r/Superstonk•
jeffxt

The Jon Stewart interview with the WSJ editor, Spencer Jakab, was infuriating but also enlightening, let me explain why-

🗣 Discussion / Question

First off, if you've been away eating crayons for the last week, please go check out the Jon Stewart podcast for context.

Now that's out of the way, I wanted to share some thoughts that I had.

The entire episode was one giant back and forth between Jon and Spencer. Each argued their own points, and even agreed on about a few things (albeit maybe at surface level), but what I found interesting is that they came to wildly different conclusions. Now, for those of you who actually listened to the episode (seriously, go listen to it, it's worth your time), you might be thinking "this guy's a shill". I'm honestly not sure - that's why I say go listen to the episode, inform yourself, and come to your own conclusions.

Either way, the TA;DR is that Jon was clearly advocating for retail investors vs. Spencer whose argument could be summed up as "yes, I know the market is like a casino, yes the market is not acting in the best interests of the retail invest, I think those who invested in meme stocks are going to get hurt, but there's one tiny part of the market which you can invest in, which is investing in index funds and ETFs". When Jon pressed him on how our markets can be improved to increase transparency, reduce complexity, and generate overall fairer opportunities for retail investors, he seemed to glaze over that some "guardrails" that could be put into place (what does that even mean?) -- and not even on institutions but rather on retail investors (??) Furthermore, he didn't even specify any clear vision of how that could be done...

Honestly, I disagreed with nearly all of his points - that's just my personal opinion. And not even because he could be considered a shill, but because I sensed a sort of defeatist mentality in his narrative. His point was that retail investors should "opt-out" knowing they will get screwed over (literally his words). Instead, they should take the wins where they can, like investing in index funds and ETFs to build a nest egg to ensure their financial futures. Need I need to remind anyone what is happening with ETFs containing GME?

But then it got me thinking: I've definitely heard people in my own personal circles, who are equally as educated as this guy, who have even worked in or alongside the financial industry equally as long, and have said the same types of things.

So what I learned from this episode is that this is the type of narrative we will continue to hear, from shills or otherwise. I think we all can learn a thing or two from Jon, who does a great job countering points while simultaneously continuing to push back, all the while doing it respectfully - and I think that's the key. If we are able to clearly articulate our points, stick to the facts, meanwhile stay laser focused on the problem to prevent the conversation from even remotely deviating away from it, then THAT is how we keep the conversation going. Honestly, after listening to Jon speak, it's kind of inspired me to rethink how I even engage with others in my personal life about GME / MOASS / all the fuckery that's been happening in the financial markets.

But all that being said, at the end of the day, this is just one interview. We've also had so much happen in the last year, and it's great to have yet ANOTHER powerful voice on the side of retail. Let's take a second to remember all of the other people like Wes Christian, Susanne Trimbath, Daddy RC, Dave Lauer, and so many others who have dedicated their entire careers (and even their lives!) pushing for change. Once I remind myself that -- because let's be honest, sometimes we need that to remind ourselves -- it helps confirm that we are on the right track.

But hey, what do I know? This is obviously not financial advice, and I'm as smooth as the 16 lb ball at your local bowling alley.

Anyways, I'll get off my soapbox now.

Stay safe everyone, have a great weekend, drink some water, live your life, jack yo tits (responsibly), and of course: BUY, HODL, DRS. See you on the other side 🚀🚀🚀

EDIT: Some apes pointed out he's the author of "The Revolution That Wasn't: GameStop, Reddit, and the Fleecing of Small Investors" (not posting a link, don't want to give him any visibility, you can Google it if you want). I'll just say this: if anyone stands to gain off of something else, like GME, they should be taken with a grain of salt *insert Fry squinting meme*. All I can say is grow a wrinkle and come to your own conclusions, but as for me (I like the stock) am skeptical of this guy...

Posted Mar 11, 2022, 10:43 PM UTC · edited

15926
iwasneverhere43•

Fuck the "nest egg" approach. I'm holding for the entire forest with every nest and every egg.

30
SoreLoserOfDumbtownMy flair is sPEshhhAaaLL🍋•

Anyone that promotes ETFs is a shill or clueless in my book. Derivatives are not designed to benefit retail.

