r/taekwondo•
rfabbri

Flexibility vs strength

Is a flexible body weaker overall than an unflexible one? It would seem that loose tendons might offer less support for really strong kicks, for example. Not sure if I am trying to talk myself out of attaining full splits at age 41, they seem attainable but quite unnatural.. Anyways I suppose a flexible body will need better muscle fitness to provide added support, at the least.

Posted Jan 4, 2022, 1:22 AM UTC

1915
supportdesk_online•

For sure. If you're too flexible your leg may just flop around like a wet noodle when you try and kick. Will totally be out of control.

My guy, don't be lazy - just stretch. We've all been there

36
rfabbriOP•

lol

8
Sparks701•

Gulity, lol Im following this starting today.

1
98Vader•

same lmao

1
Ellasandro2nd Dan•

Flexibility and Strength work together synergistically to create mobility.

For a beginner athlete, both can be trained/improved at the same time.

For an intermediate athlete, both can improve, but they have to be trained separately.

For an advanced athlete, they eventually become antagonistic and one must be trained in preference over the other. However, if you're not deadlifting 500 pounds, you're not there so don't worry about it.

19
WishBear192nd Dan•

I've been doing TKD for 5 days a week on average for the past 3 years. I also do HIIT workouts everyday. So in other words my legs get a good workout and are strong. At 39 my goal is to be able to do the splits by 40. I was doing my own routine for a while, but in mid December started doing formal stretch workouts for the splits from an app. It's an additional 20-25 minutes to what I normally do and for the the first time in a long time sections of my legs are actually sore after a workout. I'm working parts of my body that are usually missed even with leg heavy workouts. In order to become more flexible you have to strengthen parts of your body to support yourself in different positions.

TLDR; increasing your flexibility makes your body, and therefore your kicks, stronger.

12
Suvid123WT 2nd Dan•

No. Flexibility increases the strength of kicks. This is because flexibility increases the range of motion of your foot so it gets easier to do kicks which make them stronger. If you can gain additional flexibility and the ability to kick higher the power of your lower kicks will be increased because they are no longer at the edge of your foots range of motion. If you don’t understand what I mean try doing a round kick to the belt level and see how powerful it is. Then do a round kick to the head level and see how powerful it is. The lower kick probably has more power because it is not at the edge of your range of motion. So if you gain more flexibility the power of your kicks at all heights you can currently kick now will increase because they are farther from your maximum range of motion.

In summary flexibility makes your kicks more powerful, a full split is definitely attainable with consistent stretching and don’t be lazy.

7
sadboi03•

Basically, making tendons more elastic by stretching (not overstretching mind you) is actually a good thing lol, and also making muscles more flexible has been known to be a good thing for a long time, due to greater range of motion which then allows for more force production, less injury chance, and a few other things im forgetting.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2658965/
you could read through the whole thing, but the two boxes and conclusion sum up everything relevant pretty well

but yeah, flexibility overall, in muscle and tendons, is just about universally accepted to be beneficial for athletic performance, and also day to day quality of life.

Get to stretching, but obviously warm up and dont rip apart your body going too intense too fast, adding more muscle isnt a requirement so to say, but there is no real downside apart from an increase in cardiovascular demand from your body.

So maybe if you have time, stretch, build muscle, and run/up your cardio

5
Nakmuay255•

Sport science background here.

Flexibility increases overall power production.

4
Lvl3burnvictim-86WTF•

Typically the reason that anyone just starting some kind of activity that requires flexibility doesn't have it is that their prior experiences have trained their muscles for strength. Over training strength and neglecting flexibility training will stop you from kicking high. And over training flexibility without strength will stop you from having control while doing so. It goes both ways

3

That is when gymnastics helps your training, its training strength, AND flexibility.

2
love2kik7th Dan MDK, 5th Dan WT/KKW•

While tendons, ligaments, bones, and muscles work together, they each have different functions. In short, muscle strengthening and the ability to elongate and two different things. And while it is easier for some than others, it is necessary to increase the range of motion. It will Not weaken the muscles, much the opposite. But they do need to be done in concert. Generally, in the MA's world, as long as a person is working, kicking, and stretching in regular classes, that is enough strengthening so accommodate extra stretching. Study up on static and dynamic stretching and find a good balance.

I do think a person with above average flexibility who only works on stretching can create an imbalance between flexibility and strength, becoming somewhat 'gumby' like. I have seen this in kids.

You last sentence hits the nail on the head.

2
Naryn_Tin-Ahhe3rd Dan•

Flexibility is strength through a wide range of positions. They are the same. Most common cause of inflexibility is weakness outside of a certain range. That's why strength training can help with flexibility.

2
lothiavan•

You're 41 some yoga will benefit you a lot more than you would think. Strength and mobility will help a ton

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
HADESmusicundrgrnd•

Yes. Your spine for instance. If you're constantly stretching it both ways you're essentially weakening it and risking injury. Like a metal rod. You can't just snap and break it, but opposite pulls and done repetitively can cause serious damage. A stretchy muscle won't be as strong as a solid one.

-4