Shelvey yellow vs Allan red
streamja.com/9EzQ3Posted Mar 17, 2022, 11:12 PM UTC
Posted Mar 17, 2022, 11:12 PM UTC
Don’t think its a red honestly, what Lampard said really hits the nail on the head. The ref saw it, clear view, gave the yellow. The ref has the final decision and gave the yellow.
A fucking 2 footed challenge vs a missed time challenge. Guess who got red. Fuck u Ref and fuck you VAR.
Allan’s was not mistimed. He knew exactly what he was doing. Not a red though.
Definitely not mistimed. Took one for the team. I've no problem with it being red, but agree that Shelvey's was probably red too.
I have a problem we went to VAR for that, and then it was removed and given as a red.
The voldemort tackle wasn't even reviewed as it was clearly a yellow, no? Bullshit
I just don't want us buying into any conspiracy theories. I can go with 'incompetence' and feel hard done by. I don't like when it goes further than that.
The people making the VAR decisions have a huge consistency problem, but they're human and fallible. I'm far less angry about last night's decision than I was about the handball against City.
Yeah he tends to do that immediately after we don't get a call just so he can stop play and yell at the ref haha
[removed]
It happened right in front of the referee, he gives a yellow card. Then it goes to VAR. They can’t decide, so they tell the red to look at the monitor, which is what gets me.
See, I thought the criteria for overturning a call on the field was if it was a clear and obvious error. If the VAR booth can’t decide, then how can that be considered clear or obvious? It’s one thing if the ref wasn’t in a good position to see it, but he was right there.
I wouldn’t have a problem if those type of tackles were regularly given red cards, but that’s not the case, at least not in the PL. I would even be less angry if he’d immediately given a red card. But I can’t imagine what he saw on the monitor that he didn’t see on the field that made him change his mind.
I see the same problem with NFL instant replay. "incontrovertible visual evidence" (to overturn the call) is the wording there, but same logic. when they spend too much time reviewing, it feels like they're looking for excuses to make a non-obvious call, and invites accusations of league bias.
VAR don't tell the ref to go to the screen if they can't decide btw. If the VAR ref thinks the on field ref has made an incorrect decision they can't just over rule them, they have to tell them to go to the monitor and change the decision if they agree. End of the day every decision that's made is the choice of the on field ref. The fact that the VAR ref thought this was an obvious red that the on field ref has missed is what I disagree with, its an orange card in my opinion.
That’s fair, and I might be wrong about the whole process. Still, I think it’s pretty laughable to call that clear and obvious. The referee was right there, he saw everything, he should have stood by his initial decision.
Exactly right. The ref didn't 'miss' anything. He also had the benefit of making his decision based off context and seeing it in real-time. When he first gave the yellow, I thought "maybe got away with that a bit", and would have no problem with Newcastle fans feeling salty over it.
Fucking incompetent cunts, PL refs are a fucking joke. Stealing a living
Gordon’s lucky to get up after that shit
I don't know the rules here regarding changing a yellow to a red via VAR, but if we can we must appeal it.
As Frank said, apologies mean nothing after the fact and these things are happening far too often against us.
both felt orange (hard yellow / soft red), so the inconsistency is what gets me
Has VAR gotten anything right for us recently?
When we should have had a penalty against Man City for a blatant handball, VAR decides to pretend to be blindfolded. When we challenge for a tackle where no studs are shown our player is red carded.
These are big points for us, yet they continually disappoint us. Very frustrating.
Honestly feels like they've been bribed to not give us calls/call against us
Don't forget the penalty we should've had in the first half for a handball against Southampton the week before.
Nope
There was one where Godfrey was going to be sent off because he appeared to have stepped on a guy’s face, I think maybe Tottenham (at home, not last week), the referee looked and didn’t give a red. Don’t know if that was right, but it’s the last one I remember going our way.