Meanwhile in tribunal...

Posted Apr 19, 2012, 8:29 PM UTC

Posted Apr 19, 2012, 8:29 PM UTC
Can we ban the reporters?
This and reporting people from champ select need to be options.
You can email Riot support directly if you really feel the need to report someone at champ select.
Did it today!
That bad?
What do you mean "reporting people from champ select" ?
Do you mean that the champ select chat should be part of the report? If so, I agree. Right now you can troll people hard in champ select then be good all game :)
... not that I do this ... shifty eyes
It's a bit of both. My main problem with LoL's moderation system is in order to report a player you have to complete a game with them so you have to suffer dealing with a full experience with that player. Situations like being AFK in ranked champ select mode, verbally assaulting players in champ select or in chats theres nothing you can do about them. It's really annoying when a player in champ select has to queue dodge because of a troll afker or uncooperative player and take a elo/win ratio/time hit because another player is being a jackass while that player gets off scot free is pretty lame and as clearly stated a lot of players jackassery starts off in champ select so being able to report them from there would help.
[deleted]
yea, just a constant option to report would be nice. I might spam the, "player unskilled" button a lot, but hey, they will be around people on their level...
I think that there should be a program in place to keep track of how many reports you place that don't end up in bans relative to reports that do, and if you get a high enough score you get put on report probation.
I don't have a source, but my understanding is that this is already the case. Essentially the tribunal is a tool to filter and send cases to Riot support. Reporters with higher accuracy contribute more to the likelihood of a case being dropped or escalated. That is to say, their opinions are given more weight.
My understanding is there is. When you report someone who is not punished it notes that and adjusts the "weight" of your report.
Oh my god it burns my eyes to see the word entire written as 'intire'.
prolly not native english speakers, cause the Summoner Name of this Eve is German, so its probably on EU-W
And believe it or not - there exist other languages than English over here!
Wait.
There are other languages?
Wait. There are other countries?
NA is the best country of EU
Wait. There's good cholesterol?
Sí, alguno que otro.
Definitivamente, es probable que haya alguno más, pero no me hagas mucho caso...
GOD DAMN BRAZILIANS GET THE FUCK OFF MY SERVER
ohja mann glaubt garnicht wieviele es eigentlich sind
Sie haben ja Recht. Hunderte davon... und das zahlt nicht die Dialekte! Damit ist es nicht nur kaum zu glauben, sondern auch kaum zu erfassen!
How do they talk to each other if neither of them speak English!
I thought there was only American.
我恨你,笨老外!
No Ezreal.
Tak, jest parę innych języków.
Chwila ... to jest więcej języków niż polski ? ಠ_ಠ
Jesus spoke American.
English*
*American
That's the joke!
At the top of the window you can see it says EU-West so you're right!
There exist other languages HERE, too. No surprise considering we're the same people.
Evelynn new FotM
I know I'm going to be playing her all day tomorrow!
[deleted]
There is already Tiamat tuesday.
All from the enemy team.... Someones mad....
I like how they reported eve for "offensive language"
first option in list, i guess they didnt bother to check
Or maybe the eve player bmed in chat after going godlike multiple times with a sub par champion?
bmed?
Was bad mannered.
bad mannered
I would have.
[deleted]
This is the best thing I have seen in all my years living on the internet.
An op eve killing all of us, Lets report her for feeding!
well she was intentionally feeding... on them.
2011-12-29
Thats 29th of december last year, so she is still in the same state as now
[deleted]
They didn't buy a pink ward early.
This is the solution to gankers that rely on stealth; namely shaco, twitch and evelynn. The fact that people would rather get killed again than pay 125g for a pink ward never fails to piss me off. Especially when they refuse to play safe without that ward.
buying a pink ward and thinking that you are safe from ganks is more likely whats the problem, since the stealthers can gank the normal way as well.
125 g on a solo lane is a pretty huge investment early on, you def won't have it before the first back, and unless you are somewhat ahead I doubt you will on the second back
It's 5 CS
And all the CS you miss while backing.
[deleted]
Except they have no stun and nearly no gap-closers. Think maokai, he has his root and it works as a gap closer at the same time while evelyn really has to rely on her stealth to slow enemy champions.
Shaco says hi.
The difference between stealth gankers and normal gankers is that pink ward completely negates one part of their kit (except for Shaco's gap closer). While other junglers have gap closers, Eve and Twitch completely rely on their stealth to get close for a kill, a pink ward that you stay close to makes that near impossible.
