Many people here have claimed to have read the Bible...
I'm just wondering who actually has and if they understand the basic concepts of Christianity.
Posted Apr 6, 2012, 9:02 PM UTC
I'm just wondering who actually has and if they understand the basic concepts of Christianity.
Posted Apr 6, 2012, 9:02 PM UTC
What basic concepts? Women as property? Being denied entry to the kingdom of heaven if you're not sorry enough for being human or you don't believe in a cosmic Jewish zombie? You're going to have to be a little more specific.
Things like accepting Jesus is what gets you into heaven, God created free will, etc.
I'm an atheist by the way. Just want to know what people know about the bible
I got my bachelor's from a private baptist institution. We had to take several classes about the impact of religion on western culture as graduation requirements. To these classes' professors' credit, despite one of them being catholic and the other Lutheran, they were extremely objective in their teachings.
The final paper for the final class was something like 15 pages using the bible as a primary source, with heavy emphasis placed on an arbitrary book of our choice within the bible, and analyze a theme. Any theme. Left a lot of leeway. This devout Lutheran professor, who had travelled the world to conduct religious studies, perform missions, etc. passed me with high marks after I turned in a final paper blasting the bible for being patriarchal and pointing out how even as early as the book of Genesis, women were considered second-class citizens at best and property at worst. I did it without even having to go very far into the chapters considered "patriarchal history."
Between those three classes, yes. I am quite familiar with western religions, especially Judaism and Christianity. I didn't delve into any other books quite as deeply as I did Genesis, but my familiarity with them does exceed cursory. I'm far from a biblical scholar, but well enough acquainted to have smelled a lot of bullshit.
edit: I guess it wasn't entirely religion. We also covered Hobbes, Locke, Nietzsche, Paine, a work titled Malleus Maleficarum, and other influential writings in western history that have had a lasting impact on our culture. The emphasis was largely religion, though, because it's still highly visible.
Interesting. Are you an atheist?
I am.
This one? I mean if you actually know what you're talking about that's cool I guess, I wasn't singling you out or anything. I could argue with you about your rhetoric but it probably wouldn't really matter.
I calls 'em as I sees 'em.
Read it in Army Basic Training, we were only allowed to read Military or Religious material. Read both the old and new testament fully.
What did you think of it?
It was.....interesting. I really look at it more of a collection of myths not anything to be taken seriously.
I also re read it several times there.
I was a devout Christian up until the age of 20, so yeah.
Good to hear. Glad you converted to atheism (I think).
it's called "reverting"
I've not read cover to cover but I had to take a bible class in college. We were assigned sections to read and discuss.
I fully understand the basic concepts of christianity and reject them as evil, especially the christian version of God.
If I die and it turns out that the christian God does exist, I will spit in his face at the 'judgement bar'.
I've read the whole thing (not cover to cover, but every part at least once at some point) because I was a somewhat serious Christian at one point.
I'm going to assume a lot of people here haven't though. I actually decided to just check this subreddit out today out of boredom, and to my disappointment it's just as stupid (on the whole) as any other gathering place for atheists on the internet. Oh well.
well the important thing is...
Indeed. There is a lot of misconceptions about Christianity and quotes from the Bible in this subreddit.
[deleted]
I'm going to assume a lot of people here haven't though.
See my post above.
so brave. You even called Jesus a zombie. That's so inflammatory and original dude. Are you sure you're not afraid of offending anyone?
Was dead and rose? Is that not the definition of a zombie?
so so brave
That's not the one I was talking about.
Feel free to check yourself out then.
During my 22 years as a Christian I probably read about 85% of the Bible at one time or another. I've never read it all in one go though. I was a counselor at a Bible Camp for 5 years. During that time I went to chapel services 3 times a day for entire summers, studying the Bible and memorizing huge chunks of scripture.
So yes, I would say I am pretty well-studied on the Bible and the basic concepts of Christianity. Despite that, many Christians I speak to still assume that because I no longer believe I must not have really understood the material, I must have never truly believed.
if they understand the basic concepts of Christianity.
that is like asking if someone understands the basic concepts of Star Trek...it means what ever a fan thinks it means and every pair of fans will disagree... the only difference is star trek fans actually know the plots and trivia even if they do not get the concepts.
Agreed. Bad wording on my part.
The problem is "the basic concepts of Christianity". Every christian believes these are something different. I've not only read the bible (more than once; studying out of different versions), I've also studied various beliefs of different denominations (and went through a few myself in my search for truth).
The biggest problem I have talking to christians is that even the ones that have actually read the bible (not many of them) usually still only have understanding of the ideas taught by their particular sect. So if, for example, I point out the flaws in the idea of the trinity, I may be informed that the one I'm talking to is a united pentacostal that beliefs in the "oneness" and I'm stupid/ignorant for not knowing about the oneness (even though I do, I just guessed wrong about which flavor of christian they are). This, in their eyes, makes me look ignorant of christianity, even though it's clear that far more often than not, I know quite a bit more than the one I'm talking to. I realize that probably sounds presumptuous and arrogant, but I'm not going to lie to spare feelings here; just understand that this is not a source of pride for me.
Whenever it seems like a christian is actually willing to discuss their beliefs with me (rather than just throw them at me a run away), I have to spend an exhausting amount of time going through various takes on different beliefs figure out which combination of options they subscribe to before we can even begin to have a meaningful conversation.
Well, I did go to Catholic school for three years...and I also had to go through confirmation classes for the Lutheran church....
I read the bible. I even read the really stupid boring parts in the OT. My grandmother on my fathers side made me do it. She also made me memorize all the books of the bible in order, and a 100 bible verses. That was over 20 years ago and I still thought it was BS back then. My first doubts in Christianity were caused by that little escapade.
I've read through the bible four times. All as an ardent believer. I feel as though I have a fairly thorough understanding of the basic concepts. I have very good reason not to believe it anymore though.
Yeah, I read it at university, cos the Gideons put one in my room in halls. I admit I skipped a lot of the 'begats' though. We had a children's illustrated version when I was little too, but it was treated just like any other book of fairytales by both me and my family.
I thought it was interesting. The stories were ok, bit dull in places.. Bit preachy. Didn't find any of it enlightening or useful. Have no desire to revisit.
As for the 'concepts' of Christianity.. I don't know. As far as I can tell this differs depending on which Christian you speak to. Everyone seems to think it backs up the views they already have.
[deleted]
I've read the bible three times. However, many concepts of Christianity are extra-biblical, (transubstantiation, emasculate conception, Trinitarian theory, papal authority, etc.)
I was devout for a long time, read the Bible three times all the way through (and large parts of it more than that).
I have not read the Bible I probably should it sounds awesome genocide mass rapes cannibalism it sounds more distructive to a child's mind than the movie pink flamingos sk of corse I have to read it some day but not yet I haven't finished looking off into space yet
no i haven't, I'm not big on mythology never have been. It just doesn't hold my interest. I've tried reading it, but I get bored really quick.