I need a sanity check.

UPDATE: OK, the question has been answered, thanks to those that responded.

I'm in the middle of a minor disagreement. I'm kinda doubting myself as I seem to be outnumbered, but I can't see where I'm wrong. If I am wrong, I want to know it, so somebody please show me where I'm mistaken.

Somebody posted a picture of Sagan with a quote on it. I, trying to be a fair skeptic, type the quote into google just to confirm it. I find the quote, but according to almost every page listed, it's attributed to Hitler rather than Sagan.

Even now I don't assume that this is correct, so I ask in the thread for a source, and point out that google disagrees with OP's claim, and I get downvoted for my skepticism while those praising the quote are being supported.

Now I don't mind the downvotes, but it's bothering the hell out of me that I could be the one who's wrong here and maybe I just can't see it. Is my google-fu weak? Was this a joke that should have been so obvious that I'm I just being downvoted for being thick-headed (this was my thought as I made the first edit, but then I was scolded for it)? Or are there just not enough skeptics in r/atheism?

This is the the post. Sorry to dig up a post from a few hours ago, but it's gotten a bit stale and it didn't seem like it was going to get any more readers to possibly answer my question.

TL;DR: I need help to find the error in a disagreement and/or an explanation if I'm the one who's wrong.

Posted May 10, 2012, 6:59 PM UTC · edited

6515
Loading comments…