r/civ5•
Stew_Long

Has anybody else had AI propose a deal (in my case it was mutual open borders), only to rescind the offer when you try to accept it?

Discussion

I want to get a feel for how common this is. I am playing a domination only game on deity as Korea, and was the first to build nuclear missiles, and it has the entire world losing their minds. It's hilarious and gratifying after a game of mad hostility, but the behavior I have outlined in this post is particularly uncouth, and frankly I am baffled. Can someone explain why the AI would do this?

Posted Jan 7, 2022, 1:27 AM UTC

4611
pjs144:Netherlands:•

They usually say this when they rescind the offer :

"This deal has faded before our eyes..." It means they don't think the deal is fair and want more to renew the deal

26
mecpaw:Hanging_Gardens: Tradition•

The AI is programed to "offer" the last deal you had even though it won't accept terms as is.

23
KalegNar:Domination_victory: Domination Victory•

What happens is that they've grown to like you less since the deal was last made.

Suppose you make a deal with Spain. You give Spain citrus for 30 turns and Spain gives you 7 gold per turn.

In between then you go on a warmonger rampage. Spain hates your warmongering and denounces you.

Now 30 turns later Spain is coming to you about renewing a deal, but not the original. So they won't give you 7 gpt, but maybe you'll get 4 gpt. That's where the denying a deal they offered comes into play.

Like someone else mentioned, if you read the text you'll notice a "This deal has faded in our eyes."

12
Ok-Goose-8930•

I’ve had this happen to me. I believe it’s only been when I’ve tried to alter the deal to see if they had anything better I could counter with. If not countering and returning to the original the AI offered sometimes they reject it for no known reason.

5
TheKingofNeptune•

It happens to me 2-3 times every game I play. It throws me off at first since I'm positive I didn't change the deal they offered.

2
jeihot:Brazil:•

Side note: offer 2GPT for the OB. Much better than opening your borders and the AI will almost always accept it - unless they hate you or something.

2
B_I_S_O_N•

I've had it happen multiple time. I think it's when you try to change the offer,then put the initial offer back,sometimes they'll decline it.

1
White_Lord:Forbidden_Palace: Patronage•

Are you sure they were proposing that deal in the first place?

Sometimes AI contact you to tell you that they don't want to renew a previous deal. In the trade screen you see the same conditions (like mutual open borders) but if you read the message they say something like "we don't like this deal anymore and you must offer something else if you want to renew it".

1
gifford42•

I thought this was happening to me for a long time then I realized the AI was saying “this deal has faded in our eyes” or something like that and will show you the same trade offer but you’ll need to further incentivize them to accept the deal.

1
Loupak_•

It's a special way of asking you to nuke them. At least that's how I interpret it. Waste my time? Eat a nuke.

1
Syrinocs•

Not just open borders, just deals in general like for luxury trades.

1