r/Destiny•
Latera

Destiny's use of philosophical jargon

Discussion

So in his last discussion with MrGirl destiny tried to explain the term "begging the question" to MrGirl. Correctly, destiny mentioned that many non-philosophers use this term incorrectly - funnily enough, destiny then went on to use the term incorrectly himself.

Destiny basically claimed that begging the question is when an argument mainly or solely relies on a certain premise and there is not much else to discuss except for that premise. While this is not *completely* wrong, this still misunderstands what begging the question fundamentally is. It's totally fine if an argument mainly relies on a certain controversial premise, that happens all the time and is no instance of begging the question. You only beg the question if you put forward a premise, where the only reason why anyone would ever accept that premise would be the fact that they already believe the conclusion. The premise has to already presuppose the truth of the conclusion.

That's why the example that destiny gave is actually no instance of begging the question at all. An argument involving the premise "Group X is genetically predisposed towards committing violence" doesn't necessarily beg the question, because you can believe in that premise even if you don't already accept the conclusion "Group X should be excluded from society" - while it is certainly true that many people who falsely believe the premise also accept the conclusion, the premise still doesn't presuppose the conclusion. For example, there could be a biological study that is supposed to confirm the premise without already assuming the conclusion to be true.

It's really frustrating when destiny tries to use philosophy jargon and then misuses very basic terminology (this has happened numerous times before). He's probably more informed on philosophy than most people, which is admirable, but he still should be more careful about misusing terms in the future.

Posted Jan 2, 2022, 10:33 AM UTC · edited

6519
Raskalnekov•

Idk I kind of have to assume that Destiny was right because he's my cult leader. But I bet a nerd like you would even think THAT'S a fallacy

57
LordDustIV•

He didn't give the best example in this conversation, but I feel like I've heard this exact explanation several times on stream. Sometimes it's just hard to appease the nerds when you're in the middle of a conversation about something else

13
frogglesmash•

How is begging the question different than circular reasoning? Or are they the same thing?

5
BoxSweater•

It's a form of circular reasoning.

10
frogglesmash•

Would saying "murder is bad" be begging the question?

3
BoxSweater•

Funny?

2
frogglesmash•

Lol, mistyped, it's fixed now

5
FrayeFraye•

No, begging the question requires there to be a premise that smuggles in the conclusion.

One interpretation of your statement could be written out as

P1: Murder is defined as unjustified killing of humans
P2: Unjustified killings of humans are bad
C: Murder is bad

This is not begging the question, but rather a very normal conclusion to make. You'd normally say that it's superfluous to spell out that it's bad since we all know the definition of murder, but from a logical standpoint, it's fine.

Usually I see begging the question from theist arguments, e.g.:

P1: Nature has divine beauty
P2: Divine things stem from God
C: God is real, look at the trees look at the rivers blabla

Here we are smuggling in God's existence in the first premise, with the divine beauty. It's probably a shitty example, it's not very often that you find actual begging the question.

Looking at wikipedia, there are some kind of silly examples.

P1: Green is the greenest color
C: Green is the best color

They argue here that there's a hidden premise P2: Greenest is the best color, although I'm not sure if I would agree that it's begging the question, rather than just extending the "greenest" property to "green" and therefore correctly concluding that green is the best color, if you accept the premises.

I guess they wanted to avoid the trivial

P1: Green is the best color
C: Green is the best color

Which truly is the quintessence of begging the question, but about as useless as an example as a "Hello world" program is as an example of a programming language.

EDIT: I would say that if it relies on a premise that you would never accept unless you already believed the conclusion, then it is begging the question.

And yes, it's very hard to distinguish it from circular reasoning imo. (looks like the former is informal and the latter is formal?)

2
tastystrands99•

See also: “Ad hom”

3
LateraOP•

Yeah, many people use the term ad hominem fallacy incorrectly, which is really frustrating. There's nothing fallacious about an argument like "Study X proves that your claim about Covid is wrong and, btw, you are an idiot." This might be rude or unproductive, but it's certainly not fallacious

8

To be clear for those that don’t understand the difference, “your claim about COVID is wrong because you’re an idiot” would be a legitimate Ad Hominem.

Something isn’t an an Ad Hominem just because it attacks a person. It’s an Ad Hominem when the attack is the basis for throwing out the argument.

Something can also be an Ad Hominem without being insulting or a personal attack. “You work for Big Pharma, so your claim about COVID is wrong.”

It’s kind of the opposite of an appeal to authority.

6
IHBBSMTBIAHYABIABMy pronouns are Yee/Yee•

Since idiot is something not well defined (nor something anybody would admit to be) I would still say that's not an instance were the term ad hom should be used.

A better example would be "your claim about covid is wrong because you're an antivaxxer" or "your claim about science thing is wrong because you're religious", antivaxxers could still be right about some things regardless of their idiocy when it comes to vaccines and religious people can know things about science too.

Ad hom isn't always about insults, it almost never is. But you wouldn't know anything about ad homs because you're a dgger.

1
LateraOP•

u/frogglesmash I somehow can't quote you, so here's my response:

That's an excellent question. I would say that begging the question is a particular type of circular reasoning, so I wouldn't say that they are necessarily two completely different things, but are actually very closely connected. In the philosophical literature, those two terms are usually used slightly differently though:The accusation "Author A's argument is circular" usually indicates something like "The structure of A's argument is fundamentally flawed from a logical perspective", whereas the accusation "Author A's argument begs the question" is often used in the sense of "Author A assumes a premise which no opponent of A's position should ever accept and the argument is therefore dialectically worthless".

​

So basically: If an argument is accused of being circular then this usually indicates fundamentally flawed logic, whereas the claim that an argument begs the question usually isn't so much about the logic of the argument, but more about the question: "Is this argument convincing to anyone who doesn't already agree that your conclusion is correct?"

3
Lacher•

One time he got confused over whether "premises" is a word, he ended up thinking it was not the plural of premise because the word was "already reserved for the property sense".

2†
CowardlyLion_•

lol ok nerd

0