One of the million cases sitting unjustly in the tribunal. I don't understand why they put the fate of people's accounts in sore losers hands. Honestly, I'm glad there are people like you that actually read the accounts, but I can imagine there are tons of people who just auto punish and not read who provoked who. Often, the "offender" is sticking up for himself, and uses some coarse language to do so. I don't understand how that's a punishable offense. It's like saying if you get punched in the face you're going to be punished for not fighting back.
[deleted]
I feel like reports should be dealt with on a game by game basis. Often I'll see someone have a few reported cases where maybe there's one bad game, and a couple of not bad games. Obviously if you break the summoner's code, you're in violation, but I look at it a little differently. If I don't see that they are doing this behavior consistently in every game, then I have a problem reporting them. IMO, one time/once in a long while offenders shouldn't get penalized. It's the people who do it game after game, week after week. When people are getting punished for just one bad game out of 3 cases, it just seems wrong to me.
I have found that if people have been reported for 4 games or so they pretty much acted like an ass in every game. It's the reports where the summoner has only been reported for 1 or 2 games where the reported player may not have been doing anything wrong. So I don't really see the need to review summoners on a game by game basis.
That's just a generalization. Yes most of the time 3 or 4 out of 4 reports are all the person breaking the rules. Occasionally though I get cases where 1 out of 3 or so is in violation. I'm sure just about everyone has gotten angry or raged at least once; that isn't toxic to the game though. But still they have violated the rules and will be punished, and the games that were incorrectly reported have been given positive weight.
Here's the fun thing though, it's set up to give less value to people that routinely put in false reports.
So lets say this guy is in there for 5 games. Three more are false reports, and in the last one he rages a bit. He should probably get some kind of warning, a slap on the wrist would be great. So you hit punish. Now all of those false reports are validated and reports from those people continue as usual.
Meanwhile, this guy with one bad game receives the same punishment as the guy going 0/40/0 building 6 boots and spamming racial slurs in 5 out of 5 games.
[deleted]
Nope, first ban i got was for a week
Yeah, I just commented somewhere here and pointed out the same problem. Nowhere have I read anything about what to do in those instances. They need to do it on a game by game basis. You can't clump up a bunch of reported games where 1 in 3 is actually report worthy, because then, as you said, all of them are identified as being punished, and that's just unfair.
Exactly. There should also be a way in which you can indicate the severity of the offense.
I would certainly hope you were right, but as blastovore pointed out... people do auto punish.
[deleted]
94% are punished and you think most don't? lololol
Funny how I went through tribunal, and did 9 punishments and 1 pardon, then got the IP credit for 9 cases.
And auto-punish means nothing at all. Riot support still reviews every case before a ban can be issued.
The purpose of the Tribunal is to weed out the bad reports to make Riot's job easier.
They do random audits of temp bans. The only thing they check 100% is permabans.
That's good to know.
It's redundant. Tribunal cases only act as a filter. Bans still need to be approved.
Riot bars people from the Tribunal that constantly click Punish 100% as well as those that have a high rate of disagreement with the consensus.
It's completely different, if you get in a fight in real life, you usually can't walk away from it so you're forced into self defense if they don't give up, in LoL, you can ignore that person ending their offending behavior. If you choose not to, you deserve that ban as far as I'm concerned. I haven't responded to an offender in months, I put them on ignore the moment they open their mouth in a way that doesn't please me. Yes, those offenders need to be reported, but don't join them, just ignore them and report post-game.
It's a bit off topic, but why can we even see what the enemy is saying? I don't think anything productive comes out of it besides shit talking.
I play bot lane dominion a lot, and I pretty often talk to my opponent. If we both have the same champion, we'll joke about that. If she kills me in a spectacular way, I'll congratulate her. If it's a tense stalemate, I'll say something like, "Quit not dying!"
If you don't want /all to be only shit talk, do something other than shit talk.
I often look at the total games as a %, so if they troll in 3 games and are unjustly reported for the last two, that's a 60% troll rate and is punishable. It's unfortunate but the only fair way I can think of doing it.
I like that. Good idea.
There is another discussion going on around here where some people do pretty much admit to auto-punishing every chance they get to maximize IP gains.
