r/AskUK•
netsecwarrior

When does a village become a town?

My idea of a village is a few houses, a single pub and maybe a small shop.

A village near me (Edgworth) claims to be a village, despite having: three pubs, a cricket club, a post office, GP, dentist, pharmacy, hairdresser, estate agent, butcher, a school, two nurseries, and probably a few more businesses. At what point do they become a town?

Although Ringway is still a village and it has a major international airport with two runways and three terminals. But that feels different somehow.

Posted Jan 13, 2022, 7:55 PM UTC

3071
another_reddit_user9•

Good point. Does it have a traditional 'town centre' though? If not, and the various pubs, businesses, etc. are dotted around the place, that still feels like a village to me. I'd be happy in a village with three pubs! šŸ»

41
netsecwarriorOP•

There is a clear village centre, although only one of the pubs is in that - the other two are five minutes walk away. I think you'd like the place. Some lovely walks

8
another_reddit_user9•

Walks too?! Sounds ideal to me!

2
netsecwarriorOP•

Well, I already doxxed the place :) Hit me up when you move in

3
cuccir•

The boring answer:

The terms village, town, hamlet no longer have legal status in the UK. Until 1835 it was anywhere in England and Wales with a town charter, and from then to 1974 it was anywhere with a borough charter. In Scotland the set-up is similar but they were called 'Burghs' and scrapped in 1975.

These charters technically still exist but are just honorary things, and new ones aren't issued. Still, that's why some places which have grown in size since then now claim to be "the largest village", as they don't have such a charter. But any parish council can all itself a town council if it wants.

34
netsecwarriorOP•

Boring is interesting, thank-you!

13
somethatwander•

I bet there's a large number of these villages with a larger population than St. Davids, the UKs smallest xityy, with a population of only 1,600

7
Mojak16•

My secondary school had 2,000 kids in it. Not all from the same village though I think it it points out the fact I went to a school with more people than the smallest city which is kinda cool tbh.

So I think most villages probably have more than 1,600 people in them these days...

2
destria•

A lot of it's historic. Hampstead in London is sometimes still referred to as a village. My current "village" has 5 pubs, 2 small supermarkets, 3 cafes, a bakery, a post office, a print shop, a gift shop, 2 restaurants, 3 takeaways, 2 hairdressers, a kitchen shop, a bridal boutique, 2 pharmacies, a GP, dentist, a leisure centre, several estate agents, a business park... But it doesn't really feel like a town because whilst there's a small high street, most of this is dotted around, there's a lot of green space, it's nearly all houses no high rise buildings etc.

13
netsecwarriorOP•

I draw the line at the mini supermarkets. You live in a town, Sir. Your parish council is lying to themselves

6
destria•

Hm it's quite common around here for the villages to have a co-op or Tesco express. Like the previous village I lived in had only a co-op, a chippy and a pub, and it was definitely nowhere near a town!

5
netsecwarriorOP•

Are you down South? Up North branded stores tend to be in the bigger places. P.S. sorry if my previous comment sounded rude, it was meant to be a bit tongue in cheek

1†
Trentdison•

You better not tell those nice folks over in Sandford, they'll be rather upset to find out they're not a village.

2
JurassicM4rc•

Somebody should tell them. After all, it's for the greater good...

1
Dinklebaird•

The greater good

1
dwair•

That's more developed than most of the established market town's in Cornwall and Devon.

1
isperdrejpner•

As a non UK-er, I find it so pleasant that the village is naturally centered around a pub.

11
elbapo•

Three pubs in this case. Two in mine. Plus the legion; which is for all intents and purposes a pub. Albeit preserved from the seventies.

3
Kobbett•

A town used to be a place that was allowed to hold a market, but it's not a rule now in the same way that a city doesn't need a cathedral any more. But places tend to call themselves villages or towns for historical reasons no matter what their modern size is.

9
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
duckduckducknonono•

I think a cathedral has to be involved for a city I’ve heard. Something to do with a university potentially being a substitute. Just little things I’ve heard in and around my area. Preston becoming a city, Burnley trying and some other random attempts at status.

Edit - I know I’ve jumped a level :)

4
BlokeyBlokeBloke•

No. No need for a cathedral. A city is anything the Queen says is a city. There are cities without cathedrals and towns with cathedrals.

2
netsecwarriorOP•

I believe Preston is the newest city in England, having won a millennium competition? Bolton feels more of a city to be, but hey, I guess these are arbitrary labels.

I did once visit the smallest city in the UK. It has a Cathedral - or had, it's ruins now - but it's modern population is like 2000.

1
cmdrxander•

Brighton and Hove became a city just after the millennium too.

I think Southend-on-Sea is about to become the latest city?

2
bernsteinsbolocks•

Interesting. At one time I lived in a village with a population of 2000. It did seem very much like a village population spread out with church, few shots and 2 pubs.

1
SKH7919•

My ā€œvillageā€ has: An industrial estate Three pubs Two Indian restaurants A dominos pizza Two Chinese takeaways Two fish and chip shops A Co-Op An Aldi A little Tesco A post office A gift shop A clothes shop Two butchers A bakery 7 hairdressers/barbers/salons A pet shop A DIY store A funeral parlour Two dentists One doctors surgery A high school with a swimming pool Two primary schools Two tea rooms A sandwich shop A podiatrist A Boots A kebab shop A library Three churches Four estate agents

I’m getting bored listing them all now, but basically in answer to your question, judging by my village, fuck knows

4
netsecwarriorOP•

I'm pretty sure that's not a village. You must be able to appeal to Ordance Survey or someone. And claim your emotional damages

2
warp-factor•

Edgworth sounds like a village to me from your description, although quite a well provisioned one.

