I'm financially ready for my STI Hatch! Where do I find one??

I've been on austerity measures through my 20's and early 30's to clear my student loans and after a few years since then, I have the cash available to buy my dream STI hatch!

I'm of course camping all the usual BaT, CaB, Autotempest, etc. but does anyone have any smaller private shops that deal in FINDING cars that aren't a mess under the hood or sitting at 120k miles? I do not mind paying a small commission (I mean BaT takes 5% on top anyway for literally just having a website) but I don't know about any.

Has anyone used their dealer? I have a great one in upstate NY here I trust but not sure if it's even worth reaching out.

I love you all and wish you a pleasant rumbly snowy morning!

EDIT: THE GODS HAVE SMILED UPON ME! Drove 12 hours each way for a 60,000mi 2 owner Texas/Arizona/Southern Ohio car. Stock everything other than a full exhaust and the original motor. Someone loved this car and now I will too. I'll post some pictures when I clean it from the snowy ride home to NY. I had been looking for 9 months BTW, day after I make this post, one popped up and for ONCE I was the first to call the seller.

Posted Jan 8, 2022, 9:13 AM UTC · edited

2472
Fredfunkin•

Those old hatchback STIs have been beat to shit. Good luck.

84
Aetherpor•

I don’t get why someone wouldn’t buy an older one anyways. It’s an STI engine, not a Ferrari costwise. If he doesn’t mind paying a commission then he can afford a new engine. Just need the interior and exterior to be in clean condition.

-4
DailyKnowledgeBombOPGR STI DGM•

This sounds like a person that hasn't already gone to see 5 STIs with blown engines as I have

1
Aetherpor•

That’s precisely my point though. You can treat the engines as blown already or ready to blow. If the interior and exterior is in great condition, then just budget for an engine rebuild.

Let’s run some rough estimate numbers. A quick google search says a 2014 STI hatch is about $26k right now. If you were willing to pay a 10% finder’s fee, which is $2.6k, that’d go a long way. I vaguely remember the Vinwiki guy talking about a 10% finder’s fee for rare cars. Even at BaT 5% that’d be $1.3k cost. You can rebuild an STI engine for $3k, it’s not a Ferrari rebuild in terms of cost. And then you get an engine that you KNOW is fresh.

You can downvote me, but you can’t deny that the point I’m trying to make about $28.6k vs $29k not being a big difference isn’t completely nonsensical, especially if $29k is a fresh engine.

To put it another way, if someone told me “they were looking for a rare $26k car and was going to put up a finder’s fee for $2.6k but decided to spend $400 more to fix up one instead”, I wouldn’t think they were an idiot, I’d say “hmm I can see how that’s a reasonable option”.

That’s all I’m trying to suggest- another “not completely unreasonable” option for you to chase, if you truly were struggling to find your dream car.

1
DailyKnowledgeBombOPGR STI DGM•

It's not just $3k for the engine rebuilt. Blown engine usually means everything is blown.

I understand your point and am not being disrespectful as text on a screen can easily be inferred but where is this car you talk about? Lord knows every STI I've seen with a blown engine has a laundry list of other things that need fixed too. I've seen these blown cars in person and I have to knowledge to understand what I'm looking at.

Nothing scares any owner who "just needs a new motor" more than when you open the fuse box or pull the panels under the steering wheel off to look at the state of what wiring you can see. When they see you pull the jack out of your trunk they usually have a lot more to add than "just needs a motor".

It's also 120,000 miles on every piece of rattley Subaru plastic, ball joint, bushing, nut and bolt, arm, top hat, suspension. Or... I find one with 60,000 miles where that's not an issues until 5 years from now.

Cheers friend!

3
throwawayblue900ss•

The Vape convention.

58
throwawayblue900ss•

Thank you for the award, kind stranger. lol

-8
Arben72Too Many•

I’ve purchased a few cars from forums (NASIOC being one) and off of Facebook groups. I wouldn’t go to a dealer for a used car they don’t have on their lot. Automotive brokers do exist, but usually in higher end cars as their fees can be pricey.

