r/carvana•
nm1515

WARNING - 2011 Mercedes E350 Wagon

Negative Review

I hope this might be able to help someone if they happen to see it and are considering buying this car. It is a black 2011 Mercedes E350 Wagon, can't seem to share the vin or the stock number without getting the post removed.

Carvana picked this mess up from me this morning at 10AM and it is already re-listed for sale. I can see a bunch of people have saved the car on their profile since it was re-listed for pre-order. Do not be seduced by its clean looks! This car is not well.

I bought this car and had it for 5 days total between initial delivery and the return pickup today. While it looks amazing from the outside and inside (it really is a stunning car with clean interior), the inspection I had done showed several serious issues. They couldn't be bothered to do a rudimentary inspection before spending thousands of dollars and labor hours to send this thing all the way across the country, so I doubt all of these issues will be addressed before shipping this POS off to the next victim.

Below are the issues that passed through their "150 point inspection":

- Needs rotors and pads all around

- Several errors cleared but not dealt with in computer

- Power steering/steering issues (PS overfilled, serious whine and heavily bogs down engine when wheel turned at idle and low rpm), steering gear issue

- Transmission leaking lots of fluid

- Oil drain plug leaking heavily, car smokes and burns oil, can smell inside cockpit and visibly see smoke coming out of grille after driving

- oil filter cap/housing stripped

- Problem with the SAM module (something dealer would need to fix)

- Most importantly as this can't be covered up/easily fixed like most of the above - Mechanic said there were serious drivetrain issues sure to come and damage due to wrong wheel size and mis matched tires being used on the vehicle. OE is 245/45/17 - Came with 18 in wheels, with 225/40/18 front and 255/35/18 rear - car is 4x4, not good...

Posted Feb 5, 2022, 9:51 PM UTC · edited

514
DontAbuseWomen•

A 10 year old Mercedes from carvana. No shit it’s a POS

17
nm1515OP•

Well, thats not necessarily a given. Only 71k miles on it for an 11 year old car. The interior and exterior are mint, it seriously looks brand new. The car would be fine for a long life with most of the items listed completely addressed (they won't be), but some dumbass putting mis-matched tire sizes on it and wrecking the drivetrain is not really something that is common or expected regardless of where its purchased from. Just my two cents.

3†
ImpureJelly•

This is such a bitch made response. Is this a Carvana employee? DontAbuseWomen is his handle lmfaoooo

0†
nm1515OP•

Seriously. I don't understand how so many people are seemingly ok with this bullshit business practice. It's insane.

1
Jimmy543o•

I’m glad you were able to return it. Not so happy it’s already relisted. Some people want luxury, but please understand not to buy old used German cars. They become even more expensive as they age. Nothing wrong on your part as for the mechanical condition. Carvana claims to do a 150 point inspection. You should not have received a vehicle with so many issues in the first place.

3
nm1515OP•

Yeah thats the thing my 2008 Mercedes wagon had almost 200k miles on it and still ran like it was a new car before it was crushed by a tree. I guess It really just depends on how well they’re taken care of.

2
profishh•

Just got a 2007 e wagon with 41,000 miles from my dad last week. Fabulous car.

3
nm1515OP•

Unbelievably low miles for a 2007! That thing will take you far. Enjoy and congrats!

1
ImpureJelly•

Went through a similar experience. Whoever is doing these vaunted "150 point inspections" are doing the bare minimum and turning it around for a profit. I don't even know who Carvana has do them, but they are shoddily done and generally speaking unfit.

2
DangerZoneDelux•

Everything went is automatically listed available after a return. If informed them upon return of the issues it should get tagged for inspection and addressed or kicked out to auction. It takes time for the process to work. It’s one of the reasons people experience delays after ordering a vehicle.

1
dukedizzy93•

An 11 year old mercedes with only a few minor issues? you actually got lucky with that one.

1
nm1515OP•

??? Its not like I bought it from some jackoff in a private sale. I bought it from a publicly traded company that claims to do full inspections and reconditioning on all vehicles. It should have exactly ZERO issues in order for it to pass their "150 point inspection" not several critical issues.

1
theRealMaldez•

Ngl bro, it sounds like your mechanic saw that the inspection results would be paid for by a big company and went for the gold. It's called 'selling the shop/truck' in the industry. I'll run you through the list:

Pads and rotors; maintenance item for one, for two, did he provide percentages? Did he say specifically what was wrong with the rotors? If you don't believe me, take a brand new car to pepboys and ask them if you need brake pads. 99% chance they're going to bring it in, then tell you it needs rotors too.

