Imagine getting a PhD in engineering to make $40k.

Posted Mar 14, 2022, 4:47 PM UTC

Posted Mar 14, 2022, 4:47 PM UTC
That has sadly been the case for postdoctoral jobs for years now
I thought it might be the case for PhD’s in arts (like sociology or anthropology), but why would someone take this job over making 3x more as a regular employee at an energy corporation. That’s what confuses me… candidates with this skill set can probably work for Tesla or any industry working on energy storage.
It’s getting competitive to get those jobs, and if you truly have your heart set on academia, you kinda have to prove that your definition of passionate means “working for practically nothing”
Seems like it sets up a situation where only the privileged can afford to work in academia.
Well, now you’re getting the picture. It’s been a valid criticism for years.
Yeah, go work in the private sector with a company that's very R&D intensive (Corning's Sullivan Park location for example). Academia is a cess pool of sexual harassment and favoritism.
What? Biological Anthropologist here. I have an undergrade degree and started at 60k... I have been say this for years. The Stem programs have been pushed to such high enrollments that even UC Berkely had to create a 2nd program as an overfill. There are so many people with these degrees now its a dime a dozen. It was inevitable pay would drop and will continue to drop in the next few years.
This is pretty standard sadly.
Go into STEM they said
This is what happens when fucking everyone does that
This is a postdoc position. It pays poorly because it’s in academia, not because it’s in STEM. People generally do this if they’re insanely smart and want to be professors.
Anybody applying to this position could also easily pull six figures in industry.
Just because these are pretty typical doesn't mean that they should be accepted!
I don’t understand who applies to these jobs. $40k salary for 40 hours a week, managerial duties, a lot of experience and published papers required, so an energy company can profit off your research.
You’d be lucky to work 40 hr/week. Postdoc is the new grad school.
What is the end goal though? Aren’t the requirements for this post enough to get a job that pays a living wage?
If you want to work in academia, living like this is a forgone conclusion. Hence the “managing students” part of the job description. This is training for being a professor
[deleted]
The old grad school to postdoc to professor trap. I spent two years teaching undergraduate organic and biochem, paid $50,000 a year, but had to pay for my own software and supplies. Work in industry now for the same pay I might have gotten after 20 years teaching.
A professor mentioned this in my class and had us all shook. In engineering you can over qualify yourself with a PHD. Hence why on big bang theory dude just has a masters. Essentially you get so specialized you get put in a niche or you know more then your boss/person hiring you. It's dumb. Happens in physics and math degrees too. Only thing left is to teach at that point. One dude had a PHD in physics and was getting 100's on all the tests in a class where the averages are like 30. When asked why he is taking the engineering class when he should be teaching it he said "I have to feed my family"
How would that encourage people to pursue S.T.E.M fields when the salary isn’t worth the effort
This isn't indicative of private sector salaries. They would likely pay 2.5-3x as much for a doctorate of engineering depending on the specific field. Source: I'm an opto-mechanical engineer with bachelor's and 7 yrs experience and i make ~90k USD.
So all private sectors pay handsomely or just the one you’re in
Well, most (if not all) STEM fields pay well which was what I was commenting on. There are other fields where academia and the private sector pay equally shitty salaries.
No this is a particularly bad example of what educational pay can be like at the university level, stem or not. I made $35k as an engineering undergrad during a summer internship, the $40k listed in the post is awful.
Private/public government work is entirely different, wages and work life balance tend to be much better.
[deleted]
Well if a phd fellow is dumb enough to work at a university with a phd in engineering or chemistry, their phd is probably fake. The real phds are making high 6 figures in oil and gas.
Universities are terrible with this sort of thing. They think because they’re a university that alumni and others should be beating down the door to get their underpaid jobs. It used to be that the poor salary was offset by great benefits and a pension, but those days are gone.