r/audiophile•
missing1102

Dirac

Impressions

I love my avr but my wife does not. She might live wirh a small two channel set up when we downsize. I was thinking like a mini dsp Dirac type thing? I would appreciate any advice or experience with using two channels wirh Dirac . I have good amplifiers and a good media server. I just have not used two channels in a long time now other than the occasional break out the 80s vinyl with my wife's system. We have our own spaces and now we have to converge. Thanks.

Posted Feb 20, 2022, 7:22 AM UTC

127
heres_tubbers•

No personal experience but sounds like this might suit your needs: miniDSP Flex

Curious myself. Tempted to ditch the standalone DAC and play with room correction.

5
missing1102OP•

Yes. This is what I was thinking. Like do I use wirh a standard old school two channel amp wirh that or go smaller d class and use like two nice bookshelves with subs mixed in well. I learned a lot about sound during covid but understand my wife is not dealing with my audio circus in a new place.

1
blutengelmegadeth•

Since you did not mention the budget I think 🤔 NAD M10 V2 would suit your needs?

3
missing1102OP•

I would like to spend about 5k.

1
missing1102OP•

So like go smaller. Is that a D class amp?

1
breweres•

You can’t really go smaller than the M10. Really, it sounds like the M10 is exactly what you are looking for. Save any balance in the budget for Roon.

I run an M10 with dual SVS 3000 Micros and a rotation of bookshelf speakers currently including Revel M16s, JBL 530s, and Cambridge Audio Aeros. Single driver Omegas on the way.

The M10 is an outstanding option for people looking to go small and simplify without compromising sound quality and function. And Dirac Live is a game changer.

The miniDSP Flex piece is intriguing, but given the quality of the BluOS ecosystem and the potential to do other things with it around your home, something like the M10 is probably your best option.

3
missing1102OP•

Wow. Nad had a whole list of products that are very interesting. This has everything for the same price as a decent avr and is very nice looking. The hdmi is a definite need. That was another hard part of giving up the avr. I love this very much as well. Thank you.

2
face_the_light•

MiniDSP SHD series or MiniDSP 2x4HD if you already have sources and a preamp.

Both options will allow you to run Dirac on 4 channels (stereo mains and one or two subs).

As with all room correction, best results come from careful microphone positioning. Dirac is very effective, in my experience. Play with it - you'll be able to tweak the effect to your limitations and preferences more than an AVR's correction.

3
missing1102OP•

I have a good media pc.. I was tying to figure out how to downsize the preamp/amp thing.. I would probably get a d class NAD maybe with a phono. I liked the Dirac on a Pioneer I bought but the amp sucked so I returned it. I definitely think that's the route I want to go. I currently am tired of Audyssey on the Denon and the app is to hard to adjust the curve on my phone..

2
LosterP•

What's your usage? What's your current system made of? What are you looking to keep? What's your budget?

2
missing1102OP•

My current system is a 5. 2..2. I am running a Denon 4400. I am suing Mirage omd 15 home theater set up. I have two elac subwoofers . The towers are good but will go. The surrounds are excellent but not enough for what I would like. I honestly have multiple sets of speakers..my wife likes the kefQ150s so we would probably kick that up to the R series. I have a nice emotiva two channel amp. I probably need a decent pre pro...though we have a good vintage Onkyo. I would like to spend about 5k.

Edit. I think I would keep the emotiva, the technics, record player, maybe one sub. I would definitely spend a little more for an svs sub if I am only using one. I am not sure of the space. We might live in an apartment we own but the tennant is very sick and we are going to make sure she lives her life without any pressure form us.

2
Fi-B•

I wouldn’t claim my room is beyond improvement but it sounds good to me, in the way that I could hear the difference between a good and an excellent acoustic instrument played live. I regard my system as a source of music so that works well for me.

Point is, even if you’re going to correct acoustic anomalies with electronics (and I’m lucky that it’s not an issue for me) it will still pay to get your stereo space as good as you can. With surround you can go deader and that’s fine: with stereo I truly believe you need some “room” contributing to the sound.

Just to put my money where my mouth is, I’m building a valve (tube) amp for my stereo system. I hesitate to promote what must seem such a backward step to you, just putting the thought out in case.

2
missing1102OP•

No definitelynot backwards. I think sound is incredibly subjective. My wife and I saw a local performer open up for Robert Plant in NYC about six years ago and he came and played a party I had at my home. My large cathedral room sounded very good with live music. Not so hot with speakers. I gave up trying and retreated to my man cave where I kind of fell in love surround sound. I literally bought the avr to listen to Rush in 5.1. I think since we are going to downsize I feel like I need a system I can live with but still tinker with. I have a lot of space where I currently am so I literally play at 80 plus decibels all the time. It's a luxury I have to learn to live without soon. I was thinking like how to downsize and still use subwoofers and get that clean sound.

1
UmlauticaHear Hear!•

The Monoprice HTP-1 is worth checking out. Unlike the MiniDSP products, it has loudness compensation and is designed for multichannel content.

2
missing1102OP•

This is a different can of worms. I have seen this and it has everyhting. This could let me do a down scaled ..but rather expensive home theater. I have to look at the specs for dolby Atmos. I wondered if I could do 2.2.2 in a bed room. I would be having rugs for the first time in years and years instead of all hard wood.

