Another ridiculous tire question

I have a 2017 Crosstrek Limited and finally in need of new tires. OEM tires are Yokohama Geolander G95 (everywhere online says G91 but mine is the G95 and those are way more expensive than the G91s and dont know why). Great tire that has lasted me well over 62000 miles at this point. My question is what if any specifically all season tire do you guys like? Usage is probably 90% road, 9% forrest roads and 1% snow. I am looking at the goodyear weatherreadys. Please, obliterate me in the comments if my question is on the verge of utter insanity given there are countless options for me that likely wont have much of a discernible difference. Thanks

edit; didnt mean to put second question mark

Posted Jan 11, 2022, 5:05 AM UTC

1628
roflmaozedong•

I really like my Falken Wildpeak AT Trails. I won’t go mudding in them, but this winter has been especially snowy in the Puget Sound and they have handled great throughout (they are all weather 3PMSF). Also very good on gravel and paved. They are designed specifically for crossovers like the Crosstrek and RAV4. No discernible changes in road noise or mileage for me. Will get again for sure.

14
not_a_meme_farmer•

Literally planning on getting these for an 18’ Crosstrek in the next couple weeks. From my scouring of Reddit and forums the past month, If you are staying OEM wheel these are a great tire; can’t recall for lift kits and changed wheel size though.

3
roflmaozedong•

I have the ‘21 limited and mounted them on the stock rims. They look and perform great.

1
winnipegjets31•

How bad was the mpg loss tho

1
rez_at_dorsia•

There should not be much of any, they are specifically designed for the Crosstrek and are really the only tire you can get that isn’t going to have some sort of heavily negative trade-off.

4
winnipegjets31•

Hmmmmm. I’m heavily debating them. I drive like 60 miles to work all highway, not sure if it’s worth it or if I should just get tourings or something.

1
rez_at_dorsia•

I would say, if you don’t deal with snow or take them on any trails, a road tire may be your best bet, but I have not driven on them (I am going to put them on my Crosstrek when it comes in and have researched them). From what I’ve seen online they are great tires but someone who actually has them may know more about any cons

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
roflmaozedong•

No change for me. I use L/100km and am averaging 9.3 right now, but I am often stuck in traffic. On highway I’m around 8.6. 2.5L engine btw.

2
winnipegjets31•

That’s not bad. That’s where I’m at once u added my roof basket, be worried and that it’d knock more out of it though

1

There was a discernible, but minor, increase in road noise for me. Also somewhat less grippy on turns.

1
ednksu•

I put Michelin Cross Climates on my outback and am considering them for my wife's Trek. Fantastic ratings in snow (for an all season) and rain. Look nice too. They're on the cross climate 2s now.

8

I've got CrossClimate2 on my 2018 Crosstrek. Love them, they look good, great rain handling, good dirt road performance, not sure about snow.

2
Rollinseal•

Just got crossclimate 2 just before all the snow came to Seattle. I drove to Steven and snoqualmie pass when the snowstorm hit, and went around snowshoeing. They performed great, and my mileage didn’t change at all from having them on for more than a month now.

Edit: Costco is having a sale/ discount for them too. 150 off for 4 of them right now.

3
blueorv•

I’m very happy with with my CrossClimate 2 on my 2014. They have a very unique feel steering wise especially when they are brand new but honestly no complaints other than the voids might be more prone to picking up rocks or screws. Not to the point where I pick up gobs of stones though. I’ve never had tires so minimally siped still handle so well in rain

My only concern is treadlife. They look to be doing ok so far but I just don’t know how well even the best compounds will hold up at opposite ends of the temperature spectrum. They certainly handle well in the cold, I’m assuming that even if they handle well in high temps there must be a penalty somewhere. I had originally planned to go with the most aggressive tire I could fit under there but in reality it just doesn’t make sense to compromise on road handling that much and possibly have worse wet and snow traction. In my opinion my off-road ability is mostly limited by approach and departure (followed by lack of low) and if there’s a chance of modding to over come these are a great balance.

So far they are the best tire I’ve had, and I’m excited to see how they go in some real snow.

2
HissyFit808•

I second this. Consumer Reports says they’re good I see them frequently on sale at Costco.

1
MusicMonkeyJam•

Just put them on my XV and did amazing in snow last week. Yesterday the car in front of me stopped hard on a yellow and though I probably wasn't breaking 100 percent I did not get any slip (dryish pavement).

Of course my benchmark were Bridgestone Ecopias which were the worst tire I have ever had on any car.

1
Skamanda42•

I'm a big fan of the Continental Extreme Contact DWS. Phenomenal dry and wet traction, and good enough grip in snow that it can be hard to do donuts with. The 06+ model has stiffer sidewalls, which was the one weakness the older model had.

6
ednksu•

Are you running those Contis a little smaller profile? I had put them on our Mazda protege wagon and they were fantastic and wore nice and even. I hadn't considered them since I don't see an exact size.

1
Skamanda42•

Running the same size as the Geolandars they replaced, in the size tire rack suggested for my 2017.

1
icecronie•

Second these, they're great tires.

1
BAgen2OP•

One of the local tire shops recommended these. Might have to try those instead

1
therealphatmike•

I’m currently running Michelin Defenders and really like them - smooth, quiet, and an 80k mile life. Enough that I put them on my partners Rogue. It doesn’t snow much in middle Tennessee, though. They do well enough in our mild winters. But I’m considering some 15s and Falken Wildpeaks for a winter setup, especially since we’re considering moving north.

2
BAgen2OP•

I actually ended going with the defenders as well. Guy at the tire shop this morning said hes ran both extreme contacts and defenders and he would recommend the defenders

1
BAgen2OP•

I was going to do an off road set up too with 15s and wildpeaks but kept seeing too many rubbing issues with 1st gen modals

1
therealphatmike•

Well damn. I thought I had seen on here that you could get away with those on a stock 2017 model, but oh well.

1
SpiderArms66•

17 Limited here. Just put Toyo ATlll 235/65/17 on my stocks. They rubbed for 20 miles and now only when I hit large bumps at high speeds, or turn all the way (you can get a 215 to combat this part).

They run well on sand (after airing down), NC dirt, pavement (with no drone), and snow.

So far have been amazing and look aggressive.

Lost 2mpg total in city, 1 hwy.

2
converter-bot•

20 miles is 32.19 km

1
Cutlasss2016 Premium Quartz Blue Pearl•

A good all season street tire is Continentals TruContacts. But they have a CrossContact which has a touch more forest road ability.

1