This sub is smart and Knowledgeable. Please ELI5 if buying assets on Secondary markets meaningfully supports the underlying Issuer.

Discussion

It's too late for me to unwind.

I am so exposed I can't trust myself to think impartially.

Some will return "guity," some "not guilty," others "not guilty but still despicable. And annoying."

This is a mindblow for me... my reasoning is inconsistent yet I can't identify the error.

Premise A:. Disapprobation of certain vices disinclines me from considering their inclusion as investment candidates. Mainly war and private prison stocks feel dirty. No judgement on others belief systems.

Premise B: Buying and holding stocks of unpopular, boycotted companies on the secondary market does not support or benefit that company directly.

Premise C: However, buying (or failure to divest) the shares may indirectly communicate my vote for the company's investability, thereby encouraging potential creditors to provide new imvestment. Additionally, those who owned the shares in the bad company are enriched more whem selling due to those investors who held or bought the bad shares.

Premise 4: If new investments and share trading is halted, Premise 3 is rendered moot.

True or False: While tacky, low-class and perhaps self-injurious... there is no harm caused or support given by the self-centered purchase and ownership of boycotted Russian companies.

Posted Mar 15, 2022, 2:57 AM UTC

17
rsmartin1857•

Depends on what constitutes meaningful support in your mind. I don’t support certain companies or practices as a consumer, but most of my money is in index funds that include companies that I wouldn’t want to work for or support with my spending. Maybe that’s hypocritical, or maybe it’s the price you pay for wanting to be able to retire before your 90th birthday. Maybe investing in Russia in the immediate term is an attempt at war profiteering, or maybe it’s a play that implicitly assumes there will be a peaceful resolution.

At the end of the day, the only real metric on this is whether you can live with your own choices.

3
xL_monkey•

What if you bought the whole thing?

2
CapitalExploitOP•

Well... I guess I'm a hypocrite then. This is hard to unpack.

Now I'm questioning whether it is ethical to invest in most companies... The EU seems to treat workers with dignity.

I have a feeling Marx probably wrote something insightful on alienation from ethical consciousness through dilution of ownership...

Dang that is such a good question!

It was easy to condemn capitalism when I had nothing. I wonder if I somehow accounted for and balanced out any debits on responsibility to not harm by creditong myself for hard efforts expended.

This raises in me an unconvincing economic fallacy: that profit and consumption presuppose working success, which presupposes contribution to the whole, which then justifies profit and consumption, ad infinitum.

Is that supply side economics?

0
DoubleAtLeast•

It really sounds like investment is not gonna be your thing

6
JoshAGould•

True or False: While tacky, low-class and perhaps self-injurious... there is no harm caused or support given by the self-centered purchase and ownership of boycotted Russian companies.

Not in the Russian case specifically but companies will often use their stock to colateralise debt, and as such lowering their stock price by selling or not buying can lead to them finding it harder / having to pay more to loan money.

2
CapitalExploitOP•

Wow! I think my broker trusts me way less with my stock choices- negative collateral.

Mel Brooks' The vodka Producers:

Bialystok: "You know, with the right tax planning, we could actually make more money buying back our shares for pennies than if they doubled!"

1
ddr2sodimm•

Level of linkage lies in how close you are to action on financial, moral, and physical levels.

Does paying taxes to your country at war support the war?

Does driving a gas car make you anti-environment.

It’s probably best to interpret everything in sum as a net action rather than isolated small actions.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1