How bad was this?

I come in peace, I promise. I asked this same question in r/atheism, but then it occurred to me that for it to be an honest question, I need some christian perspective as well. (I cleaned it up for this subreddit)

I'm in a motel working out a few math problems and need some scratch paper. I didn't go straight to the gideon bible in the drawer (didn't even occur to me at first), but after a looking everywhere else and coming up short, well...

So my co-worker swings by my room, sees the scribbling and comments that that was a jerk move. Maybe it was? How much so? I honestly meant no offense, but it occurs to me that I could be jaded/out of touch and could use some brushing up on my perspective.

Things to consider:

  • I used the empty pages in the back.

  • I didn't write anything offensive, just math.

  • I had no point to make, it was purely functional.

  • I didn't make any marks anywhere else.

I'm not looking for forgiveness or validation, just curious how much of a jerk move other would consider this. Say, scale of 1 to 10.

Posted Apr 13, 2012, 10:31 PM UTC

212
notanartmajorChristian (Alpha & Omega)•

The Bible is important, but it is just a book. The physical thing itself has no power or value (I guess except for whatever the materials themselves would be worth, but w/e).

That said, I would have torn/cut out the pages I marked on, but that's more for neatness' sake.

8
ResidentRedneckReformed•

Or just take the whole thing - it's placed there with the expressed intention of the guests taking it.

When I worked in a hotel, we had an entire stock of Gideon Bibles in a linen closet, just to replace those that were taken. And every month or so, the local guy who brought them would stop in and drop off some more.

4
haactorChristian (Cross)•

This is exactly what I came to say. Don't feel bad, FreeFromChrist (lol'd at username and post). It was not jerk at all. 1/10 for not tearing the pages out.

1
[deleted]•

God's Words are inspired and preserved.

The paper... is not. :P

5
GhostlyGirlCalvary Chapel•

I think if it's okay for me to mark up my study bible, it's alright to do some sums in the back. There's no real edict against writing in the Bible. IT's a bit flippant, but it's not horrendous.

3
TheBluesMan232Reformed•

Scale of 1 to 10?

  1. I would have said 0, but that's outside the range requested.

I'm curious - What kind of responses did you expect here versus what you got in r/atheism?

3
FreeFromChristOP•

Actually I expected pretty much the responses I got in both places; I just didn't want to assume them. It didn't seem to be that big a deal to me, and having been a christian I believe I probably wouldn't have cared back then either. But that's not much of a point of reference (pretty large potential for bias) so I just wanted to make sure I wasn't getting out of line.

Don't get me wrong, I love a good debate and have no qualms offending others that shove their beliefs in my face, but I don't go looking for fights, don't actively seek to offend anyone, and it's certainly not why I'm in here now. Basically, I just wanted a sanity check and I appreciate the open responses. Cheers.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

If it was just the back pages it doesn't matter. You could have just torn the pages out, that would have been fine. Or if you don't have a bible and would like one you could have just taken it with you. Of course people do donate money to put those bibles there so just make sure you don't needlessly make them useless to others.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
BillWeld•

I'd put you at about a two, the same as farting in an elevator without intent. The Gideons would be delighted if you kept the Bible and read it but I don't think they'd be too upset at what you did.

1
buylocal745Atheist•

If it was a Koran, I'd say it was offensive. To Islam, desecration of that book is gravely sinful. But a Bible? It's just a book.

0
Quark_LeStrangeChristian (Cross)•

Because you don't use books as scratch paper, especially if they aren't yours. Maybe I'm just a bibliophile, but I would be offended if you scribbled math problems in the back of a copy of Tom Sawyer that you got for 10 cents at the thrift store.

0
[deleted]•

the bible is different, it has less value as they are distrobuted free of charge, they can be more readily replaced

1