20
gorilla_gambler•

For a financial journalist who only invests in Index Funds & ETFs seems he doesnt believe in what he preaches (financial journalism)

he came to me as a clueless / ignorant professional that seems to not want to understand whats really going on or is being paid off to not understand the situation and push others to look away from the actual situation with a narrative distraction. (apes chasing ghost & MOASS expectations willonly hurt us- we need to be saved)

A stock that can be possibly shorted 140% or more and that same stock and also others (🍿) being possibly overbrought by retail exceeding the actual float seems to be the real issue here..

the lack of transparency that makes these transactions possible is tge real issue

Him saying the markets are corrupt and it be best if we just stay out of it (seems shill) why not write about how corrupt the market is…

Jon owned him throughout the entire conversation and at the end Jon saying “thats the wrong way to look” gave me a sense Jon reads between the lines of that guy

I just felt he was pushing his shitty book trying to profit off from gamestop saga as well

might as well put a shitty review and hope Jon doesnt give him any more platform cause honestly,

hes a nobody

20
ErnestMorrow🚀🚀🚀 not-a-cat 🚀🚀🚀•

He's worse than a nobody though- he's the author of the book "The Revolution that Wasn't" about the whole gamestop phenomenon

And obviously I don't think that book would sway anybody who's been really dialed into this, but it gets used as a cudgel by the shorts, and it could work on someone out of the know. You have to be deep in the real information to be immune to that kind of FUD. My banker uncle who I've been having an ongoing discussion/debate about gme referenced this book when it came out(hadnt read it).

But even still being able to point to a book that says "nope didn't work its over", that got Published with a capital P. It holds more weight than bullshit fOrGeT gAmEsToP articles and it's absolute swill- I've had the misfortune of skimming it, but a book will reach people an internet forum can't.

So in short, this guy is not nobody because he's actively wrong and spreading his interpretation of events.

I think Jon Stewart did a wonderful job in his interview with Spencer.

9
demoncasehedgies r fuk•

Hanlon's razor?

How possible someone can be more retarded than us?

3
jeffxtOP🦍 You mess with the stonk, you get the bedpost 🛏️•

It's like the Kasaun, one of the writers, who mentioned in the last 5 minutes of the podcast that the discussion tends to focus on the "how vs. the why" (paraphrasing). I think it's true - while it is important to talk about the complexity and nuances of the markets, at the end of the day, it can also be used to distract the conversation from asking "why" to understand the root cause as to why all of this is happening in the first place.

1
Mountainmama814🎮 Power to the Players 🛑•

Anyone else tired of being referred to as inferior, naive, uneducated, clueless and unworthy of entering the stock market? This guy really got under my skin.

18
ipackandcoverWet Blanket Ape•

We gotta DRS harder to get under their skin

3
JohnnyMagicTOG🗳️ VOTED ✅•

The WSJ didn't believe that mortgages would go bellyup in 2008 either, so it doesn't matter what they think. They speak to the interests of Wall Street, not Retail.

9
demoncasehedgies r fuk•

He is a shill. Fuck him. Why I'm that angry? Because look, we don't have access to even 1% of the tools Wall Street has and how the fuck we need regulation? This shit happened ONCE, how many times Wall Street got bailed? Remember 2008?

This makes my blood boil. Maybe it's time to revisit all of his articles and search for coordinated short and distort and send to the DOJ.

Edit: look at the name of the latest book from him, The Revolution That Wasn't: GameStop, Reddit, and the Fleecing of Small Investors.

MF is a journalist and didn't even bother to do a research, smh, I think I don't even need to go deep on him, the DOJ will LOVE that book lmaoooo

6
funkinthetrunk•

a journalist who throws up his hands at corruption and would rather that regular people just learn to live with it

4
demoncasehedgies r fuk•

This is outrageous! I have an advertising and marketing degree but the first two years, we did class together with Journalism, a lot of moral and ethics too.

99% of the journalists who cover wall street are morally corrupt, this is INSANE.

I learned that good journalism isn't about making good stories, it's about showing the problem and demanding change (Thanks Jon). Journalism is a tool of the people.

Power to the people.

3
funkinthetrunk•

yeah it makes me totally mistrust WSJ. My mentor in J school was a WSJ reporter in the 70s and 80s and he expressed great disappointment in the quality of the paper around 2010. He did serious undercover reporting and narrative writing for the them, producing content that he considers art.

He called WSJ "a shell of its former self"

2
demoncasehedgies r fuk•

He did serious undercover reporting

I miss those times...

2
UnderstandingEvery44🦍 Buckle Up 🚀•

What most people fail to understand (or choose to ignore) is that GameStop is not a meme.

4
blizzardflip🎮 Power to the Players 🛑•

It seemed clear to me that he was their purely in a shill role. He was gunning hard for his narrative, constantly trying to frame it/reframe it, and his whole thesis was this paternalistic and supposed concern for retail investors. It all came across as disingenuous. You can tell he doesn’t respect retail investors and doesn’t give two shits about us so this supposed concern was ridiculous. His lack of respect for retail bled through as he got whiny and finger pointy about how some of the folks on Reddit are conspiracy theorists etc. He was clearly there to run w the corp media narrative around “gamification” which was the tight script all networks/publications stuck to around the Jan sneeze and following (the congressional hearings too). Bullshit waste of oxygen.