21
DailyKnowledgeBombOPGR STI DGM•

I've got NASIOC on notify as well, they are an excellent resource but the cars are usually IAG/local shop built projects. Someone always seems to be getting rid of their dream car 3,000 miles after they put 10k into it. Signals it's a complete and total headache or why wouldn't you be keeping your investment :(

Just want a clean STI hatch with <60k miles stock enough to take to a dealer/shop for service

Any listing online where they don't post a picture of the engine bay is a huge red flag too unfortunately. Usually when contacting them and finally getting one shows it's all bubblegum and duct tape under the hood

Edit: Are you aware of any quality brokers? Googling "auto broker" is a shitshow. I wouldn't mind at least starting a conversation with one

7
withsexyresults19 CTR•

U might need a lot more patience for one to pop up with those requirements. The hatch sti came out 10 years ago so you’re looking for an owner who averaged 6k miles when average is 10-12k. And close to stock when this platform is popular for mods. Wouldn’t be surprised if stock + low miles commands a premium

20
gik0geck0Replace this text with year, make, model•

IAG blocks are great. I suggest including IAG certified installers it your search.

My stock STI blew a motor, and I feel safer with an IAG block. TBH, I contemplated getting rid of it right after fixing it, just because of sticker shock. But I'm glad I didn't, and chose to add power instead. No regrets.

2
PaperScale99 Impreza Coupe, 85 Brat, 89 k2500, 17 Golf Sportwagen•

Outfront would be a better engine choice tbh. They have better tolerances and are better for a "lightly modded" replacement. The IAG ones are built more sloppy with the intent to just slap an assload of boost at it

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

14
[deleted]•

Buy one with higher miles and invest in a built motor

11
DailyKnowledgeBombOPGR STI DGM•

I was on that path but I FOUND A UNICORN. 2 owner Texas/Southern Ohio car. Just picked it up and it's flawless, original engine and everything is clean. Someone loved this car.

1
Curly_Cucumber1997 Miata / 2017 Audi S5•

Where did you find it? Let’s see some pics!

1
DailyKnowledgeBombOPGR STI DGM•

Down in southern Ohio! Drove 12 hours on one day's notice. I called 90 minutes after the posting and was the third caller but I was available next day with a trade on my WRX and the rest in cash. I'll post pictures when she's clean from the snowy drive home to NY!

1
Curly_Cucumber1997 Miata / 2017 Audi S5•

Kickass, congrats!! I hope you enjoy. I’ll be waiting for some pics!! Hahah.

I more meant where as in like.. what method did you use? Facebook marketplace, Cargurus, etc?

1
lolparty247•

He's not ready.

  • future bank account anticipating rod departure.
10
DailyKnowledgeBombOPGR STI DGM•

I have $7000 more saved for repairs and Cost of Ownership so yes, I am ready. I will also be paying the difference between my trade and the STI in cash. Not everyone on here is 21 just getting their first job.

1
esoterikk21 Veloster N, 03 JDM Forester STI•

If you are shopping for an STI hatch be sure you have an extra 3k on top of purchase price to replace the short block if the previous owner was a moron.

Finding a well maintained Subaru is like finding a unicorn. Most of them are running 5w30 and 91 octane with random mods and a Cobb OTS tune

9
jotegr03 Pathfinder LE/Norco Aurum HSP•

Out of curiosity, what are Canadian STI owners to run instead of 91?

2
esoterikk21 Veloster N, 03 JDM Forester STI•

It's less the 91 and more the 91 + bad mods mixed with Cobb OTS tune. The Cobb tunes are so bad Canadians have to run the AZ 91 tune to run safe but must will just stick terrible Canadian gas in there a run a full on stage 1 ots which is incredibly on the edge for your motor.

91 is fine on a protune or a stock tune and with no mods, any mod needs to be tuned for.

3
STRMfrmXMN05 Subaru LGT Wagon 5MT•

Cobb tunes are pretty conservative and are not “bad.” It would be worse for most cars to have them be amped up as much as possible with a dyno tune and consequentially lose a lot of the driveability that comes with big-name tuning. Things like the throttle being touchy or jerky, aggressive timing tables, etc, are common with dyno tuning.

