Bellroy Case after a Few Months

I have the black one and I'm guessing that it hides scuffs better for what it's worth.

After a couple months it mostly looks brand new. There are a few spots where I must have scraped it slightly, but it doesn't really show unless you look closely.

The leather wears pretty much like a leather belt would wear (but not right at the buckle where it gets rubbed all the time)

I had the same color for my Pixel 4XL and it still looks quite nice after 2 years. Hardly any discoloration. I am not rough at all on my phones though, pretty light handling.