r/Colts•
Red_Stevens

[r/NFL X-Post] Baker Mayfield has been almost perfectly average since entering the NFL, with the exception of a below average completion percentage countered by an above-average yards per completion average. Here's Mayfield's stats vs. rest of NFL's passing stats on a per 1,818-attempt basis

Discussion
reddit.com/r/nfl/comments/rdb3kg/football_per...
reddit.com

Posted Mar 16, 2022, 3:28 AM UTC

5782
NoMoreMrQuickWayne Brady•

My wife would agree with me. Average is just fine.

64
[deleted]•

I’m sure if you look at Drew Brees with the Chargers, it’s very similar. Playing in a dome away from shitty Cleveland weather will bump up his stats

45
THATS_MAD_SUSHorse•

Factor in our shitty receiving weapons, and he’s back to average

40
ryta1203•

Baker has also had shitty coaching. He's actually a good fit for Reich's schemes.

1
ManIWantANameMegaStrachan•

Oh shit your shoulder is fucked and you can't throw it more than 10 yards? Let's fuckin chuck it 60 times a game fam

2
My-Cousin-BobbyRookie Manning•

I believe Baker's non-throwing arm is the one injured/had surgery

Jimmy G's throwing arm is the one he had surgery on

2
[deleted]•

The Chargers had shitty WRs from 01-05

-11
THATS_MAD_SUSHorse•

Not sure what that has to do with Baker coming to Indy.

21
DRoseCantStopPascal•

Sigma was doing these Brees comparisons with Wentz last offseason too. Shit is weird.

17
[deleted]•

[removed]

32
[deleted]•

Brees was average with the Chargers.

-6†
[deleted]•

[removed]

16
[deleted]•

Watch the KTO video

-5
clutchthepearlsViva Felipe Rios•

I mean he was a Pro Bowler and Comeback Player of the Year one season and then the next he had Top 10 stats, so "average" is underselling it a bit. He started slow, but was definitely above average when his rookie contract was up. The Chargers franchise tagged him and then offered him a long term contract the next year, even with Rivers on the roster. He just chose a better deal in NO.

5
[deleted]•

The Chargers were not keeping him after the shoulder injury and burning top overall on rivers. Brees wasn’t anything special with the Chargers.

-1
minero-de-salJimmy from the Colts•

65% comp and 7.5 YPA his last two years with the Chargers. There were signs that he was good.

2
Red_StevensOPPeyton Manning•

and right into the brick hands of our shitty Indy receivers /s

Cleveland with Hunt/Chubb and Landry/OBJ is better than anything we could put together in a year, and even that wouldn’t be enough to elevate Baker above the other mid QBs. No way will he justify the cost in picks and cap.

0†
bvgingy•

Not to mention having a solid tight end room.

2
Lumpy_Isopod_6592MATTY ICE•

Baker COULD thrive under a new system in a dome, but unless he’s super cheap to trade for I don’t think he’s worth it.

14
stroopwaffle69•

Other than Carr, who would you prefer at this point in time

11
dragonz-99Frank Reich•

Right? We got nada. Zip. I’d take Matt Ryan tho too. Not over the other two

6
Lumpy_Isopod_6592MATTY ICE•

Jimmy G. He's a safer option than Baker, he fits our offense, is a great leader, and would fit well in our locker room. With the 49er's cap window closing he would also be cheap to trade for. He's also a winner. 2 NFC Championship visits and one to the superbowl. Sure, the 49ers had a great supporting cast around him, but he's shown that he can take you to where you want to go if you surround him with weapons.

1†
ryta1203•

Baker is younger with a better arm and more mobile. What Baker really needs is good coaching.

2
alexjsaf•

Winston

-1
dragonz-99Frank Reich•

Right? We got nada. Zip. I’d take Matt Ryan tho too. Not over the other too.

-3
ElFelipeRios•

I get why people want Baker because he's sadly probably the most exciting option, but man he's EERILY similar to Wentz last season if we get him. A QB who's current team decided he's not it and who specifically wants to go to the Colts to bounce back. His last year was awful but he has an injury excuse... Except even beyond his accuracy his decision-making and playstyle were extremely questionable. He has a great past year that people will look to as hope he can get back to that, even though his overall play for his career is very average.

For the right price (like a 3rd rounder) I would be okay with it but I might lose my mind if this sub gives Baker the same treatment Wentz got where he's anointed a hero before his first game or if we give up a lot for him

11
minero-de-salJimmy from the Colts•

Its even worse than Wentz in my opinion. Wentz had a lot more excuses for being bad (bad OL, bad receivers, unstable coaching) that sort of justified taking a shot with him. Baker has none of that. OBJ is going off to play for the guy we should have grabbed last year and suddenly he's a good receiver again. I'm all for taking risks on a guy who has the excuses but I think Baker is about as certain a mediocre QB as you can get.

