r/Star_Trek•
aitae

Discovery Captain.. first captain to whisper everything.

How do I drop a suggestion to the makers of Discovery? It is so very distracting, very silly, and very out of place that the captain whispers during times of crisis, whispers much needed commands, whispers in conversation, and basically anywhere she should simply speak normally.

Posted Mar 10, 2022, 5:16 AM UTC

1713
neelankatan•

I blame the actress, that's her crutch. Her idea of playing 'profound' is whispering. I'm not sure she can do it any other way, which is probably why the directors just kinda live with it and work around it. Just a guess, though.

16
aitaeOP•

think you are right.

3
donkleone•

"reach for them" ...."hhchfthhm"

2
Admirable_Ferret•

Bad actress and worse character

2
BCSWowbagger2•

My work friend dubbed it Star Trek: Sotto Voce before giving up after Lorca died.

2
shindleria•

Picard whispered hard in Yesterday’s Enterprise, hence why the Federation was getting its ass whupped by the Klingons.

-2
HeliumCurious•

Did you not notice that both Janeway and Picard (TNG) also whispered half their lines?

When I was in a hardcore watch everything in proper order phase, it was weird to see that both Janeway and Picard whispered half their lines and Sisko never did. (Hawk would not allow it)

-3
aitaeOP•

i just finished TNG last year after never seeing it before. Heavy voyager fan as well from years and years ago. I do not see what you are suggesting.

2
MikeyMGM•

I can hear her and I’m hearing impaired

-11
aitaeOP•

The comment wasn't about hearing her. It is about her whispering.

13
MikeyMGM•

When she’s whispering, I can hear her.

-12
aitaeOP•

The comment wasn't about hearing her. It's about her whispering.

12
[deleted]•

Great job!

6