I'd say one of the defining features of a town is a high street. While villages may have a village centre with a pub and a couple of businesses, a town will have a full high street with a WHSmith, a Gregg's, 2 or 3 of the major national bank branches, a CEX, betting shops, couple of charity shops, Poundland, Boots, home bargains or B&M, that sort of thing.

4
Dinklebaird•

You've just described the high street of the town I work in exactly that's pretty much all that's in the high street.

1
dontmesswithnuns•

I think villages don't have a town council, a mayor, and so on.

3
Scarboroughwarning•

Needs a court and a police station, I believe. Obviously, I assume this was the old rule, as so many courts shut down.

3
netsecwarriorOP•

Definitely no court. Interestingly there is a sort-of Police station. I'm not sure on the detail but there's some weird story that it was a former Police station, and now a copper lives there, it's his house, not an official station, but he kept the sign up? I may have the details wrong, but there's definitely a sign there

3
Ageing_Changeling•

Lots of villages used to have a 'Police Station', although they were actually a 'Police House' where the village constable lived and would be available to the public when necessary.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
LumpyCamera1826•

My village used to have 7 pubs

3
brntuk•

You don’t mention churches but certainly one definition of hamlet is a village without a church, and cities only became cities when they had a cathedral. St. David’s in Wales is the UKs smallest city since it is basically a cathedral surrounded by a few houses.

Obviously nowadays churches don’t get much of a lookin, but go back a thousand years all up to the end of the 1800s and you can see how strong religious faith was. Almost all villages, towns and cities had a number of churches and these were often the most imposing structure in which ever location they were set.

3
[deleted]•

Always annoys me in cosy mysteries when the author tries to set up a cosy village type environment and the hamlets always have a church anda local vicar.

1
BleedsIsDead•

Boring fact: I live in the biggest village in England. It’s alright

3
BorisBoris88•

Possibly even more boring - I believe there are several villages in England that lay claim to being ā€˜biggest.’ Apparently it depends on your definition of biggest.

1
BleedsIsDead•

This is mildly exciting. I think Lancing claims first by population.

2
BorisBoris88•

Which is indeed a strong claim. Cranleigh bases their claim for the title on geographical area.

1
BleedsIsDead•

When I first moved to Lancing I went to a lock-in at the main pub in the village/town. Someone shuffled their bum off a bar stool and did a poo on the floor. I think that’s enough reason to believe Lancings population would kick the crap out of Cranleigh

1
Jeffuk88•

My village has 7 pubs... Had 11 when it was half the population.

I remember being taught in Geography GCSE that to be a town it needed a secondary school and some form of leisure centre

2
moobietron•

Street in Somerset is apparently a village even though it contains a major shopping outlet and has over 10000 population

2
netsecwarriorOP•

I think by this point they are at least Road

7
cmdrxander•

My hometown Lancing, West Sussex, has a population around 20k and it’s a village. We always used to get told it was the most populous village in Europe!

2
bernsteinsbolocks•

How is it a village? The largest market town in my region is 12K. I realise the definitions are arbitrary but that is a bit of a streach.

2
cmdrxander•

Some of the common definitions for a town are having a regular market, a town hall or a town council. Lancing has none of those (parish hall and parish council).

1
Krakshotz•

Cottingham (just on the outskirts of Hull) is around 17,000. Prior to 2019, the base population would get a temporary increase by a good 1000+ because Hull uni’s main student accommodation campus was located in the village (until it was closed in favour of overpriced, private, sub-par, on-campus accommodation).

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
menglish89•

Historically it would be if had a town charter and permission to hold a market. Hence a lot of rural towns calling themselves "market towns" and having a town or market square

2
ignatiusjreillyXM•

Dunno. I live in a place which at the last reported census (2011, but it's grown since) had a population of about 11,000 and that is a town for sure. It has a market, a marketplace, two supermarkets, shops of various kinds (albeit for lots of things even shoes you'll need to go 20 miles away), and multiple pubs (mostly good and distinct in character) and a few restaurants (generally not great). Big medieval church, and other biggish churches. Pre-pandemic there was a nightclub. Other halls for events. A sort of theatre/cinema/events venue. A secondary school and three primary schools. It's scenic and mostly pretty, even the suburbs.

Then there is a small strip of open land that takes at most five minutes to walk across. On the other side lies a (big) village. Population of about 10,000 in 2011. No market, possibly more shops than the town (but more practical than prestigious, they even have a laundrette which the town hasn't), a couple of mini-supermarkets, only two pubs, some takeaways and cafes but no restaurants as such. A couple of small churches. A village hall as a kind of social centre. Only a primary school. It's mostly neither scenic nor pretty. Even though there is less of a clear centre or focal point than the town, people who live in the village are generally adamant (a) that it's a village, and (b) it's not part of, and separate from the town, and the small gap between them must remain that (big big fuss about a small number of houses being built one side of the gap, and that was before the health centre went up, then there were plans for a swimming pool, to replace one in the town...outrage from the village, they are stealing our identity!)

Clearly a population of 10,500 is the dividing line.

2
cantab314•

Random idea: When it has multiple distinct areas that are more than just one end or the other end, and/or it has multiple commercial centres not just one.

2
Deadbeat85•

When they get a Gregg's

2