1
UmlauticaHear Hear!•

I reread your post and see that it doesn't really solve your problem.

I can answer any MiniDSP ddrc-24 questions you might have though.

2
dicmccoyKef Q950/JL D110 x 2/NAD C658/IOTAVX pa3 x 2•

Stay away from anything HD series from miniDSP. They are noisy as hell. You'll thank me later. I have the 4x10HD and it's a piece of crap. I'll never purchase another miniDSP box. I will purchase their Umik mics though. Those are a handy tool. As for Dirac for 2 channel. It's pure bliss. I have Dirac built into my NAD C658 preamp running my 2.2 system. What it does with soundstage/imaging and fixing smearing/instrument bleeding is jaw dropping good.

2
missing1102OP•

Ok. So the Dirac is part of the preamp. I also noticed it would has an hdmi switch a available. It's almost like a a hybrid. It's also not terribly expensive. This wirh the two channel amp I have would work very nicely. Maybe I use the nvidia Shiled and rip my 4ks .

1
dicmccoyKef Q950/JL D110 x 2/NAD C658/IOTAVX pa3 x 2•

Yes, it also has BluOS built into it. That is what runs the NAD C658. So all your streaming is built right in. If you want HDMI, you will have to purchase the MDC HDM-2 module. I purchased the C658 to replace my IOTAVX sa3 (used as a preamp), miniDSP 4x10HD and Node 2i. I wanted more of a smarter all in one preamp solution to cut down on components and wires. The C658 does have an included hockey puck style mic. The phone/tablet Dirac app can only support the included mic. The results with the phone/tablet app are hit and miss. The results are not consistent. You also cannot load target curves you have downloaded online with the mobile app, such as the NAD and Harman Target curves. I use Dirac 3 that I downloaded onto my Mac Mini and a Umik-1 from miniDSP that is plugged into the Mac. The results are consistent every time. The included "tripod" mic stand that comes with the Umik-1 is ultra tiny. I purchased a boom arm mic stand and screwed on the mic holder that comes with the Umik-1 tripod stand.

2
missing1102OP•

Yes. I have been reading a little about the mic that seems like a necessity. When I did Dirac before it was on the phone based app I really would like something that gives me that clarity. I just felt like I heard more speration with the Dirac than anything else I have ever heard.

1
dicmccoyKef Q950/JL D110 x 2/NAD C658/IOTAVX pa3 x 2•

I saw that you said, you use vinyl. All the NAD products with Dirac will convert that analog signal to digital. So if you have any other speaker systems around the house and you use a Bluesound product on them, like a Node or another NAD with BluOS, whatever you're playing on one, you can link it to the others.

2
dicmccoyKef Q950/JL D110 x 2/NAD C658/IOTAVX pa3 x 2•

Also, the included version of Dirac that is included with the C658 is the limited bandwidth edition. It will only correct 500hz and below. For an extra $100 you can unlock the full frequency version from Dirac for the NAD, that will get you 20hz-20khz.

2
breweres•

I own both the 658 and M10. Both running 2.2 systems. The 658 feeds the matching 268 power amp. The two systems more or less sound and function the same. Biggest difference is the 658 has a phono preamp on board. I run Dirac on MacOS and have the UMIK-1 as well. I have tried the puck mics as well and not noticed any difference - but it would be really hard to do really A/B something like that. Since the UMIK-1 doesn't add a huge amount to the costs - it is probably a reasonable purchase either way.

If you are really looking to simplify as your post suggests, the M10 is the way to go. Consider selling off the other stuff to fund it. The amps on board the M10 will likely be of higher quality than the Emotiva (I think you mentioned that) and you have one less box to mess with. It makes basically no heat, and has the display and design are truly beautiful. Your significant other may even think its cute - but it's still real deal audiophile stuff. Any if you really wanted to get a bit smaller - the Bluesound Powernode is an M10 light. Hard to beat the value there - but you lose the cool display.

Remember that your TV can serve as an ARC hub for your video sources at this point - so a switching function isn't really necessary for many people. BluOS is pretty rock solid at this point, and the synced play works more or less perfectly for me. Adding Roon is a huge plus if you play a lot of music. The best thing about the BluOS enabled NAD gear (or the BluOS pieces themselves) is that when you press play for music on your phone - they just turn on and switch to the right source. So many people end up fussing with remotes and source switching - and it just isn't necessary any more.

I should also say I have had very good luck ordering NAD B-Stock thru Safe and Sound HQ in Chicopee, MA. They are very responsive to questions, process orders very quickly, and do everything that you would want a dealer online to do - without you asking.

2
missing1102OP•

That's excellent information. I don't live far from that company so shipping would be quick. I totally appreciate that break down. I have some nice stuff here that is well made. The Mirage speakers are beautiful ans sound nice. I am sure I could get some money for them. Maybe it's time to get back on ebay. This is my last Denon. I tried so hard wirh these products becaue I listened to the reviews on audio science. My 300 dollar Sony sounds as good and does not give me any of the trouble with hdmi,audessy, all of it.

1
Manner_Mann•

Lyngdorf TDAI 1120. Roomperfect>Dirac (imho).

1