"Choosing not to give birth is not a right" -- **Why Not?**

Question for Pro-life

As a society - we normally all agree that bodily integrity is a right.

I don't see many pro-lifers arguing that people should be forced to donate blood, bone marrow, etc.

If someone starts to take those things against your will - most people would say lethal force is OK to stop those bodily violations from occurring.

Nor do I see many pro-lifers saying the state has the right to mandate and control medical decisions an individual makes.

Why is giving birth different?

If bodily integrity is a right - then you also have the right to choose whether or not to give birth regardless of it's impact on someone else.

That's how rights work. You don't loose a right just because someone else's life is on the line.

Below is a summary of the common arguments and why they are misleading at best.

Disingenuous at worse.

Posted as a reference so we can avoid the circular and contradictory logic from the get go and have an honest conversation.

​

No one has the right to end the life of another human unless its in self defense because their life is at risk.

Irrelevant. An abortion is not about the right to end a life.

It's about the right of self-preservation - the right of maintaining bodily integrity.

​

They do until a person exists whom they would have to kill in order to have that right.

If you can't defend your basic human rights by any means necessary - how can you possibly call it a human right?

This argument basically says you have to let the violation occur if there is no non-lethal way to stop it.

This argument has implications far worse than just this debate.

It could be used to justify forced bodily donations, blood transfusions, bone marrow transplants, etc.

​

Do not have sex unless you are prepared for consequences. Sad how people think their inconvenience for 9 months is a bigger ethical issue than taking another life.No morality left.

Sex falls into the right of bodily integrity.

Passing laws that make it impossible for consenting adults (who refuse to give birth) to have sex legally 100% violates this right.

​

I'm saying "Abortion violates human rights and is therefore bad."

Forcing someone to continue with a pregnancy against their will also violates human rights of bodily integrity but you claim that's ok.

You can't have it both ways. Human rights don't work that way.

​

If you don’t want children get a vasectomy.

Even a vasectomy can result in a child.https://www.healthline.com/health/mens-health/vasectomy-failure-rate

Posted Jan 31, 2022, 8:34 PM UTC · edited

32469
Loading comments…