r/Malazan•
umpesh

Never read malazan before...can I start at The God is Not Willing?

NO SPOILERS

Basically the title. Can I start at the first book in the Tale of the Witness? I don't really have time to read all of malazan, but I could do so over a period of 2-3 years. Is it safe to start this new book just to get a feel of what Erikson is about, or should I rather go through with reading the entire series?

Posted Jan 6, 2022, 5:18 PM UTC

920

If you start with tGinW, you'll be thrown into a world you don't understand with references to people and places thrown out without explanation, expecting you to pick it up as you go along. But if you start with Gardens of the Moon, you'll be thrown into a world you don't understand with references to people and places thrown out without explanation, expecting you to pick it up as you go along. It's kinda Erikson's style.

I'd say the main downside to reading tGinW before the main ten is that it'll spoil for you some of the events in the main ten. If you're okay with that, then I think it's an okay place to start before deciding whether you want to commit to 3 million words. It stands fine on its own as its own self-contained story.

68
Logbotherer99•

Love it.

8
umpeshOP•

Thank you!

2
Boronian13rd Re-Read MBotF•

I mean, you can read whatever you want. It is just like reading the first book of a sequel series meaning you miss out a lot of context and understanding.

I would not recommend it.

25
ShivonQ•

It would be wildly confusing and contains a million spoilers for the original 10.

18
nerdhell•

It’s really not, if you’ve read even a little bit of the original series. I actually had an easier time folllwing it than I do the main books.

1
Theabstractsound•

The “God“ who is not willing is one of the main characters of the 10 book series. Erickson definitely wrote this book with the expectation that readers would know the main 10.

Unlike the other books outside of the main 10, the new book is a A chronological continuation. I know some readers are saying it would be just as confusing as starting the main series, but I don’t think they’re fully acknowledging how much their awareness of the main characters, the cultures involved, and all of the Marines and their history play into everything else.

13
zhilia_mannjaghut•

I've advocated tGiNW as a potential entry point to the world before and even I'm not convinced it's a great idea.

On the plus side, it's a relatively short, relatively self-contained story that does highlight Erikson's style. Beyond that it's on the comprehensible side (as long as you can convince yourself to just go with the flow and not second guess what's happening). While not his best book, it's a fine one and it does give you a sense for the flavor of his other writing.

But on the negative, well, it does lean heavily in to implications of events of both MBotF and NotME as a starting point. Characters make reference to those events -- even if they aren't fully understood. While nothing is explicitly spelled out the spoilers are real. Even setting that aside, tGiNW throws an awful lot at you if you're not already familiar with the world; Erikson is writing for an audience assumed familiar already (as he should). Even by his standards there's not a ton of hand-holding (and his bar is very low on that already).

So I'm not convinced. It's a better option than, say, Forge of Darkness but that's not saying much.

If you were to want to dip your toes in and see if the style works for you you might try Midnight Tides. Yes, it's the fifth book of the series, but it introduces a new continent and an entirely new storyline with very little overlap to the first four books (the overlap comes in the next five books of course).

Why start there?

  1. It's a better self-contained story than Gardens of the Moon
  2. Erikson's writing style has matured significantly by MT and better represents what the rest of the series looks like
  3. Gardens is just a little disappointing period
  4. Both books throw you in the deep end and expect you to keep up; you might as well try it with a better book, especially if you're undecided on the series as a whole

If you were to go that route I'd then suggest doing MBotF in order, including rereading Midnight Tides after House of Chains to make sure you're up to speed when it starts crossing over with other stories (which starts in The Bonehunters and really gets rolling in Reaper's Gale).

And there you go. Far too many words to say "sure, you could, but try this instead".

11
KellamLekrow•

And as the god himself would say, "too many words" lmao

Solid advice. Came here to say this.

4
Assiniboia•

TLDR: if you just want a taste, the short tales of Bauchelain and Korbal Broach are a good option. The novellas are a little more wild and free than the series are, but it gives you a sense of pace and style.

There are some minor spoilers, but it’s mostly the loss of context that will hurt the read. As a book it will stand just fine solo.

I suspect it was meant to allow an entry point for new readers, because a lot of the content from the main series is barely alluded to, and not in ways which jeopardize those plot lines. (Well, except for part of House of Chains, sorta).

But it does exist after…and some of the themes have a little more depth with that background.

9
transientcat•

+1 for the Midnight Tides suggestion. Even in Malazan MT is jarring for a lot of readers because it's the 3rd(?) time SE drops you into a completely new setting with basically no context. It doesn't really spoil future events of the books and chronologically it takes place before Book 1.

That being said, I would just read Gardens of the Moon.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
AnomandarisPurake1•

I say go for it, because it will be a fun experiment. Definitely tell us of your experience. I've no idea how well it will work, but'll definitely be an unique experience!

3
Happy_CycleR•

Why do people do this to themselves?

Just read GotM.

3
Fair_UniversityTeblor•

I actually kind of think it would work fine. You’ll miss a lot of references and it’ll spoil the main ten in a lot of ways (but not all). I think you’ll be able to understand it though

2
an0nymite•

But...

Why?

2
TCristatus•

Kinda like watching the Force Awakens before any of the first 6

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Sword_In_A_Puddle•

NO

1
AnXit86•

Hahahaha

1
nerdhell•

You should probably read up through the beginning of house of chains but after that, yolo

Citation: I did it

1
Soletaken-Eleint•

No, you should have the same experience like the rest of us i.e. confused af in GotM.

1