Let's talk about Rossetto...
Rossetto seems to be one of the more divisive players on the team, with some fans basically saying he's garbage. So, let's compare his 2021 stats to Darlington Nagbe's 2019 stats. They served similar roles, so I think it's a pretty fair comparison, except for the fact that Darlington was in his career peak, and Rossetto was still a few years away from it.
Here's the full comparison, for anybody who cares. I do recommend toggling onto per 90 stats, since Rossetto played fewer matches due to his delayed start to the season caused by getting his green card and then having to get back into fitness.
https://fbref.com/tiny/KFq4e (EDIT: The link should now compare 4 player seasons: 2021 Rossetto, 2019 Nagbe, 2018 Nagbe, and 2019 Remedi; Rossetto's stats compare even more favorably vs. 2018 Nagbe than vs. 2019 Nagbe.)
Just recently read someone saying basically 4 things: 1) He doesn't score or assist 2) He only passes backward 3) He is terrible when pressed and 4) His defense is awful. I'll focus on just those four, but again, feel free to look at the full stat comparison. I haven't really dug into the stats, but my eyes tell me those two narratives aren't really fair, so this will be done on the fly. Maybe my eyes are wrong?
-
No goals or assists? Yep. That's completely correct. For comparison to how Darlington Nagbe did in a similar role: Nagbe had 2g and 4a in 33 matches vs. Rossetto's 0g and 0a in 23 matches. OK, so it's true that Nagbe produced more g and a in 2019 than Rossetto in 2018. I would like to point out that Nagbe at 0g and 1a in 2018 though, so it's not like there's a huge difference here. Edge to Nagbe, of course.
-
Does he progress the ball? Well... interesting thing here. Rossetto passed the ball further and progressed the ball a further distance, on average, than 2019 Nagbe. Rossetto attempted and completed ~4-5 extra passes per game at a very slightly lower percentage completion. Rossetto attempted more short and more long passes, while Nagbe attempted more medium passes. They both made a similar number of passes under pressure (~10 per 90) -- and again, their completion percentage was similar. Rossetto attempted ~2 swings per 90, vs. Nagbe's 1 per 90. Nagbe averaged about 1.3 extra progressive passes of >10 yards per match. (4.3 vs. 3.01)
So... Rossetto's progressive passes moved the ball further toward goal than Nagbe's, but he completed fewer of them per 90. I don't think it's fair to say that Nagbe progressed the ball significantly more than Rossetto does (through passing).
- OK, I admit that it's hard to find a good data set on stats when pressed, or at least FBRef doesn't have it, so I'll fall onto a different stat: What does he do with his dribbles? On a per 90 basis, Rossetto touched the ball about 10% more times than Nagbe. Rossetto's dribble percent is 73.9 vs. Nagbe's 88.9. That's one of the stats where Nagbe is far and away one of the best in the league and probably up there worldwide. Rossetto's 73.9% isn't great, but it's also not awful for a CM. Nagbe also attempted more dribbles per 90, fwiw.
But carries (any time the player controlled the ball with his feet) is really interesting... They both carried the ball a similar number of times per 90, with Rossetto having 1 extra carry per 90. But there's a big difference in distance. NAGBE carried the ball a really long distance. But... even though he carried the ball an average of nearly 100 yds further per match than Rossetto, he only advanced the ball an additional 48 yds with those carries. They also had similar carries into the opponent's box.
Nagbe lost the ball 1.05 per 90 on carries. Rossetto 1.28. So Rossetto gave the ball up about 1 extra time for every 4 full matches. I would hardly call that a disaster.
- Defense? I'm running short of my lunch break, so I'll just cut to the chase: Rossetto is a more more active defender than Nagbe. It stands out pretty clearly. 1.99 tackles vs. 1.4. More pressures and more successful pressures per 90. Significantly more blocks. 1.62 vs. .73 interceptions.
Bonus: Miscellaneous: Rossetto's +/- is better than Nagbe's. .96 GD/90 vs. .35 GD/90.
In total, Nagbe is the better player, I think. Stat-wise it's not as clearcut as some would suggest. The fixation on 0g and 0a is just pure cherry-picking, considering how little is asked of Rossetto in the attacking 3rd. It's simply not his role, just like it mostly wasn't Nagbe's role -- see Nagbe's 0g 1a in 2018.
It's definitely not fair to call Rossetto trash. His stats are similar to one of the best to ever play that role in MLS. Not quite as good, but I'll bet Nagbe's age 23 stats weren't either.
Posted Feb 1, 2022, 5:53 PM UTC · edited