So, I was just sorted into Slytherin. Can any of you Slytherins convince me to stick with this sorting?

OK, so I normally consider myself a 'puff, for a while now this has been the house I affiliate with, so of course when Pottermore kicked me into Slytherin, I got a bit of a shock, and am considering going with a new account to try and get into Hufflepuff. I was wondering if I could be convinced to stick with Slytherin (i.e. shown that I do, in fact, belong in it).

Now, I know why I might be seen as a Slytherin; at times I can be two-sided, and the depths of my mind are, in fact... dark... but in terms of my personality I have always thought I was better suited to Hufflepuff. I am quite introverted around those I don't know well and don't take well to strangers (unless they are open and inviting). I am also extremely timid unless angered. I have never considered myself "manipulative", and try hard not to inconvenience others just so I can help myself. Of course, in retrospect I can be extremely bloody stubborn, and blatantly disregard authority if I know I am in the right and am wrongly accused of something.

So, 'puff or Slytherin? Thanks in advance to anyone who replies! Love to everyone, irrespective of house.

Posted Apr 15, 2012, 11:43 AM UTC

29
TuftybeeFlightKnight31360•

We're not as bad as you might think, honest! Being in Slytherin doesn't necessarily mean being evil or manipulative - it's about being cunning, ambitious and possibly having a bigger moral grey-area than most people.

Do you tend to look out for yourself over other people? Are you prone to fits of fierce loyalty for people you see as "yours"? Are you willing to do whatever it takes to get ahead of the competition? Do you hate Gryffindor? (ok, that last one was a joke... really.) If you answer yes to those, you'd be fine in Slytherin :)

Honestly though, you do sound like you'd be more at home in Hufflepuff, especially if that's what you normally consider yourself.

6
Pterodactyl418SilverGinger•

I had the same problem. I usually associate myself with Gryffindor, yet I was sorted into Slytherin, and I wasn't very happy with it. However, I decided to learn to love it and your comment convinced me! Especially the "Are you prone to fits of fierce loyalty for people you see as yours?" and the moral grey-area. So thank you. I'm working towards being a proud Slytherin :)

1
TuftybeeFlightKnight31360•

Oooh I converted someone :)

1
Krsst14Proud Gryffindor Snape Loyalist•

Don't be upset. This really is not the most accurate sorting. I get it. JK designed it herself. But it REALLY does depend on which of the 200 questions it asks you. And let's face it...Does black or white or heads of tails really make any difference in which house you REALLY belong? That and the Hat doesn't take any of your choice into account like the true Sorting Hat would!

I made two accounts because the first e-mail I received told me there was an error and that I needed to make a new one. But then they caught up with each other and they ended up both coming through anyway. On the first sort, I was Hufflepuff. On the second sort, Gryffindor. I did however think it was more compelling that my wand cores were consistent both times (I know...One in three shot, but interesting nonetheless.)

You know what you are. Don't let Pottermore tell you any differently. It's just fun to play for your team.

3
kialna•

You should in no way take it too personal. Even though I was disappointed at first with being a Ravenclaw. But as it may be, I also have a Slytherin account now. I suspect that the sorting is either random, or not accurate. Of course, I'm not sure about that.

But at least, read the intro about slytherin. This sentence in particular appeals me, as it's something I've known even before my Slytherin-era:

"But we’re not bad people. We’re like our emblem, the snake: sleek, powerful, and frequently misunderstood."

2
RizzyMissy•

I'm in Slytherin too, it's not too bad, I think...

2
[deleted]•

You sound a lot like a Slytherin, and I really think the two houses are more alike than you may think.

2
sturg1dj•

I always knew I was great, and being in Slytherin confirmed that. What was your question?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
TomlingOP•

Yeah, I did create a new account and got into Hufflepuff. In all honesty, I don't really care for who is winning, playing for the team is what it's all about, I think.

1