If the car has been modified beyond what Cobb tunes are accounted for then yes, that would be good to have tuned on a dyno.

3
esoterikk21 Veloster N, 03 JDM Forester STI•

Cobb OTS tunes are notoriously poor and that's not accounting for the fact that they are made only for specific Cobb parts.

I'm not sure where you heard that Cobb OTS were great but a protune from a good tuner will be significantly smoother for multiple reasons. Elevation, Fuel quality, and temperature alone play a big part in your tune not to mention other factors, even the factory tune can be a bit aggressive in this case.

https://youtu.be/SMa-VvnhJCU

He talks more about OTS tunes here, we personally never recommend them because we have seen more customers come in with engine failures running Cobb tunes than any other tuner, stratified and ammbot generally seem good and torque performance is probably my favorite, our tuner has put torque tuned cars on the dyno and said he barely had to make any changes at all which is impressive considering the amount of FBK and FBKL and DAM adjustments we see from Cobb.

3
jotegr03 Pathfinder LE/Norco Aurum HSP•

Thanks for explanation! I'm always curious to hear this sort of stuff when it comes to tuning and terrible Canadian gas.

1
becomings1990 Mazda Miata (NA)•

I know in Vancouver the Subaru crowd goes for 94, can’t remember what station has it though. I want to say Chevron

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
DailyKnowledgeBombOPGR STI DGM•

I have $7000 extra and will be paying the difference for my trade in cash. Like I said, I'm ready.

1
BrokenToast3r•

What’s your budget for a clean STi hatch under 60k miles? I know a person that has a last year Black 2014 STi Hatch w/ 18k miles stock.

8
DailyKnowledgeBombOPGR STI DGM•

I FOUND A UNICORN

I paid $25,500 for a 2011 STI with 61,000mi. 2 owner Texas/Southern Ohio car with the original engine and not even a cold air intake.

If your friend is really selling that car? It should go on Cars&Bids or Bring a Trailer. He'll fetch low $30000.

1
BrokenToast3r•

Awesome! Congrats, that’s a great price for the mileage and year. I’m a big fan of the Hatch STi as it’s the only STi hatch model ever produced. Yea, I think my buddy is looking to get the high 30s to low 40 referencing what those low mileage STi sold for on BAT.

1
DailyKnowledgeBombOPGR STI DGM•

He will easily get that. Unfortunately I'm too frugal for that game and had to do the leg work of hunting myself instead of BaT or CaB. Those sites are for people who just want the cleanest possible and will pay $5000 too much for it.

1
TVR_Speed_1297 Mazda Miata, 06 Mazda 6•

You living my dreams. I want to get a STi one day but my budget really only allows for 100k plus mileage.

Try Autotempest. You can search multiple sites. Get familiar with the engine bay. If it has a STi logo on the IC then it's modified.(only 02-07 have the STi logo) No water sprayer either, but you get avcs on the exhaust side and a slightly lower redline. (6200 vs 7)

08-10 Seats are different from 11+. Hatches never got full leather only the sedans did. Also no moonroof for hatch STis.

3
DailyKnowledgeBombOPGR STI DGM•

No moonroof on the hatches? That funny I was wondering why they were all slick tops but just figured that moonroof was only on the Limited lol

1
TVR_Speed_1297 Mazda Miata, 06 Mazda 6•

Yeah it's something that surprised me aswell but I guess it's the way the hatch is constructed

1
DailyKnowledgeBombOPGR STI DGM•

I hate moonroofs anyway, sun burns my bald spots.

1
Ajaxguy132012 Land Rover LR4 HSE•

While I’d love one too I decided the more intelligent (maybe not financially) thing to do would buy a gr corolla and drive it into the ground. I already have a deposit down at the dealer for if/when it arrives

3
DailyKnowledgeBombOPGR STI DGM•

I want an STI. I think it is amazing that Toyota in bring the GR platform here for the corolla but it's not a STI with the rumble. I didn't dream about a GR Corolla as a child :)

Now... if the STI hatch I just bought (found a great one) decides it is ready for the grave in 10 years, the GR Corolla will be top of the list to replace it!

