r/sysadmin•
Yentle

AWS Backup

Hey guys, I'm thinking of replacing veeam for our windows server backups to aws s3 using aws volume gateway - cutting out veeam will save a lot of money, and I can't as of yet thing of many negatives - I was wondering if any of you kind gentlemen had any opinions or have experience of such?

Posted Feb 16, 2022, 9:34 PM UTC

210
-SPOF•

Since you're using windows you won't find anything better than Veeam if you need whole image backups. I've tested it myself with backing up and restoring on different hardware, works fail-proof.
If you need to push your backups to the cloud with a free Veeam Comunity Edition, just take a look at rclone https://rclone.org/. Alternatively, Starwind Virtual Tape Library is an option https://www.starwindsoftware.com/starwind-virtual-tape-library-free. You backup directly on the virtual tapes and push them to the cloud.

5
YentleOP•

Thanks for your input, I'll take a look at these!

5
DarkAlmanProfessional Looker up of Things•

Backups is not something you should be saving money on

Veeam works extremely well and I trust my job to it

4
smoothies-for-me•

It's also not even that expensive compared to other *real* backup solutions.

1
YentleOP•

Ah you see that's where you're wrong, unfortunately we need to save across the entire organisation, given recent events.

Our windows server backups will be tested bi-yearly to ensure that successful backups are indeed recoverable.

Nothing is held on site except cache for our AWS Gateway - it is automatically uploaded to S3, then replicated to Ireland and London and then backups older than one month are then automatically moved to S3 Glacier.

I think this is actually more resilient than veeam.

Any actual technical reqsons why this wouldn't work as well as veeam?

1
DarkAlmanProfessional Looker up of Things•

Any actual technical reqsons why this wouldn't work as well as veeam?

Anyone who's dealt with Microsoft Support during an emergency will understand why this is a bad idea

2
joeykilaita•

Why don't you look at Druva? They offer a SaaS AWS solution for VMs, NAS, DBs, File Servers, etc - software has built-in dedupe and they only charge you for storage used after deduplication. Forever incremental backup, ingress/egress all included, and if you have an EDP you can retire commitment spend with it since it's available through marketplace. Their security is insane too.. no backdoor access - ransomware can't traverse your historical snapshots :)

2
YentleOP•

I'll take a look at this, thanks!

2
joeykilaita•

No problem!

1
phpfiction•

It's very complicated, 5 years ago I did that before with community edition, but it was not the result expected, no encryption, no cloud, no DRP, no integrity check and lot of monitoring time.

Every VBK should had be extracted to VMDK and used with aws cli to vmimport with no snapshots and not vmexport possibilities.

You have less than 10 vm and use drp, try Veeam B&R Essentials, I'm sure your data worth more than a day of transactions in the company.

1