Codes: this one is probably true, but it's an 11 year old Mercedes, did he list what the codes were? How did he pull them up if you didn't see the check engine light on? Usually you need a certain number of key cycles or miles for codes to come back on after theyve been clear. Also, take into consideration that he's also using aftermarket software rather than OEM Mercedes software which tends to require some finesse to do anything above reading active codes.

Oil plug leaking: probably a cheap fix. Either needs to be upsized or an o-ring replaced. If it's smoking from the engine compartment it's not burning oil, oil is dripping on the exhaust. My guess would be the PS reservoir lol. Burning oil would mean blue smoke out of the tailpipe.

Transmission leaks: did he say what was leaking? Could be a 50cent oring, could be more. If it was a massive leak, how did you not notice it?

The steering thing: Probably a combination of PS pump and the oversized wheels, if those wheels are wider than stock or flat. Could be something as simple as the belt being too tight. Edit: you probably have a bad PS line that's leaking. Probably up close to the actual PS pump on the engine, or the pump itself. Would explain the pump and the noise and the fact that it's overfilled.

Oil filter: normal for Mercedes, especially if prior owner took it to jiffy lube.

Tire size/power train issues: giant crock of shit. Theoretically, is it possible? Sure. It's not tire size that causes power train drag, it's unsprung weight(Weight not supported by the suspension eg. Rims, tired, wheel end assemblies, brakes, axles, ect.). Usually putting 18"s on a car like that means using low profile tires. As long as the weight is close to stock it's fine. Even still, unless they're figures of magnitude heavier, the strain put on the mechanical parts is so slight that the car would have to live multiple times beyond it's lifespan to see realized damage. If what he was saying was true, every redneck south of the mason Dixon line would be replacing engines and transmissions on a yearly basis as it's customary to put significantly larger rims and tires on their pickups, while lifting the frame higher off the axles which deviates the drive shaft angles away from stock, causing additional strain, then they tow stupid heavy things around for fun or something.

In conclusion, whoever did the inspection saw a Mercedes (insanely high labor/part costs) which was under a third party warranty(usually third party warranties just blindly write checks based off alldata time estimates and preset part costs, rarely do they have an independent adjuster confirm the diagnostics) owned by a person that didn't seem to know much about cars(because they bought an 11 year old Mercedes sight-unseen on the internet) and decided to upsell the shit out of the job(depending on the shop, a lot of mechanics get paid flat rate; eg. If the book time is x hours, they get paid their hourly rate for x hours regardless of how long the job actually takes, which means that a lot of the time a mechanics creative writing ability determines their paycheck more than their ability to spin wrenches, and a lot of the time they also get paid commission on part sales). Lastly, I'm not trying to slam mechanics here, because usually and especially in the chain repair shops management sees the shop techs as salesmen, not repair techs. There's a lot of pressure to upsell things, to cart-blanche part orders in specific mechanical subsystems(that means ordering unnecessary odds and ends like hardware to drive the cost up), and to play up minor issues. They even offer useless services like A/C system flushes(refrigerant doesn't have an expiration date, and it's a pressurized/sealed system so there's really no way for contaminants to get in unless they open it up, by doing things like A/C system flushes) and will attempt to sell legitimate services outside the mfg recommended service windows.

Finally, as an industry professional, I'd highly discourage buying any older model luxury vehicle. They're maintenance hogs and that maintenance is fucking expensive. Even still, they aren't any more reliable than a non-luxury brand. Hell, half the time the power trains in luxury brands are the same as the non-luxury brands owned by the same manufacturer, and in some cases literally the only difference is the brand emblem and packages. Are Mercedes nice cars? Sure. But unless you're buying new(smarter to lease) and trading it in once the warranty is up, you're basically throwing money away. We're talking, in some cases, a 100% price difference on oil changes between a Mercedes and comparable class non-luxury brand.

Edit: reread your post and added something I missed.

1
nm1515OP•

Lol what? They told me not to take the car they didn’t want my business! They said send that shitbox back where it came from and don’t buy it! They are a serious and honest shop, which is why I took it to them for inspection

Edit: To solidify my reasoning and defend the shop mechanics: I went and bought a 2016 Merc wagon this week, from local Carmax instead. Took it to them for inspection and they did the same whole inspection. Said its in great shape and the only thing worth keeping an eye on now is the battery maybe in 6 months to a year. Didn’t charge me for anything or try to upsell me on any repairs. These people took care of my ‘08 wagon for many years. Its not a chain its just a family owned shop here in SC, they know me and I trust them fully which is why I was so appalled when they gave me the list of all the issues with the first car.

That aside I appreciate the detail and time you put into the comment. Maybe the mis matched front and rear tire sizes wasn’t all that big a deal but they said it would surely cause nightmares down the road, so I know they were just looking out for me and my $.

1