9
jono9898I Love Sigma•

I was going to type exactly what you did but you saved me some time so I’ll piggy back off the OBJ situation. After OBJ left, a lot of players came out to support him which lead me to believe Baker is not liked around the league and It definitely didn’t help that OBJ is loved by alot of players. If we get Baker, why would FA WRs want to play for a guy who killed OBJ, the most electrifying guy who was putting up numbers comparable to Moss his first few years and Landry who was incredibly productive his first few years?

2
RestoredX123Rookie Manning•

This is what I’m seeing as well. Pretty much the same story of Wentz in a lot of ways. Clamoring for the return of a flash in the pan season. Playing through injury. Surrounded by a bad organization. Average completion percentage. Super aggressive but has accuracy issues.

1
Brian_lafeve34•

Baker had Odell, Jarvis, Njoku, Chubb, Hunt, best O line in the league, and still looked horrifying. He was insanely accurate in college but that seems to have left him in the NFL. Would much rather sign Mariota or Jameis than give up assets for Baker

7
[deleted]•

“Horrifying” sure pal

2†
Brian_lafeve34•

Baker was an absolute disaster this past season. He was injured, so who knows how much that had to do with it. But to say he was anything more than God awful last season is lying

2
[deleted]•

He had a torn labrum from October onward. Idk what else you want me to say.

2
Brian_lafeve34•

His stats in his career year are pretty much identical to Wentz last year. When he was healthy he was middle of the road to mediocre, and last year he wasn't healthy. He has never played anywhere close to top 10 in the league level. At that point I'd rather pay pennies for a free agent and draft someone than pay capital to someone who's proven to be average at best and injury prone

4
ryta1203•

So a bunch of headcases?

Mariota and Jameis both SUCK. They both have had plenty of 2nd chances and both have been unable to win a starting job.

1
Hot-Cry920•

Baker had tremendous talents around him and still sucks 🤷🏻‍♂️

5
ryta1203•

What tremendous talents?

1
BeckerLoR•

He’s perfect.

5
Vivalaraza90•

It’s a bad move for us for anything more than 2nd/3rd round picks. Even then the upside is limited.

In the NFL you need to keep buying into the raffle for a top 5-10 QB. You will never win without one.

4 years in we know Mayfield is not that. Will just be wasting time with him.

3
RushTheStands•

It’s a bad move.

1
ryta1203•

I would definitely try him out for a 2nd and a 5th. Look, most draft picks are gambles anyways, the draft is basically the lottery. At least you know what you might be getting with Baker and if he doesn't pan out as the starter, restructure and move him to back up.

1
gangjoinsredditThe Maniac•

Exactly. I lived with a roommate who was an obsessive Brown's fan, so we usually had the Colts and Brown's games on side by side TVs... Baker is a marginal upgrade from Wentz? Maybe. He's certainly just as volatile and unpredictable. Anyone trying to convince themselves that Baker is a good deal for us is kidding themselves.

2
ryta1203•

He's likable at least and has heart. That's more than I can say for Wentz and basically the rest of the leftover QBs the Colts may or may not be trying to pick through.

At this point, I'm just looking for a reason, any reason at QB, to give a shit this season. We've been irrelevant for a LONG time now.

1
CuriousCucumber88:colts: Indianapolis Colts•

And he was average with one of the best olines and running games in the league

2
SportsRadioAnnouncerKenny Moore II•

So basically he’s the same QB as Mahomes, right?

1
jono9898I Love Sigma•

I’ll point out that these numbers aren’t accurate, Baker has 14125, 92 tds and 56 picks, 61% completion percentage, so yes still mediocre numbers except his interception numbers which actually are above average, so he’s good at that at least.

1
ryta1203•

He's also played on the Browns with shitty coaching.

1
ndhl83•

I'll take average...who doesn't try to play hero ball...with the run game we have right now. Sign me up.

1
teh_drewski•

They have have a day 3 pick for him, same as Jimmy G

0
jbvann05WE GOT A QUARTERBACK•

Average is much better than Carson Wentz

0†
Khend81Jonathan Taylor•

Not according to any relevant statistic lmao

8
jbvann05WE GOT A QUARTERBACK•

Statistics =/= Reality

1
Khend81Jonathan Taylor•

Even in reality he’s at bare minimum average man. You’re just still salty about the way the season ended and that’s fine but it doesn’t excuse saying ignorant shit lol

1
jbvann05WE GOT A QUARTERBACK•

The team itself would've kicked out Wentz even if we made the playoffs. They didn't like his attitude and his lack of leadership skills. While Wentz and Mayfield may be similar statistically, there's more to a QB than stats

1
minero-de-salJimmy from the Colts•

Poor decision making. Can't go through his progressions. Wentz 2.0

1
Red_StevensOPPeyton Manning•

This is who we’re willing to ditch a first round pick over? Seriously?

-7†
Indy4LifeFuckRyanGrigson•

Who said a first round pick?

12
Red_StevensOPPeyton Manning•

people on this sub. I.e, the guy who replied a second after you

1†
ryta1203•

No way we give a 1st rounder, but even if we did, whatever. mid to late 1st round picks are mostly crap shoots anyways.

1
RatherBLucky487•

Yes

0†