Project Cancellations

Practice

Projects get canceled on occasion for various reasons.
I run a small firm and don't have too much of a problem when a job evaporates, it doesn't happen often, but because of our size we have to regularly decline many new projects to fill the needs of the current contracts.

I'm wondering if other firms have a cancellation fee or non-refundable retainer to help fill the void? Any information on this is appreciated...

Posted Feb 27, 2022, 5:15 PM UTC

79
pencilarchitect•

I might be wrong but as far as I know it's very unusual to have anything like a cancellation fee in the contract, typically you would just front-load your fees in the schematic design/design development phases if you're worried about getting burned.

3
structuremonkeyOP•

My thoughts too. I worry about front load and too much of a retainer. I know that scenario can scare clients away. It hasn't been a recurring problem, and I've always filled the void quickly, but its always jarring when it happens and I wonder what happend to the other projects I had to pass on...human nature I guess.

1
DigitalKungFu•

This would be a great discussion for r/architects if it isn’t already there.

As for my own experience, a cancellation fee is certainly something that would have been beneficial, though there is still a number of unpaid invoices that I’m having trouble with and an unpaid cancellation fee would not be surprising

3
structuremonkeyOP•

Unpaid fees are a common problem. Really depends on the market though. I've had many who didn't pay part of their fee over the years, but its typically they got into something way over their head without fully realizing the total costs....I can't bring myself to "go hard after" people in that situation, and only hope that it brings good karma eventually...it seems to work out. I've always been fairly busy...

2

Most firms in my country break a project (and the associated fees) up in phases. So the client is free to cancel at any point but are obliged to pay up to the latest project phase.

They also charge a 10% deposit which they keep in case of premature cancellation.

2
structuremonkeyOP•

This is very similar to my approach, but my retainer / deposit is not always as much as 10% ( depending on the size and scope).

Am I understanding correctly; if they initiate a phase, the whole phase will be billed regardless? But if the next phase isn't started they can cancel without penalty other than the deposit?

Is the 10 % you mention paid in advance per phase, or for the entire project?

1
AlfaHotelWhiskeyPrincipal Architect•

The AIA contracts have pretty clear language regarding pausing or terminating a project. It certainly happens for many reasons and is a risk in the industry.

You can certainly put anything you want into an agreement regarding pauses or cancellations. If your value and market demand is strong enough do it by all means necessary!

You could also start charging retainers and put clients on a waitlist if they are willing to do pay. Don’t be self conscious if you have a great company that does great work and is in demand.

On the upside, if you want to see it this way, you got paid to work with ZERO liability or risk downstream. You might even be able to recycle portions of the work into a new job later.

0
structuremonkeyOP•

Good points, thank you!...I do see it as an odd win for firm development and less liability, but the hole to fill is not fun. I am a very small firm. Been 100% solo since the beginning of the pandemic, and enjoying the solo life. But, was considering brining back one or two employees to help. Situations like this make me re-think having to keep others healthy with payroll commitments, etc...its not an easy thing...

0
AlfaHotelWhiskeyPrincipal Architect•

Totally agree. It’s a big deal to grow. You could consider outsourcing some drafting to arch firms in Argentina. They speak marvelous English, are in a friendly timezone and are highly educated. You could then partner with one you end up liking as a flex option. Traditional staffing in this tech enabled era is not the only option for any sized firm.

Plus you might make great friends and have a kickass vacation in Argentina someday.

1