The end of silicon [crosspost from /r/technology]
Posted Apr 28, 2012, 11:22 AM UTC
Posted Apr 28, 2012, 11:22 AM UTC
Im putting my money on carbon nano-fiber something or other as the base or the next processors.
You can use carbon nanotubes or silicon nanowires, but nanofiber is not a regularly accepted term, at least it it pertains to electronics.
how about cotton candy made out of carbon? is that more of an accepted term?
As a student studying semiconductor devices, this video confuses me at some points.
Moore's law predicts the number of transistors to double, not the computational power.
Ideal computational power is directly related to the number of transistors.
Intel isn't going to "three-dimensional chips", but rather non-planar transistors.
Non-planar = 3-D. Those terms are synonyms. Also, from Wikipedia:
In 2004, Intel presented a 3D version of the Pentium 4 CPU. The chip was manufactured with two dies using face-to-face stacking, which allowed a dense via structure. Backside TSVs are used for IO and power supply. For the 3D floorplan, designers manually arranged functional blocks in each die aiming for power reduction and performance improvement. Splitting large and high-power blocks and careful rearrangement allowed to limit thermal hotspots. The 3D design provides 15% performance improvement (due to eliminated pipeline stages) and 15% power saving (due to eliminated repeaters and reduced wiring) compared to the 2D Pentium 4.
So there is experimentation going on with actual 3-D chips.
What layer is he talking about going down to 20 atoms? The oxide? The channel length?
He is referring to the channel length, I think. See here.
His description of the QM problems doesn't make sense.
He is referring to quantum computing, which actually uses the quantum nature of particles to compute answers. This requires very controlled circumstances to avoid the problems he is talking about.
I don't think you understood my complaints:
Ideal computational power is directly related to the number of transistors.
Right, but it's not Moore's law. The direct quote from the video is,
Years ago we physicists predicted the end of Moore's law that says that computer power doubles every eighteen months.
This is just flat-out wrong.
Non-planar = 3-D. Those terms are synonyms.
Chips aren't the same thing as transistors. The transistors are 3D.
He is referring to the channel length, I think.
He says the features are 20 atoms across, which would be 2nm, which is more on the order of oxide thickness and not channel length.
He is referring to quantum computing, which actually uses the quantum nature of particles to compute answers. This requires very controlled circumstances to avoid the problems he is talking about.
At 2min in the video? He's talking about QM effects on existing transistor performance, not quantum computers.
This is just flat-out wrong.
Not quite. I mean, he is citing the wrong person, but David House did say that was the effect of Moore's law.
Chips aren't the same thing as transistors. The transistors are 3D.
Yes, and the chip, being made of transistors, is now 3-D.
He says the features are 20 atoms across, which would be 2nm
You are forgetting the crystalline structure of silicon. The atoms are not directly touching, or even that close to each other. 20 atoms across means ~20 nm.
At 2min in the video? He's talking about QM effects on existing transistor performance, not quantum computers.
He's referring to the limit on the size of silicon transistors. You make them too small, and quantum tunneling means you cannot control the current flow.
Not quite. I mean, he is citing the wrong person, but David House did say that was the effect of Moore's law.
Davis House's statement was infamously inaccurate. I don't see how you think him saying Moore's Law predicts performance doubling isn't wrong.
You are forgetting the crystalline structure of silicon. The atoms are not directly touching, or even that close to each other. 20 atoms across means ~20 nm.
Having just looked it up, 20 atoms would correspond to a channel length of 11nm -- still beyond where we are today. I was thinking he meant the oxide because right now it's stuck at around 5 atoms due to tunneling, which is what he mentions. Conventional transistors stop working way before you get to 5 atoms, more like 10nm.
He's referring to the limit on the size of silicon transistors. You make them too small, and quantum tunneling means you cannot control the current flow.
He said nothing even remotely similar to that. Now you're quoting me and not the video:
When you make the channel too short, you start getting tunneling which means you no longer control whether your devices are on or off.
Surprised?
If I was going to put money on the table, it would be for graphite coated architectures.
you mean graphene?
Yea I gotta check
Graphene substrate to be specific.
yes.
I wouldn't. I'd put money down instead on optical architecture.
Hopefully if the chips are't increasing in performance as much, developers will spend more time optimizing in code and coming up with new algorithms like back in the day.
I would love to see what a mobo looks like that supports a 3d chip, as well as the heatsik.
They're already on the market. Ivy Bridge chips are three dimensional.
Also, does anyone know why this video doesn't mention graphene as a viable alternative?
AFAIK Graphine transistors are much more akin to BJT Transistors as opposed to CMOS, so their properties (currently) don't line up for traditional CPUs
Yes, in the sense BJTs have an off current. BJTs are much faster, but not scalable to VLSI. They still aren't sure how to turn them off well. However, dual Graphene layers looks promising there for properly controlling the bandgap.
=) awesome. It'll be interesting to see where they take graphene over the next few years
I was thinking of a large cube type chip when I heard 3d...
Imagine trying to cool the core of that thing though...
It would likely be built with heatsinks running through it to move the heat to the outside of the cube, where more traditional looking heatsinks cool it off as fast as possible. Still, it sounds like a chore.
Alternatively, there could be a 3-D built in liquid cooling system, similar to that used to cool the brain with blood. Either way, you would also need a drastic reduction in power consumption. (The brain, for instance, only uses around 20W.)
yea that would be a task.
Graphene (and CNTs) are difficult to process and manufacture the same way Silicon is.
However, there has been research on using CNT channels for high-performance ballistic transport:
http://nano.eecs.berkeley.edu/publications/NanoLett_2012_CNTcircuits.pdf
Well hurry up and start making artificial brains instead. We know they're several times more powerful than conventional computers.
They don't even require fans and heatsinks.
Blood serves as a cooling system for the brain. While not as prevalent in humans, other animals have countercurrent heat exchangers near the brain (nose or mouth, usually) that cool blood entering the brain, with the added benefit of warming the blood entering the core.
TL;DR, brains do have heatsinks
For algorithmic, serial calculations, brains are absolutely terrible. In many ways, computers were designed to supplement our natural limitations. Humans are great at all kinds of things - 3-space orientation, understanding language, finding patterns etc etc etc. We are also hopeless at some things. Basically anything that can be broken down into a set of discrete instructions would run orders of magnitude faster on current silicon architecture than on any brain.
TL;DR brains are not good at solving many of the problems we use computers to solve.