Meta-complaining about the criticism regarding boss quality and reuse
I truly don't understand the rose-tinted logic that some players have regarding change. While i can agree with the arguments that slapping one plus two plus three of the same enemy can come across as lazy, the "repeats" of bosses in the overworld are not actually bosses, they're miniboss/elite enemies that players are meant to kill quicker than when you first faced them. Is that not the point of a classic rpg? To grow stronger so the difficult enemies become not so difficult?
It boggles my mind when people on this sub see crucible knight with a boss healthbar once at level 15, and think the various other times they see him in the overworld constitutes as a "lazy reskin", regardless of the actual lore and design choice associated with it.
I think this game requires a change in mindset regarding boss design that a considerable number of souls veterans (disclaimer: I played through every soul game.) refuse to engage in. There is this unfounded belief that a boss necessarily needs to be unique every single time you face one, that every boss a player faces must rise to the same level of quality. The 'victory' messages you get at the end of each major encounter prove this wrong: 'enemy felled' 'great enemy felled' 'legend felled' etc. There is a hierarchy that exists.
Some fights just aren't meant to be at the level of diverseness and quality you expect from a main boss. Especially in miscallenous dungeons, that's absolutely fine imo. They're just tidbits of fun/challenge you are meant to not think too much in.
Now regarding the actual quality of main bosses like malenia, i sympathize, but i realize that this analysis is entirely subjective. In the heat of the moment, you may think the three piece waterfowl combo is bullshit, but the fact is that there are already several writeups online explaining the "non-cheese" strat to many of the combos players deem unfair.
If you are getting two shot by enemies, check your damage reduction, are you equipping sore/scarseals that are increasing damage taken while you're at soft cap for vigor? Are you playing a glass cannon mage character with robes on? Are you getting hit by the highly telegraphed one shot attacks that are meant to do a lot of damage?
it's a skill problem /s
In all seriousness, people compare the boss reuse in this game to games like dks2, when it should be compared to games like breath of the wild, where enemy variety is equally lacking, but people still view that game favorably. Because...well...it's not a "souls" game.
Posted Mar 13, 2022, 4:37 PM UTC
I think a lot of people don't understand the amount of development time that goes into creating an entirely novel boss for a AAA title. Sure it would be nice to have all completely different bosses but with the size of the worlds that people want / expect, it just isn't feasible.
Other very successful games are much more guilty of it. God of War 3 is one of my favourite games ever but with about 6 exceptions, every boss is a troll.
See, I would *much* rather have a smaller world with more unique bosses. Quality over quantity, regardless of genre.
I do think that if From really wanted to, they could easily cut every single "not unique" iteration of a previous boss from the game and there would still be an insane variety. The argument that From choosing an open world instead of a linear experience is what pushed them to re use bosses/minibosses is a valid one, but I think it still works to the betterment of the game. The variety in enemies is still very much present throughout the whole experience.
I agree that they could but I thinks it's nice to have more mini dungeons with a boss at the end. Who cares if it's another version of troll or a burial watchdog.
It’s okay for Elden Ring to reuse a LOT of stuff because it’s… hard work and a decade-old game did it?
Maybe they should have realized their limitations and/or not charged $60 for this.