Maybe I'm just unlucky but I punish almost everyone--I'd say 9 out of 10 cases--and then the email comes and only 2 of those people were punished by the majority. I punish for even the slightest bit of racism/homophobia so I can see where others would disagree, but I don't think the majority of tribunal users just auto-punish everyone.
I've seen buddies do Tribunal, and just get case after case of obvious trolls or otherwise ridiculously un-fun people. On the other hand, I usually get gluts of teams butthurt-reporting one player on the enemy team for facerolling them.
Yeah, I don't blame riot... because it's a big job sorting through all this stuff. I just think it would be better handled by game moderators, instead of an abused system like the Tribunal.
I quit doing the tribunal because I punish many cases and get most of them wrong. Probably like 10/15 punish and I get 6 right.
In a fight where you are in harms way it makes sense. Not so much in internet flame wars. Much like the special olympics. Even if you win, you're still retarded.
The tribunal is terrible unjust bullshit that obviously violates consumer rights yet it's used by Riot because it saves them money. Fuck the tribunal and fuck Riot.
u banned bro?
ಠ_ಠ
So report her because she killed them a lot.
Makes perfect sense.
bad memories
This makes me wonder...
I think every single player has been on Tribunal before
People report (and don't even bother to change the reason of the report) for nothing...like,"Hey,he is better than me,reported."
Remember that not everyone is lvl 30, and i feel like most cases in the tribunal are about ppl below 30.
I got a tribunal app for android, and it shows the Summoner level. Only a tiny fraction of summoners are level 30 in the tribunal, most trolls never make it that high.
Nope. Riot says that the percentage of summoners who make it to the tribunal is in the single digits.
That was the number punished. They never said anything about how many people are brought to tribunal.
1.4% of summoners have been punished, and 94% of people sent to the tribunal are punished. Pretty easy extrapolation, even accounting for people punished more than once.
http://na.leagueoflegends.com/news/tribunal-records-16-million-votes
how do you plan on adjusting for multiple entries into tribunal?
There's no "Champion OP" report option for a reason.
"Well um... I don't know how to tell you this but you are bad players"
Honestly, eve isn't as bad as everyone thinks, it's just that most eve players have no clue how to play passively and wait for a fucking opening.
Oh wait, that's all players. Derp Derp.
Seriously. I had a player in ranked that randomed Eve because he lost 8 games in a row, so he wanted to troll. We absolutely DESTROYED top lane. Even got a FB on their jungler doing red and the other team just couldnt handle it. She can work in some situations but people really usually only look at a champ in terms of its tournament viability.
"Lose 8 games? Time to lose more to make myself feel better!"
I wrote a poem about this:
oh u
solo q
et tu
solo q?
F U
solo q
I'm actually afraid that they were serious...
Going to be honest here, forgot Evelyn existed for a bit.
I'll never forget the OP pub stomping days. 3k nuke ftw.
She still has this nuke, you know.
Only if you have 31 kills....
Her AP ratios were hit pretty hard and she lost her stun. She also used to get a portion of the champion killed's total health pool (10-20%) on kill or assist with 2.5 k health was a pretty big heal off some larger kills. I actually think that changing it helped a bit in some cases but i stiill miss that full health heal that you occasionally got when tards killed the tank first.
As a person who has every Eve skin and 500 or so games with her total I am really annoyed that they allow Shaco continue to have one of the most frustrating spell kits around, while using long stealth and the 'need' for a stealth remake as a reason not to balance Eve. Shaco has a strong stealth initiate/escape, the ability to jungle (boxes double as sustain), and a form of CC / zone control. A good Shaco can use the fact that he has a huge wall jump to simply avoid warded areas altogether at least with Eve wards let you control entrances to lanes, and oracles all but obliterate her team fighting potential since she has no escape skill.
that's why you need oracle's
Eve is strong with a team, that supports her. Focus the oracle and get one yourself to clear pink wards.
I dont think she's op, but we had a Victor mid, that fed her after having lost his tower and kept pushing away from the pinkward I had put him on his lane. We lost.
Another game i kept pinkwarding, my team kept having stealth vision, Evelynn fed and got zoned. We won.
Against a team, that doesn't know her simply because she is "underplayed" she might seem op.
She was my laning partner for my first game of the day yesterday, I was Caitlyn.
We got steamrolled by Tryn and Sion, fun times. And by we, I mean I, she was hiding in a bush.
Pretty sure it was just a premade team joking.
31/8/10 though.. they may be seriously mad,
they could have been trolling
I've seen people being this pissy about losing on EUW a few times. They are usually godawful at the game.
