Marc Ó Cathasaigh TD on Twitter - relative in depth discussion on the PM Bill on carbon tax. "Per person we emit nearly twice the global average of carbon. By comparison per capita emission from a Chinese person is 7 tCO2e, and from an Indian person is 1.6 tCO2e. We are the 1%."

Posted Feb 24, 2022, 8:14 AM UTC

356
Dookwithanegg•

'we' are not the 1%, it's unfair and unreasonable to repeatedly place the burden of green living on individuals when industry emissions far outstrips what anyone could conceivably achieve.

45
fungie89•

Individual demand drives industry though. If individuals change their behaviours because of tax then industry will have to follow suit, otherwise they will lose out in the long run.

9
Dookwithanegg•

A lot of our industrial and agricultural demand is international.

12
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2†
kingofthecrowsCrilly!!•

That's just an excuse to avoid responsibility. Consumerism is a choice

-1†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4†
eoinerboner•

This video sums up the role of personal responsibility in relation to the environment very well IMO

https://youtu.be/yiw6_JakZFc

0†
Eurovision2006Gael•

Eh, yes it is. People are perfectly capable of not eating meat, going on flights or buying clothes and tech.

0
Ballin_kapper•

Ireland is one of the least industry intensive economies in the world…

1
Dookwithanegg•

Agriculture and Large industry make up over 50% of our emissions, the rest is divided among SMEs, residential, and other lesser uses.

2
Remote_Package5119•

Are most of the manufacturing industries in china anyways?

1
Dookwithanegg•

About a quarter of global manufacturing is China, though they do have a higher population than us, them being about 1/5th of the world's population, so there's more ways to divide it out.

1
Eurovision2006Gael•

Yeah cause it's just the big, bad corporations making all that stuff for nothing. It's ridiculous to make out that all of the developed world isn't to blame.

0
das_punter•

Hasn’t this 1% trope been well debunked by now? We are nothing in comparison to industries.

20
Hour_Mastodon_9404•

The argument that in total terms Ireland is a small emitter is meaningless, it's a bit like saying "sure that guy over there murdered scores of people, so why should I stop murdering a few?". Delinquent behaviour is still delinquent behaviour even if you believe the overall effects are minor in comparison to other actors, it is not an excuse to do nothing. As pointed out, on a per capita basis we're emitting double what we should, so that has to be answered for.

15
MotoPsychofleg•

It also ignores that everywhere can be broken down into smaller populations. China has 1.4 billion people but a lot less than that live in a random village or a random street in Shanghai.

7
Ballin_kapper•

To the people saying that you can’t compare China to Ireland, how are you going to tell China to reduce their emissions when you are doing nothing to reduce your own?

Obviously small countries can claim that their emissions don’t matter, however, if you want to drive change you need to make a least a token effort to avoid looking like a complete hypocrite.

5
Perpetual_Doubt•

how are you going to tell China to reduce their emissions when you are doing nothing to reduce your own?

Because they are producing a third of the world's emissions.

A third of the world's emissions.

Gonna say it again for the people at the back: a third of the word's emissions.

If Greenland had 5* the emissions per capita as we do who'd give a shit? The amount that Greenland produces is infinitesimal in the bigger scheme of things. As is the case with Ireland. If Ireland ceased to exist tomorrow no meaningful change in global emissions would result.

1
Eurovision2006Gael•

Okay and considering Europe's emissions are bigger than China's does that not mean it's more important that we reduce ours?

This is a complete cop-out. Ireland is one of the biggest emitters in the world and the people will have to accept the changes necessary.

-1
Perpetual_Doubt•

Okay and considering Europe's emissions are bigger than China's does that not mean it's more important that we reduce ours?

Where on earth did you get that idea from?

in 2018 China's CO2 emissions, including LUCF was 9,663.36. The EU's was 2,636.98

Remember that in 2018 that the EU figures would have included the UK.

China's per capita emissions are higher than the EU as of 2020.

Ireland is one of the biggest emitters in the world

The 68th biggest emitter, just below Serbia. Oh when will Serbia step up and sort out climate change.

If we aren't interested in who the biggest emitters are (and China is by a loooooong shot) and instead interest in just per capita, Ireland is in 38th spot.

2
Eurovision2006Gael•

Please tell me, who drives China's economy? It isn't perhaps Western consumers is it?

What is even your point? We shouldn't do anything because they're not bothering. We're never going to get anywhere like that.

0
Karma-bangs•

Cut back the dairy herd by half. Problem solved.

5
Nurofenplus2020•

This was posted lady night op

2
Bandit6888Waterford•

Yes, but also no.

Looking at the EPA website transport and residential made up 17.4 million tonnes CO2, transport at 10.3 and residential at 7.1 respectively.

Agriculture is at 21.4 million tonnes making up 37.1% of the country's total emissions.

Further looking at 2019 charts we are the highest in Europe per Capita for CH4(methane gas) at 2.99 tonnes per capita and 7.55 tonnes of CO2 which is roughly in line with the original EU15.

Obviously we all have a personal responsibility in reducing our CO2 but the elephant in the room(agriculture) is always over looked.

EPA link for anyone interested

2
Anderi45•

Ireland feeds the f***ing world! Of course we spew out crap loads of co2! Per capita the output of meat, dairy and tillage is insane!

2
CajunPenguin•

Complaining about the "populist left" and saying we should listen to Paschal Donohoe indicates that this guy is in no way serious about tackling climate change.

1
MoneyBadgerEx•

Climate doesn't change on a per capita basis though. This is like trying to clear up hard drive space by archiving your word documents while you also record raw video in 4k, because its just one video but a whole thirty documents.

1

I won't be given him a high preference again so!

0†
Eurovision2006Gael•

Who else will prioritise environmental issues?

0
niall0•

The Chinese thing is a weird comparison, their population is over 1.4 billion people

0†
louiseberStill don't actually want a flair •

As is Indian one, huge swathes of their population don't live in urdan areas and barely have a pot to piss in, living subsistence or much lower on the poverty scale.

That's lies, damn lies and statistics to make us all feel shitty and swallow whatever taxes they have coming for us. Regardless of our cost of living spirals

11
Qorhat•

Not to mention it doubles down on pushing climate action back on the individual instead of corporations

2
Eurovision2006Gael•

Yeah cause those corporations are just spewing out emissions for nothing. Not like they're just fulfilling consumer demand.

1
Eurovision2006Gael•

Are you saying that the average Irish person isn't living excessively and needs to give up more than most of the rest of the world?

1
louiseberStill don't actually want a flair •

If you're living excessively, can I come live with you

1
Eurovision2006Gael•

I am living excessively, but much less so than most Irish people.

1
purinatrucks•

We literally have no public transport outside urban areas and have a far colder climate than the countries used in comparison, fucking cunt

0†
Eurovision2006Gael•

We literally have no public transport outside urban areas

Well that's the people's fault. The Greens have said how we can fix that, but the people have refused.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1