aitaeOP•

They should have to prove how they ALL come to the very same price on ALL their services and products. They obvisoly can't have the same costs... infrastructure expansion, employee costs, R&D, etc etc and yet they ALL magically come out with the same prices and same allotments over all tiers? The only difference is seems between them is the bottom tier offerings between Public Mobile vs Chatr vs Lucky Mobile. So easy to see blatant and illegal price fixing.

10
Flash604•

The problem with that logic is that price is not determined solely by costs. Price is largely determined by what the market will bare; a business wants to maximize profit. And having competition often is one of the biggest factors in determining what the market will bare; they won't bare a price higher than your competition if you're providing the same service.

If the Big 3 had joint released a single statement stating what their new prices are then you'd likely have good proof of price fixing. If, instead, a retailer announces that the 3 have had their prices equalize, such as you have here, then more investigation would be necessary to determine how that came about before one could declare price fixing.

8
aitaeOP•

Everything you said I would have wrote down as well, but that's not really what I see. Yes, you have to offer what your competitor does. While it might not be "let's all sit down and set a price", it certainly shows some sort of "silent agreement". I am not sure of the word for it. If they were acting like competitors, there would be a race to the bottom in terms of price and since they all float at the same spot AND post extremely healthy profits. I am sure there is a solution, but i don't know what it looks like to break this "silent agreement".

1
Lewl77•

Yes, it's competition. Just not the kind that we consumers want. They are competing as to who can raise the price the most while retaining customers. So long as no one breaks the cycle by competing downwards, they always win because they'll back each other up by increasing rates and fees to match. Once freedom is removed from the picture they'll be able to increase the speed at which they raise rates without any worry.

1
jt325i•

That is a good deal. The big 3 do all sit down together to hash out minutes/texts/data alotments at key price points. They all win when they offer the same services at the same price points. They also have to lobby the politicians in the federal government with bribes to make sure they look the other way and dont go after them in the court system.

10
rootbrian_•

Pretty insidious if you ask me.

1
Born-Hunter9417•

Well... We all know price fixing has been happening for the last decade and they keep getting away from it.

1