Looking for 5 player PC games (non PvP)

Hello! A small group I play with is looking for a multiplayer game that suits 5 players. One of the people in the group prefers non-fps, however everyone else in the group likes them, so suggestions in that area are okay as long as they are the type where FPS skill of the 5th player doesn't matter (or is perhaps a supportive role).

Other than that we are open to exploring other types of games, and generally are fans of co-op. It's challenging because a lot of the games we want to play are limited to 4 players.

Appreciate any suggestions you can offer!