Destiny's use of philosophical jargon
So in his last discussion with MrGirl destiny tried to explain the term "begging the question" to MrGirl. Correctly, destiny mentioned that many non-philosophers use this term incorrectly - funnily enough, destiny then went on to use the term incorrectly himself.
Destiny basically claimed that begging the question is when an argument mainly or solely relies on a certain premise and there is not much else to discuss except for that premise. While this is not *completely* wrong, this still misunderstands what begging the question fundamentally is. It's totally fine if an argument mainly relies on a certain controversial premise, that happens all the time and is no instance of begging the question. You only beg the question if you put forward a premise, where the only reason why anyone would ever accept that premise would be the fact that they already believe the conclusion. The premise has to already presuppose the truth of the conclusion.
That's why the example that destiny gave is actually no instance of begging the question at all. An argument involving the premise "Group X is genetically predisposed towards committing violence" doesn't necessarily beg the question, because you can believe in that premise even if you don't already accept the conclusion "Group X should be excluded from society" - while it is certainly true that many people who falsely believe the premise also accept the conclusion, the premise still doesn't presuppose the conclusion. For example, there could be a biological study that is supposed to confirm the premise without already assuming the conclusion to be true.
It's really frustrating when destiny tries to use philosophy jargon and then misuses very basic terminology (this has happened numerous times before). He's probably more informed on philosophy than most people, which is admirable, but he still should be more careful about misusing terms in the future.
Posted Jan 2, 2022, 10:33 AM UTC · edited
Idk I kind of have to assume that Destiny was right because he's my cult leader. But I bet a nerd like you would even think THAT'S a fallacy