Troy and Skid and a lowkey moment of brilliance on the last episode of Dune

I'm talking about the moment where Skid is temporarily at a loss at what do with Aurelius's action, and Troy suggests having Aurelius call for a duel. Nice moment, kept the story moving.

But! If you've been game mastering for sometime you'll recognize that this is a classic conundrum that's not so easily solved.

Sometimes a player feels boxed in and and needs some kind of out. The session starts to grind to a halt, and bad vibes creep into the table. It the end of the day, it's up to the game master to find a solution. It's your game after all.

What that player doesn't want is for something that ruins the fiction. They don't want to twist their skills into knots and do some loony toons shit, and they definitly don't want you to fudge numbers behind the scenes so that their character is suddenly competent at something their not.

It's a hard problem! Even when I have all the time in the world it's hard to come up with a solution that 1. Preserves the tension 2. Stays true the players character 3. Doesn't break our suspension of disbelief.

That's why I'm impressed that Troy was able to hand Skid a viable out on air. I've seen this happen a few time before on GCN shows, and this is the first time the game master has reacted so decisively and successfully.

Great stuff and all the game masters in the audience should be taking notes.

Posted Mar 14, 2022, 11:31 PM UTC · edited

676
Naturaloneder•

While I agree with you personally, In my experience it depends on the player. Some people have no problem with the hand of god coming down and punching the enemy, or the enemy suddenly start rolling very badly.

Some people just want to find loot, kill monsters and not really be in any real danger of dying or losing their beloved character.

What I usually do is in session 0 is find out what each players expectations of the game is, then either try to accommodate each person's play-style or recommend a different group.

For example, some players would be having a blast in the local town trying to flirt with everything, stealing things off the rack in-front of them, helping the farmer find his favorite pig, where other players will be groaning and bored, wanting to go and do something significant or challenging.

3
Dovahkiin•

Absolutely. Brilliant moment, nice catch. Stuff like this slips my mind sometimes as I usually listen while doing other things. Cool to see the retrospective type discussions about these shows.

3
Percinho:Lorc: Desk Ranger•

Also, I like the way Skid played into his character and had him offer to take part in the dual as well. I think he struggled a bit with how to fit his character into the twists and turns that the arc took, but that was a particularly good character moment.

3
smirk_lives•

Agreed. I don’t know if it was the new system, the character, or the situations, but Skid really seemed to struggle with Aurelius in a way I don’t think I’ve heard from him before. No issue with it, he was essentially playing like Joe and I love Joe.

I hope Skid takes up the offer to roll a new character for the second half of the show.

2
CSerpentine•

he was essentially playing like Joe and I love Joe

He shouldn't have gone so far as to start rolling like Joe, though.

Skid has been leaning into elderly, combatively ineffectual characters lately, between this and DG. I approve of that, mind, especially in these heavier role play games. There had to be a mentat. But it has to be frustrating when it culminates in a boss battle.

1
HappyCamper82•

Is this where Elon Musk got the idea too?

1