Successfully breaking a chain with a typical multitool?

I decided to have a practice run with some old chain links after replacing the KMC chain on my commuter ebike. I used a pretty standard multitool chain breaker with a thumb catch (Crank Brothers M19). I couldn't get it to budge. I could do it with the Park Tool CT5 with a little grunting.

Is the ebike chain much tougher than average in this regard? I've not tried it on a mountain bike chain.

Am I just weak? I'm a rock climber, I figured my finger strength is at least better than an average cyclist. But then again I'm a shitty rock climber :-)

I have a full sized shop tool for home use, and the little CT5 that I'll make sure to throw in my pack, so I'm not looking for advice on what to buy. Just wondering if people have had a different experience with multitools? Just struck me as odd that these tools would be so prevalent if an average user can't pull it off.

Posted Feb 1, 2022, 11:34 PM UTC

19
Chamois_Hagar•

The only one I like on the fly is the Park I-beam style, where the detachable tire lever acts as a crank handle for the chain-break. The others I’ve used end up giving me hell.

4
NOsquidOP•

It does seem like the crux is leverage in your second hand. That's a good solution from Park. I think with the Crank Brothers F15 you can use the case as leverage. But most tools out there seem to be just a little tab for 2 fingers. Thanks for confirming I'm not totally crazy.

2
NOsquidOP•

Alright dear readers. After some experimenting I ended up hacking the little sliding handle off the Park Tool CT-5. My multitool slides in with the 4mm hex key giving additional leverage length and a fatter handle to hold on to. Now it's easy. Bring on the chains.

2
StandardForsaken•

ebikes use heavier duty chains. yes.

multi tools are made for regular bike chains, you need a tool that is specifically for e-bike chains.

1
NOsquidOP•

Thanks! I was curious about how much the ebike chain might be contributing. I don't carry a chain tool on my ebike commuter so it's not a huge deal from that standpoint, just happened to be the chain links I had laying around at the moment for testing the tools I carry on MTB.

I will try to get my hands on a MTB chain to test. Until I'm convinced I can break a standard SRAM 12spd MTB chain in a pinch with the multi I'll carry the CT5 on MTB rides just in case.

1
ILoveLongDogs•

This dude is wrong. Sorry u/StandardForsaken. Most chain tools will serve for a range of speeds and brands, it should say on the packaging. Ebike chains of the same speed and brand as a non-ebike chain will come apart in the same way. You'll mostly be fine with an all purpose chain tool: they're good with 12 speed, this Park one will do everything bar Sram AXS, Shimano XTR and finishing on Campag chains:
https://www.parktool.com/product/chain-tool-ct-3-2?category=Chain

0
NOsquidOP•

I have that tool, but I'm not bringing it on a ride :-)

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

0
NOsquidOP•

I can assure you delicacy was going nowhere with this particular torture device :-)

2