2
TVR_Speed_1297 Mazda Miata, 06 Mazda 6•

Don't drive it into the ground. The 2nd owner is waiting please

-3
ChapinLakersFan•

Lmao this is why we don't get nice things. Put your money where your mouth is.

5
GhostRedditWRX STI•

Unless you're really really committed to the hatch get a new sedan. It's a better, stiffer platform and realistically it's going to cost about the same, maybe a few k more than one of the old hatches.

Used STIs are a crapshoot, you may have better luck with a Golf R or something if you really want a hatch but if it's really your dream car you're probably on the right sites already for a clean one but I'd also look at facebook marketplace if you haven't already, a lot of private sales are moving to there instead of CL or autotrader.

3
DailyKnowledgeBombOPGR STI DGM•

I have a VA WRX and I love it but I want the EJ engine with unequal length headers and if those are the needs then hatch is a must.

New Camaro has more power and rides better than a 1971 but which would you want to drive?

1
GhostRedditWRX STI•

The VA STI has the EJ25 with unequal headers though. The engine package hasn't changed, just the body style.

2
DailyKnowledgeBombOPGR STI DGM•

I thought they moved to equal length on teh VA, my bad!

2

Get a Miata instead. Jokes asisde though all I can say is, don't rush. Wait and be patient until the perfect one comes by. Since you have the money, don't settle for a modded out shit box.

2
DailyKnowledgeBombOPGR STI DGM•

I live in the snow belt. This is just the first of a few "end game" cars for the garage. Miata is on that list for sure. So is that new Z but I will wait until it's been out a few years. Have a feeling Nissan is going to make that car for 10 years then reintroduce the Z as electric, I'll have time for that car.

1
HeshootsHescores882019 Ford Ranger •

Keep an alert on CarsandBids

2
TubaCharles99Replace this text with year, make, model•

My biggest piece of advice is be willing to travel for that car. Willing to travel and drive 1k miles will make your search so much better at finding one. A lot of them are probably beat up

2
Broad_RockReplace this text with year, make, model•

Bring a Trailer for sure. Going to be expensive but the cars sold there are only the best. Might have too wait a little bit for a hatch to show up

1
PurpleSausage77•

If I couldn’t find a clean STI hatch, I’d rather go for a MK7 Golf R, much better/responsive platform for mods. Expensive as heck to get power out of Subaru if that’s what you’re going for. Golf R would be a better higher quality daily as well.

1

Hope you find what you are looking for but a wrx sedan would open up a lot more options if you are willing to amend the dream slightly.

1
Creativeusername833Replace this text with year, make, model•

Buy a civic type r instead

1
BoonTobiasHellcat Town &amp; Country•

Sorry to hear about your austerity but no worries, people here are very friendly and I'm sure you will find the exact car you like 😊

1
Curly_Cucumber1997 Miata / 2017 Audi S5•

Good luck. I’ve been on a hunt for a stock under 80k mile STI hatch (11-14 ideally) for the past month or so. I haven’t found a single one.. and the ones that I have found have 10k miles and owners are asking 45k. Lol. Nuts.

I test drove one and was instantly sold on the driving feel. It’s just a nightmare to find a clean one.

1
DailyKnowledgeBombOPGR STI DGM•

I FOUND ONE! 60,000 miles, original everything for $25,500. After my trade it was $7000 cash.

I got it because I called 90 minutes after it was posted and went to buy it 12 hours away the next day. The seller told me he got 4 more calls the same day (after I paid him so it wasn't a hard sell) and has gotten 4-6 calls a day since.

1
DailyKnowledgeBombOPGR STI DGM•

Took me 9 months with money in hand to find mine. If you want one, you got to be on the sites EVERY DAY unfortunately to wade through a sea of 120kmi examples or front intercooler amateur modded junk.

1