I just finished ADWD and I have a question about Jaime [Spoilers]

Is it safe to assume that Brienne chose to betray Jaime after Lady Stoneheart put her on trial? Can we infer that Jaime is dead, or do you think that she will side with him?

Posted Apr 15, 2012, 10:29 PM UTC

025
coyote_gospelHouse Martell•

Not necessarily. I actually feel like Jaime Wild Speculation

3
MomentumjamUnsullied•
3
coyote_gospelHouse Martell•

I'm not really sure how it's actually supposed to go down either, but maybe Jaime Speculation Like I said, just my crazy speculation.

1
thedarkwolfNymeria's Wolfpack•
1
coyote_gospelHouse Martell•
2
pahina1House Stark•

You realize that by simply saying that Jamie is still alive in ADWD is a spoiler in itself right?

3
emmsterHouse Mormont•

My friend, I wish I knew for sure.

Personally, it is my opinion that Jaime will survive. But that's because I'm also pretty damn convinced that Speculation That's my theory, and I'm stickin' to it.

2
[deleted]•

Book Spoiler Remove this post mods.

-6
VadenKhaleHouse Greyjoy•

I could post a title saying, "I just finished ADWD and I have a question about Aerys/Rhaegar"

Has NOTHING to do with them being dead or alive. I guess anyone asking a question about Aerys with a title like that implies that Aerys survived in your world, huh?

6
Flowah•

That's... kind of a stupid comparison.

  1. People watching the series only know that Aerys died.

  2. People watching the series only know that Jaime is captured. He could well survive.

  3. We have no idea who Rhaegar is. At least I don't.

If you replaced Jaime's name with Ned Stark, people up to date on the TV series would know he's already dead. If you replaced it with Robb, Ayra, Sansa, anyone still alive as of yet, we would assume that the question is because they are still alive in book 5.

Duh.

-4
thedarkwolfNymeria's Wolfpack•

How about this example:

A Question about Syrio [Spoilers ADWD]

You might be tempted to think that this means that Syrio is really alive and show up in ADWD. But it's just as likely that I'm referring to information available only in ADWD that ties back to Syrio's plot line from AGOT.

Another example would be:

I have a question about ACOK Spoiler Character Name motivations [Spoilers all books]

Note that I covered this because it's kind of ACOK spoiler and you stated that you have not read the books...

But for this title, I'm not necessarily implying that this character is alive or dead. But I want to incorporate some scenes from all the books, from many different character perspectives in order to learn more about scenes that took place in ACOK.

5
VadenKhaleHouse Greyjoy•

You know spoilers are there for people that have not seen or read the books, right? Saying it's a stupid comparison because people that are up to date know stuff, then they don't need spoilers. Spoilers are there solely for people that are not up to date

I like italics

2
Flowah•

I see the spoiler tag as a warning that book discussions are inside.

Regardless, the same principle would apply if someone made a title:

"Question about Ned Stark in S02E03 [Spoilers]" for people who aren't up to date on the TV show.

0
kjhatchMODYou Don't Know Cold•

Please read the spoiler policy. Naming a character and a book together is not moderated information.

3†
[deleted]•
-5
kjhatchMODValar Morghulis•

It's never been a moderated spoiler in this subreddit. It's "structural information." Anything related to the publishing of the books or production of the show outside of what happens in the story is part of that, like filming locations or chapter POVs.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
Flowah•

It certainly implies that he survives.

I havent read any of the books and that's exactly what I took from the title.

2
thedarkwolfNymeria's Wolfpack•

If you have not read any of the books you probably should not be in a post marked spoiler for ADWD. I'm not saying that it implies he survived or not... I'm just trying to point out that inside this thread, which is marked for spoilers, I'm not going to be covering ADWD spoilers, so you should be careful.

2
Flowah•

Uh, all the spoiler info is in the TITLE. Unless you're suggesting I just avoid this subreddit entirely.

-1
The_Second_BestA Hound Will Never Lie To You•

Maybe you're wrong...

1
[deleted]•
-1
[deleted]•

So you're basically saying that I could phrase a title like Book Spoiler

I think you need to look up the word illiterate.

-3