I've mentioned it before, but I've seen first hand in games and when judging tribunal that A LOT of players will report someone whos doing really well just because they are bad sports. They believe if they get the numbers of reports in that, regardless of scenario, the person will get a suspension.
And this can be true lol. If they see you enter the tribunal 4 times it doesn't matter why, suspension here you go.
They might be really bad/low level players. Evelynn was problematic because she would often fluctuate between stomping everyone, and being stomped by everyone.
[deleted]
Level 18 Champion. Not summoner. That means that the evelynn was level 18 by the end of the game
This is made obvious by the fact that they aren't yelling at/blaming and reporting each other instead of Eve.
[deleted]
I think you underestimate the stupidity of people. I've seen worse.
Even if they are, there ARE teams like that, so I wouldn't be surprised at all if they weren't.
It's not like they said "EVE TALKING SHIT SO MUCH" etcetc, they were saying Eve was OP, & then the intentionally feeding thing.
True, true. Still, my interpretation was that they were just bad sports trying to get back at a player that really annoyed them, which happens a lot.
Again, I'm not saying it isn't joking or fake or whatnot, but it could very well be "sincere" at the same time.
I had a teemo reported for feeding he went 3/0/1. Tribunal is biggest waste of time..
those are the people that dont know how the tribunal exists and figure "if i report, riot is gonna see it and ban him."
too true, because riot are the ones that review every individual game through tribunal, or do they?
As I understand it, it first goes to tribunal, and then gets checked by riot, and only after that is punishment ever delivered.
The only time it's automated is for leaving, I think.
0% of cases that go to tribunal are banned. If they get into the tribunal, they have a good chance of getting banned, even for something small.
Wut?
Huh?
I had a case where someone reported a person for verbal abuse. He said nothing the whole game.
Could have been in the chat in the stats page. I have seen people not say much all game and start talking like a 15 year old that wasn't beat enough as a child in post game chat.
Which means that Riot needs to put pre game and post game lobby chat in the tribunal.
favourite quote of today "talking like a 15 year old that wasn't beat enough as a child" you sir, are a genius
He might report the wrong player, that's what I usually asume on those situations.
Or maybe the reported was insulting on the lobby, you wouldn't know.
This is true but sometimes you get the most ludicrous reports - four people, "offensive language," one of them says "Just read the chat", only said "mia" all game.
Had a case where a Kassadin got reported for the same thing. I think he actually spoke once and just asked if he could have the 2nd blue buff. I don't think he even got a reply. lol.
Agreed, I got reported yesterday for "feeding" when i went 0/2/27 on Janna. I really don't understand people.
FEEDER.
WHY U NO PLAY LIKE XPECIAL?!
Srs: Nice Janna score :o
I love/hate games like that. As if you didn't keep people alive, interrupt ults, or ward the entire map about 34849 times.
I generally get reported by every 4 man german pre made when I refuse to take the abuse they hurl at me
The job of the Tribunal is to filter out wrong reports. Riot created it because their support was couldn't handle the huge number of reports.
Maybe if Riot was the ones doing the banning and checking each report (similar to world of warcraft) people would take the risk of a ban more seriously. I know they look at some cases (very few) but Im sure they could hire some people on minimum wage or internship students to go over the reports.
As I wrote in another posting in this thread already: All bans longer than 24h are checked and issued by Riot. Shorter bans are automated and Riot reviews a part of them.
Where do you get these cases where people are innocent? Every case I review has multiple games where they raged, called people noobs, used racial slurs etc.
Id say in my 15 cases I did last week 1 was innocent and even he did rage a little but not enough to warrant a ban. Apparently 8 of my cases were correctly judged as well..
Calling someone a noob is not a bannable offense.
actually it is according to riot...
Sure it is. How does that not violate the summoner's code?
i had a case where this caitlyn went 22/0/5, and carried her team.
the whole opposing team reported her for feeding.
judging if reports are justified is exactly the point of tribunal. the option "intentional feeding" is a waste of time if anything
In lol always assume that they are seriously stupid.
I really think they were serious.
They are serious, check the date of the game.
December of 2011? Eve was already nerfed to hell at that point.
Her major nerf patch wasn't until late January.
The last time Eve was changed was in the Yorick patch, June 22, 2011. Meaning that she had already been nerfed in December of that same year.
