r/HomePod•
Aofwa

I'm baffled by how bad my music experience is

Question/Support

I've been part of the Apple ecosystem for a while and I'm quite baffled by how bad the user experience is for this product, specifically when listening to music.

I primarily listen to music synced across all homepod minis and the music CONSTANTLY cuts in and out on some devices, sometimes songs just randomly stop playing. And then when I try to fix it by tapping my homepod button I accidentally start playing U2. WTF????

Does anyone know how to resolve this or what the best setup is for listening to music?

I had almost no issues with the Google Nest speakers at a fraction of the price.

The only positives I can think of are that the Siri voice is nicer and provides slightly more fluid conversation, and the audio quality is better.

Can someone please give me some hope before I go through all the effort of returning these?

Posted Mar 18, 2022, 5:25 PM UTC

021
Yuri_Ligotme•

The problem is probably your wifi

6
ToddBradley•

This is very possible. I had a bunch of problems with my HomeKit devices and music, then got a much better wifi router, and now music is rock solid. My home devices are still a little flaky, but only about 1/20 of how flaky they were before.

1
AofwaOP•

How so? I just ran a speed test (not that this is necessarily relevant to the issue)

196 Mpbs down, 100 Mbps up

-1
aaronbenyamin:homepod_spacegray: Space Gray•

doesn’t matter if you have 1 gig wi-fi, if there are dead spots airplay issues will occur

3
AofwaOP•

I live in a 900 sqft apartment and my speakers are in the same room as my router maybe 10-20 feet away.

This wasn't an issue with Google Nest speakers that were in the same configuration

1
aaronbenyamin:homepod_spacegray: Space Gray•

damn sorry to hear that. it really is unfortunate. my experience has been nothing short of stellar. i’m sure you’ve tried but i’m assuming you’ve already done a restart on the devices

6
furruck•

This is an issue with your WiFi router

If you’re using the router provided by your ISP, get a good one.

Anytime I used a router provided by AT&T or Comcast, I’d have issues.

4
AofwaOP•

Does anyone know exactly what the issue is with the Wifi router?

I don't otherwise have issues with my Wifi router. What constitutes a good WiFi router?

2
furruck•

They’re usually just bad with packet prioritization, which will affect AirPlay

Also try changing your WiFi channels manually; a lot of times they’ll pick crowded channels that cause packet loss, and airplay will be sensitive to that

3
AofwaOP•

I use Spotify, I wonder if that somehow makes a difference since I know them and Apple don't have a great business relationship.

1
AofwaOP•

The problem with Apple Music is that the currently playing song doesn't sync across devices like Spotify does.

2
ToddBradley•

Do you mean that you can't play a song on multiple devices at once?

Or do you mean that you can't "move" a song from one device to another and have it keep its place?

2
AofwaOP•

Yeah sorry that was unclear.

The songs sync across my Homepods and play simultaneously.

It's just that when I select music on my iPhone with Apple Music, my iPad's instance of Apple Music doesn't seem to have an awareness of the currently playing song/playlists that were selected on my iPhone.

1
ToddBradley•

Ah, now I understand. Yeah, I don't know of a way to do that. You can see what's playing on other devices that make up the Home, like an Apple TV or a HomePod. But other non-Home devices seem invisible to each other in this way. I have no idea why that is.

1
pheare_me•

For Apple Music Play the song from the HomePod itself (do not airplay from phone to HomePod).

This is the big advantage of Apple Music over Spotify when it comes to HomePods. Spotify must be air played.

Might help with the spotty playback as well, as you take your phone out of the equation.

When playing like this, what is playing should show up on the Lock Screen of all your devices.

I never airplay, so not sure if it should also show on all devices when air playing.

1
civilengineer4•

Wdym? Apple Music I can play easily on multiple HomePods… I use to use Spotify but Apple Music has been so much better…

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
AofwaOP•

With Spotify I can navigate to the currently playing song regardless of what device I am on. I can switch from my phone to my ipad to my computer and change the song.

With Apple Music it doesn't seem to have an awareness of the currently playing song across devices. So if I start playing music on my iPad in another room I would need to go back to that room to change the song. With Spotify I could just whip my phone out and change it.

I could be wrong about Apple Music, I just didnt see that feature.

0
civilengineer4•

Hmm that’s weird. When I use Apple Music on my phone the currently playing shows on the lock screen of my iPad and on my watch as well as my gf phone when she’s on my wifi.

1