfleet mechanics and gameplay would be totally awesome? There's also lots of ship modifications in that universe, tactical and strategic weapons, CIWS, fuel considerations, etc.

It could be a little more sandbox-based with you starting as a rock hopper and creating the OPA fleet? Same scrappy feel though. (I know there is a Telltale game coming out.)

Posted Dec 29, 2021, 7:45 PM UTC

3526
EternaI_Sorrow•

I'd like to see more of a 3D space sim with newtonian physics rather than a 2D arcade combat. 2D gamey gameplay looks better in a dieselpunk setting rather than in a quasi-realistic future.

20
Dequil•

It's not even in early access yet but I'm keeping an eye on NEBULOUS: Fleet Command. It looks very like it could scratch that 6DOF space combat / Expanse itch.

11
yollim•

That and Falling Frontier.

6
UpgrayedddddOP•

Thanks, that game looks sweet.

4
EternaI_Sorrow•

Wishlisted.

3
Slomes•

what the fleck, that looks insane

3
Slomes•

"dV: Rings of Saturn" Is 2d space with physics and it looks great and has customizable ships (but the frames are prebuilt, you can change equipment etc.)

4
syngyne•

This game is basically Beltalowda: The Game. Eke a living out by rockhopping around Saturn.

2
Slomes•

Yea it's great, I play it to mellow out if im stressed

1
UpgrayedddddOP•

True, but the management of fleet movement in 3D space with multiple strike groups might be more of a mental exercise than fun. Most of the solar system is more or less 2D anyways.

It could almost work with a reskin and a little main-map physics change.

1
EternaI_Sorrow•

3D is important for CQC fighting. Map management could be a 3D also with a huge element of automatization, since going out of ecliptic sometimes may be beneficial.

OTOH 2D orbital map is also totally viable. But IMHO if someone does a proper 3D combat simulation, organizing a map management after is a toy task.

1
ticktockbent•

Children of a dead earth did realistic space combat well. It's mind bending and crazy but fun

1
EternaI_Sorrow•

I love CoaDE, but it lacks of a strategic part and that's a substantially different tech level. Expanse is more about dV of thousands of km/s.

1

I though dV wasn't really a concern in the expanse thanks to the epstein drive?

1
EternaI_Sorrow•

Roci's dV is estimated as 4000 km/s. That's enough to travel 2 weeks at constant 1/3g and get anywhere in Sol in reasonable time, but they sometimes still run out of fuel. Combat maneuvering may also consume more of it.

1
jeaivn•

Someone already brought it up in another comment but I came here to recommend Starsector.

It does have 2D combat though, but it looks great and plays very similar to highfleet actually when you consider just how vastly different the two games are.

1
Reallycute-Dragon•

Honestly, they scratch a similar itch. There's something about a well-done 2D simulation game that hits all the right spots. They both have expressive chaotic battles with well-done effects. Complete with simulated armor and different ammo types with varied ships.

Star Sector is more on the RTS/CIV side of things where as high fleet is a more compact and condensed experience.

Like you said very different and similar at the same time.

1
Chubby_Seal•

Google Star Sector, then thank me later.

8
Atomidate•

A mix of Star Sector, Highfleet, and The Expanse (TV) would be a dream of a game.

3
AnAverageTeapot•

You honestly read my mind. I've often thought of trying to make something like that.

1
LocatingGoku•

Starsector is a really good game, however, it is lacking in the strategic level warfare that makes Highfleet so unique, a mix of the two with more emphasis in on-the-go ship modifications and an insurgency inspired campaign would be extremely fun to play. A licensed The Expanse game wouldn't really work since the situation is more of a three-way cold war, something more along the lines of Afghanistan in space would both lend itself better to gameplay and keep in tune with Highfleet's aesthetic.

1
osingran•

Man, I honestly had the same thought few hours back as I finished the last Expanse episode. But well, such combination indeed sounds tempting at the first glance, I think it just wouldn't work. Even if we set aside the obvious lack of third dimension, combat in Expanse usually occurs on relatively large distances like at least thousands of kilometers whilst ships speeds are considerably higher than in Highfleet. It's just impossible to combine both long-range and short-range combat in the same package.

1
UpgrayedddddOP•

Well, I think Highfleet does a good job of combining the two, like the cruise missiles are the long range combat (with PDC/CIWS engagement in the terminal phase) and rail guns and PDCs up close and personal.

At the the very least ELINT stuff with telescopes looking for drive signatures and stuff would be fun.

The close in combat might have to change significantly from Highfleet though since body-fixed weapons would be super awkward.

1
ten0re•

Try Empyrion. Shipbuilding is awesome in this game, and very similar to Highfleet.

Also Mechwarrior 5. There's pretty much nothing to do on the strategic map compared to Highfleet, but mech building and combat make up for it.

0
EternaI_Sorrow•

I would not recommend MW5, such a lazy game.

3