Of 2012? No...
na, late game she is a beast, people forget about her because she has a bad early game and can be easily countered with sight wards and oracles, but late game oh well, cuz she will come up and rape you
Premades are always serious on tribunal.
[deleted]
It does not indicate that summoner's lvl is 18.It's in game Lvl.Means evellynn champion was lvl 18 at the end of the game.
tough Case there - you should consider banning her, if 4 ppl on the team reported her!! And she probably wasn't cheating either, since Eve so OP! the intire game makes no sense anymore. /irony
FTFY. Learn what irony is!
You should learn what satire is, since that's not a rhetorical device, but rather a form of expression that often involves irony or sarcasm or both.
If we are to analyse what he said, it would be difficult to classify it as either sarcasm or irony, since those two often overlap.
I would say it was sarcastic, but it involved an ironic statement ("since Eve so OP").
The ironic thing is no one fucking cares.
Oh Irony, how you elude so many.
Well, if they are, they're not too far from the truth. Yeah, she's not uncontrollably OP. But under right circumstances, she can be made so strong that she just wins everything.
By under the right circumstances do you mean the other team doesn't know what oracles is?
Well, yes, that's the reason she was nerfed in the first place, because Evelynn completely ruined the game for newer players and less experienced players. It's not unimaginable that Evelynn still pubstomps a significant amount of low skilled players. Even if people know how to buy Oracles/Vision Wards, they may not know how to use them correctly. Evelynn may be unviable in intelligent play, but she's far from unable to prey on weaker players.
Woah man. These guys aren't bad players. They said so themselves. Roit should nerf eve because she kills everyone with eaz, she ruins the intire game.
I completely agree I was just making the statement semi-jokingly in low levels she is still good and carries in the right hands and "knowing what oracles is" is knowing how to use it. On a side note I think the way the learning curve for LoL is heading soon even low levels she won't be viable in her current state.
or wards
.. It's pathetic how people think that Oracles instantly wins Evelynn. Go play her a few times, perhaps then you'd know.
I have, and I never said it was an instant win,however it does make her way less efective if you get it before she can do anything.It's pathetic how people look at vague answers and assume that the person who wrote it is stupid and arguing with them.
please. she has trouble fighting caster minions.
Nah, passive too strong.
Best passive in the game. She can stay in the middle of the creeps and therefore farm easily and kill every1!!111!!!!!1!1
You don't lane Evelynn.
You don't jungle Evelynn either. You simply do not play Evelynn.
playing against people who don't know not to overextend or to buy oracles/pinks?
5man afk?
guys did you know that if you play riven and the other team doesn't buy armor she does a lot of damage????
i dont know if she's op or not, but under the right circumstances she's just so strong! especially when i have 40 kills as her!
Awww, you're cute. Now get hit by a flying turd.
Oracles/pinks don't counter Evelynn. They make life a bit easier against her, but Evelynn is still effective through them. Besides, they won't all be running in a 5 man ball with oracles 24/7. Pink wards? Eve can get an oracle of her own and get ahead that way. Either they continue buying pinks and you destroy them, or they stop buying and you destroy the players.
This guy thinks eve is actually good lol
Those circumstances being not buying pinks/oracles.
Not true.
Ok this isnt a 1v1 game, but ill gladly 1v1 you to see your eve....skills.
Nidalee W is a hard counter to eve FYI, and I can have as many as I want on the map!
Nidalee W is 18 sec CD, with 4min duration. So with max CDR you can at any point in time have 22 traps. Not as many as you want.
It's like Twitch. Just because they can stealth doesn't mean they are absolutely ruined if a pink ward is put down. Twitch still has his passive and E. Eve can just run up to someone and absolutely wreck them if she is fast enough. The stealth is nice as it gets them closer without being seen and gives about 1 second of surprise.
well played stealth champion is a true god.
True, it's just that Eve and Twitch don't really need the stealth to be strong. When I play Twitch, I just use his Q to walk up to towers and get the AS bonus.
Eve has trouble 1v1'ing the wolves, much less another champion.
She has the worst kit in the game, and the worst base stats in the game. And is melee.
False...She can 1v1 champs just fine...
And being melee is now a problem? Okay.
Love you man♥
R + Lich Bane + Ghost + Mobility Boots = Get in range before anyone has time to react through Oracles.
Pink wards? Oracle of your own.
wait does Eve start with Lichbane and Mob Boots? I'll have to play her.