3
DisgruntledPOG💻 ComputerShared 🦍•

Just buy indexes or just quit. Like wtf are you seriously hearing yourself speak. I’m glad Jon wasn’t letting him get away with his bullshit.

2
JackBauerWSB🍦💩🚽100% DRS🍦💩🚽•

Dude sounded like he hung out with Cramer beforehand.

2
Superstonk_QVMOD📊 Gimme Votes 📊•

IMPORTANT POST LINKS

What is GME and why should you consider investing? || What is DRS and why should you care? || [Low karma but still want to feed the DRS bot? Post on r/gmeorphans here](https://www.reddit.com/r/GMEOrphans/comments/qlvour/welcome_to_gmeorphans_read_this_post/) ||


Please help us determine if this post deserves a place on r/Superstonk. Learn more about this bot and why we are using it here

If this post deserves a place on r/Superstonk, UPVOTE this comment!!

If this post should not be here or or is a repost, DOWNVOTE This comment!

1
tewdahmewn100% FOR LIFE 🟣•

Jon is an absolute champion 🏆 Always has been 💎 Much love to Jon 🦍♥️🐒

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
kahareddit🚀🚀Anymore bullish and I’d be fuckin cows 🚀🚀•

There were so many times when I wanted chat enabled so I could cut that asshole down when he tries to defend wallstreet and apes fucking “conspiracy theories”.

But john really did the apes right during this interview in the most forward, comedic, and eloquent way possible.

Jon Stewart fucks

1
buzzvariety💻 ComputerShared 🦍•

Definitely agree with you that Jon demonstrated a great way of debating respectfully. He offered common ground without conceding any of his own.

In my mind, Jakab was s perfect representation of why this fuckery has gone on so long. Basically, he knows there's corruption but is placated by relatively meager gains.

And that's it right there. As long as people can make some money, they're afraid to take on systemic corruption. Maybe out of some fear that doing so will destroy it all. Probably not a surprise to this crowd, but I believe the fear he displayed is a symptom of the same short-term thinking that created this mess.

1
jeffxtOP🦍 You mess with the stonk, you get the bedpost 🛏️•

Well said - I think if people see that they're making some money, even if in the back of their heads they know that the system is corrupt, they're more willing to look the other way. Because when faced with two choices: face systemic corruption or take your "small wins" and go, most people will take the easier path.

2
ammoprofit•

The guest, Spencer, was arguing, "Follow the money." He did it in a roundabout an inarticulate way, but that's the crux of the argument.

The guard rails argument is along the same lines. We are the dumb money. It's rare for retail to get it right. 90/90/90 says 90% of Retail Investors will lose 90% of their money in 90 days. It's such a sure bet, our own brokers will take the opposite side of any trade we make because it's money in the bank. If you win 90% of the time at anything and manage your risk so you don't blow up on the 10% when you lose, you make money hand over fist.

Like it or not, the vast majority of retail is getting fleeced because they refuse to learn. They refuse to look at what worked, what works, and what will work, and Spencer is arguing to protect retail investors from themselves.

Jon agrees with Spencer on the point, but argues it from a different take. "Fix the market, and you won't need the guard rails, and it'll clean up the market." I absolutely support Jon, but Jon's approach is naive, because greed always wins. It's not an actual 100% always, but definitely the vast majority most of the time, and definitely as long as people aren't paying attention and making a fuss.

I hope Jon's argument wins, and I hope we get some real fixes, but greed is going to continue to happen.

I don't know what the next round of investmentor philosophies will be, but there will either be a shake up or a shake down in the near future, and I don't mean the GME Squeeze.

There are three avenues for wealth growth right now - generational wealth (people die and pass on wealth), the stock market (only thing outpacing inflation, before it broke 7%), and e-curriencies (highly volatile, but solid growth). That's it. Most people can't purchase homes. Most savings accounts' interest rates don't even come close to matching inflation. Actual bond yields are negative (accounting for inflation).

Shit is fucked.

1
ammoprofit•

But let's take the 90/90/90 rule a step further for GME's past runup that the SEC made clear wasn't a squeeze.

If 90% of Retail Investors lose 90% of their money in 90 days, then it's as sure a bet as it gets to take the other side of the deal.

Which means, fucking every single goddamned broker was short GME.

Every. single. fucking. broker. was short GME.

Or at least 90% of them, yeah?

I love this shit.

1